With MLB’s July 31 trade deadline approaching, it’s not surprising to see Pirates such as outfielder Andrew McCutchen, starter Gerrit Cole and reliever Tony Watson pop up in trade speculation. All of them are coming to the ends of their respective contracts within the next couple of years, so it’s natural that they’d be mentioned as candidates to be moved, the idea being the Pirates might want to get something for those players while they can rather than risk losing them for nothing in free agency.
Reliever/unofficial closer Felipe Rivero is not coming to the end of his deal. The Pirates have him under contractual control until 2022, and he’s been incredible out of the bullpen this season, posting a 0.74 ERA in almost 50 innings of work through Sunday. He’s exactly the kind of player one would expect them to want around for the long haul. And yet, USA Today’s Bob Nightengale predicted Monday that Rivero will end up with the Los Angeles Dodgers, writing:
Prediction: [Dodgers GM Andrew] Friedman goes massive, and acquires Pittsburgh Pirates left-handed stud Felipe Rivero for, yes, top outfield prospect Alex Verdugo, and perhaps expands the package by including Willie Calhoun and Yadier Alvarez, too. Verdugo could be a star, but Rivero is absolutely filthy, yielding a .088 batting average with only five hits in 17⅓ innings since his first save on June 10. He would provide the Dodgers with the nastiest right-left bullpen combination in baseball.
That would be great for the Dodgers. There are two big problems for the Pirates that make this highly speculative trade unlikely, however.
The first is obvious: It would leave a massive hole in a bullpen already in line to lose a lot with Watson and Juan Nicasio playing this season on expiring contracts and likely to chase bigger money elsewhere in free agency this offseason. Rivero can be an affordable cornerstone for a long time, and the Pirates lack clear options to replace him in that capacity.
The second problem is that there’s no obvious place for Verdugo in Pirates’ long-term picture. His Class AAA numbers are solid — he’s hitting .341/.412/.460 with the Oklahoma City Dodgers — and MLB.com ranks him as the No. 50 prospect in minor league baseball. That said, the Pirates already have Gregory Polanco and Starling Marte signed to long-term deals to play the corner outfield spots, while top prospect Austin Meadows — ranked No. 6 on that same prospects list — is the heir-apparent to McCutchen in center. Verdugo would certainly add to the Pirates’ depth and give them flexibility, but adding him at the cost of Rivero creates more urgent problems than it solves.
There’s always the possibility the Dodgers would be willing to vastly overpay for a reliever of Rivero’s caliber. They’re a big-market team that has a ton of resources and probably wouldn’t miss any one or two prospects too much. If they’re willing to blow Pirates GM Neal Huntington away, it’s likely he’d at least listen.
Read More
There’s no indication they’re at that point, though. For now, this is merely speculation, and questionable speculation at that.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.