Welcome back, baseball fans. There is reason for optimism. The surging Pirates get Starling Marte back tonight from his 80-game steroid suspension. There also are many concerns remaining with 69 games to go this season. All questions are sic’d. If you have a question for next week’s mailbag, send it to snesbitt@post-gazette.com or to @stephenjnesbitt on Twitter.
Here we go.
Brian: will cutch get to 3,000 hits?
Stephen: This is fine and fair question, Brian, and my guess would be “no.”
Andrew McCutchen’s RBI single Sunday was his 1,400th career hit, and another single Monday brought him 99 hits from the halfway point in his question for 3,000. McCutchen is 30. He’ll turn 31 in October. He’d like to play many more seasons in the majors, but he’d have to turn in almost another decade of career-average seasons to join the 3,000-hit club, population 30 players.
It is possible. It is not probable.
Read More
Pull out your calculator. Let’s do some math.
McCutchen has averaged 177 hits per 162 games in his career. One plus is he’s never hit the disabled list, playing in 95.6 percent of regular-season Pirates games since his debut. Still, he averages 154 games per season, not 162, which drop our number to 168 hits per season.
Conveniently, McCutchen is on target for exactly 168.9677 hits this season.
At the end of 2017, then, he should have 1,473 career hits.
Keep going …
2018: 1,641
2019: 1,809
2020: 1,977
2021: 2,145
2022: 2,313
2023: 2,481
2024: 2,649
2025: 2,817
2026: 2,985
What agony that would be — McCutchen entering the 2026 offseason, turning 40, with 15 hits to go to reach 3,000. Assume he continues, right on pace. He’ll hit No. 3,000 in his 14th game of the 2027 season. At 40, he will be a no-doubt Hall of Famer. And there will be much rejoicing.
But.
Those extremely elementary calculations don’t factor in all the likelihoods of a superstar’s decline as he ages. What if McCutchen’s production drops? What if he is forced to go on the disabled list? What if he gets suspended? What if baseball gets locked out? What if, gasp, McCutchen is not longer an everyday player and instead serves as a power bat off the bench? Each would delay the projected date of his 3,000th base knock.
Wait, watch and ask again in 2022.
Steve: Does management really expect the fan base to believe that this upcoming Brewers series has any bearing on their trade deadline plans?
It sounds like they want you to come on out and enjoy the ballgames.
Brandon: This has to be one of the dumbest trade predictions this year right? [Brandon linked to a USA Today piece in which Bob Nightengale writes, “Prediction: [Dodgers GM Andrew] Friedman goes massive, and acquires Pittsburgh Pirates left-handed stud Felipe Rivero for, yes, top outfield prospect Alex Verdugo, and perhaps expands the package by including Willie Calhoun and Yadier Alvarez, too.”]
Stephen: I’ve seen dumber. But I have no reason to believe the Pirates are interested in trading Felipe Rivero, or the Dodgers want to trade a potential future star outfielder for a relief pitcher. Rivero would bolster their bullpen beside closer Kenley Jansen, yes, yet they’d have to give up several promising prospects to get someone to pitch in relief. I would file this under “interesting but incredibly unlikely” in the trade-deadline-rumors folder.
Toni: Any truth to the rumor the #Pirates are in on JA Happ if they're buyers?
Stephen: I have heard nothing concrete regarding the Pirates’ interest in J.A. Happ. If the Pirates decide to buy, adding a veteran starting pitcher would be a big step in that direction. Happ worked wonders once as a trade-deadline get. Why not again? Ken Rosenthal, however, said the Blue Jays are “highly unlikely” to trade Happ, as they intend to compete in 2018.
Ron: Would the Pirates possibly be interested in Mikail Franco who the Phillies are unhappy with? If so, what would it possibly take?
Stephen: They could possibly be interested, sure, but I don’t see it happening. Maikel Franco posted a .733 OPS last season and has a .669 OPS this season. The Phillies will surely expect to get something good in return or him, since he’s under club control for several more years. If you’re the Phillies, you can sell low on him, try to get someone to overpay or hold onto him. I don’t expect the Pirates would be interested in shipping prospects for a player clearly struggling.
Tom: Josh Harrison, utility player...is his baseball home getting ready to make an All-Star out of U-haul? Could J Hay Move Away?
Stephen: The Boston Red Sox beat writers who visited his locker at the All-Star Game clearly think Harrison could be a fit at the hot corner at Fenway Park. There are, however, several other (perhaps more likely) options — Todd Frazier, Martin Prado, Mike Moustakas, Eduardo Nunez.
Franco too.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.