Last Saturday afternoon, Francisco Cervelli stood at his locker with his toes pointed inward, arms parallel to the ground, thumbs pointed out. Then he flipped: thumbs in, toes out. When Cervelli begins to return from concussions, or head trauma events that cause concussion symptoms, this is the beginning of the road back.

“They look [like] stupid exercises,” Cervelli said, “but they just help you to get back on track.”

Later that night, Cervelli would leave the game because of yet another foul ball off his mask.

This season is the second in a row that a concussion resulting from one or more foul balls off the mask has troubled Cervelli, the Pirates’ 32-year-old catcher. As Cervelli continues to get dinged, it has changed the way the Pirates think about their roster construction for 2019, the final year of Cervelli’s contract, assistant general manager Kevan Graves said.

Advertise with us

“As we look forward to next year, is there an opportunity to complement the roster with a player who has the ability to slide behind the plate if necessary?” Graves said on the KDKA-FM 93.7 pregame show last weekend. “Certainly something that we’ve talked about.”

Cervelli has vowed to study whatever preventative measures he can find this offseason, but the risk remains as long as he stays behind the plate. The Pirates’ dugout monitors Cervelli (and all players) after a situation that did, or could have, involved head trauma.

“We are comfortable that he is in a good place with respect to long-term health,” Graves said. “We have no interest in threatening his longer-term health, nor does he.”

“They know,” Cervelli said. “They see you every day and they know the way you are. If they see something different, they notice. The best thing is, be honest, because it’s not a leg or a arm or something. It’s real.”

The training staff pairs its knowledge of Cervelli’s usual demeanor with a standard series of assessments. If an on-field evaluation after a collision, hit-by-pitch or foul ball off the mask convinces the training staff that a concussion could have occurred, they remove the player and begin the third edition of the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool (SCAT3).

Advertise with us

“It’s more just, follow the finger to your eyes, they check your eyes, they check your mouth, your balance, test to remember some things,” Cervelli said. “Numbers, words, months backward and things like that.”

The SCAT3 requires the training staff to evaluate eye, verbal and motor response; ascertain a “Maddocks Score” by asking questions about the game (“What stadium are we in today? What inning is it right now? Who scored last?”); rank a series of symptoms on a scale of zero to six; and quiz the player on dates.

Once a concussion is diagnosed, the healing of the brain does not follow a linear path. They differ in each individual and in severity.

“You had to for sure kind of pace it,” said Colin Moran, who was diagnosed with a concussion as well as a fractured orbital bone when he fouled a ball off his face last year. “You can’t just go right into it altogether, it wasn’t like, all right, jump into a game. It was slowly built up. They just make sure to ask you how you’re doing. The questions were like, did you get any dizziness, did you feel mentally off at all?”

Moran said he felt no clear distinction between symptoms of a possible concussion and side effects of a broken bone in his face. He faced different limitations. He could not brace his body while, say, performing a deadlift, or blood would ooze out of his wound.

Advertise with us

“I didn’t do anything for four weeks, so if I did have a concussion, it got out of there,” he said.

Concussion symptoms can surface days after the blow to the head, which is why the Pirates track them. They caught the post-concussive symptoms that returned Cervelli to the DL in July on one of those morning examinations after he took more foul balls off his mask. Recovery is a deliberate process. When Cervelli is cleared for activity, he does mental exercises as well as physical.

“I do balance, I do exercise with my eyes,” he said. “I try to do exercises with memory, coordinate things, and of course the daily training is going to help you, too.”

Cervelli returned to play both games of the series against the Twins in Minnesota this week and the Pirates felt confident enough in his health to send Jacob Stallings down Thursday and bring back Jordan Luplow. Cervelli entered the four-game series against the Chicago Cubs with a .382 on-base percentage, a .460 slugging percentage and a career-high 11 home runs. The Pirates want him on the field as much as possible this year and next but must protect themselves if they don’t have him.

Elias Diaz gives the Pirates an excellent tandem behind the plate, and the Pirates can usually get Stallings from wherever Class AAA Indianapolis is playing to wherever they are, but as Graves alluded to, they could consider more flexibility. The San Francisco Giants move Buster Posey from behind the plate to first base at times, keeping his bat in the lineup while reducing the risk he faces. The issue becomes, most players who can catch also play a corner position, where, for next year at least, the Pirates have regular players — Josh Bell, Colin Moran, Corey Dickerson and Gregory Polanco.

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.

Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.