A couple springs ago, Pirates manager Clint Hurdle mentioned off-hand during a post-workout media briefing in February how he and the Pirates had been studying the playing time of the Golden State Warriors, who at the time were getting more production from their starters in fewer minutes. What followed was more of a commitment to attempting to keep players fresh (they had done some of that before) and being proactive with days off, with the help of Zephyr bio-harness exertion and fatigue data, rather than reactive.

Hurdle and the Pirates continue to do this — with an emphasis on recovery, which they attempt to quantify numerous ways. The process irks some fans, if Twitter and emails are any indication. Day-game-after-night-game lineups create even more rancor; among some, “Golden State” turned into a pejorative.

So let’s use Hurdle’s response Thursday morning to a question about Francisco Cervelli being out of the lineup after three hits Wednesday, and Max Moroff being in the lineup after a walk-off hit, as an updated illustration of why the Pirates do what they do — not in support for or against the policy, but merely an explanation.

So then you’re going to be completely reactive to production. Which I think is one of the traps that can happen in this game.

Advertise with us

It’s a day game following a night game, and it’s a 10-inning game, and the volume of games [Cervelli’s] caught and the number of pitches he's caught, today, the day he needs to take a break.

Max, actually the lineup was put together yesterday. I didn’t know he was going to hit a walk-off. We had him in the lineup yesterday.

I do get a lot of feedback from time to time. ‘Guy’s hot, you’ve got to keep playing him.’ The old-school train of thought is you play them until they go 0 for 20 and then you give them a day off in front of a day off. So you let them be hot and then stink for a while and then you show your intelligence and get them out of the lineup and give them a rest.

Just with the information that’s out there now, the studies we do, the players are, truthfully, buying into it as well. Because it’s not easy to tell somebody that I'm fatigued. And it’s not just, they’re going to tell you they’re fatigued when they’re not playing well. Sometimes it works the opposite. So you just need to be transparent, you need to really be selfless, all of us, do what’s best for the club, not care about external noise, when people say, how can you not play so-and-so and take him out?

You know what, I believe sometimes I have more information than you do. And truthfully, there’s a lot of things that happen in here that you have no idea about, how you need to take care of guys and give them a day here or do something there.

Advertise with us

There’s a lot that goes into putting the lineup together. That’s why we first attack it in the afternoon. We’ll spend about 10 minutes on it, and then we’ll revisit it after the game in case somebody got dinged up or something happened in a game that, we've got to make an adjustment. It’s not just setting it after the game. We do it a day early. I don’t ever come the park and make a lineup out that day. Players know when they go home who’s playing and who’s not playing. And I do believe that builds up some trust throughout the clubhouse.

Lineups, Brewers vs. Pirates, 12:35 p.m.

Brewers

1. Jonathan Villar (S) 2B

2. Domingo Santana RF

Advertise with us

3. Jesus Aguilar 1B

4. Travis Shaw (L) 3B

5. Hernan Perez LF

6. Manny Pina C

7. Brett Phillips (L) CF

Advertise with us

8. Orlando Arcia SS

9. Jimmy Nelson RHP

Pirates

1. Starling Marte CF

2. Josh Harrison 3B

Advertise with us

3. Andrew McCutchen CF

4. Josh Bell (S) 1B

5. Gregory Polanco (L) RF

6. Adam Frazier (L) 2B

7. Max Moroff (S) SS

Advertise with us

8. Chris Stewart C

9. Jameson Taillon RHP

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com