Six paces from the dugout steps, Gerrit Cole clapped his right hand against his mitt, wearing the bulldog scowl of a pitcher incensed by the way his start was going and unaware worse was ahead. The San Francisco Giants had just pieced together a three-run rally in the fourth inning Friday night, coupling five consecutive two-out singles with an error by first baseman Josh Bell.
In the dugout, Cole and manager Clint Hurdle engaged in an animated exchange. It didn’t appear to achieve the desired result. The wheels had been loosened. They would fall off in the sixth, the inning in which the Giants chased Cole, bulldozed the bullpen and piled on five more runs.
San Francisco’s 13-5 runaway win in the series opener at PNC Park represented another missed chance for the Pirates (37-43) to pick up steam prior to the All-Star break. The Giants, despite a leadoff home run from Denard Span, who went 4 for 5 plus a walk and four runs scored, trailed by two runs after the first inning and didn’t surge in front until the fourth.
Cole, on the heels of three one-run starts, allowed seven runs, tying a season-high. He allowed 10 hits, walked two and struck out seven. After 17 starts this season, Cole has a 4.51 ERA. The spirited discussion with Hurdle, Cole revealed, came as Hurdle considered replacing Cole with a pinch-hitter in the bottom of the fourth, down two runs. He stayed in and struck out bunting.
Gerrit Cole discusses 12-5 defeat, conversation with Clint Hurdle
“Just trying to shave off as much work as you can from the bullpen,” Cole (6-7) explained after the game. “We were only down by two runs at that point. We were still in the ballgame.”
“It wouldn’t be the first [disagreement] we had,” Hurdle added. “A.J. [Burnett] and I used to have them every now and then. Just the direction the game was going.”
At 31-51, the Giants still own the second-worst record in the majors. They collected a season-high 18 hits to the Pirates’ 10. Hunter Pence had five RBIs, and Brandon Belt four. Right-hander Johnny Cueto tossed five innings of three-run ball, giving up seven hits and four walks.
Andrew McCutchen was 2 for 2 with a walk and a hit by pitch. He has reached base in eight consecutive plate appearances. McCutchen fouled a pitch off his left ankle in the seventh and fell to the ground in pain. He was visited by the team’s head athletic trainer, but got to his feet. He wears a shin protector because he’s been hit there before, but not recently.
“That one hurt, man,” McCutchen said.
Still, McCutchen stayed in the game and finished the at-bat with a sharp single over the shortstop. He was then lifted for a pinch-runner. Why stay in for one final swing?
“That’s my at-bat,” McCutchen said. “Nobody ain’t gonna take that from me.”
McCutchen batted .411 in June, bringing his season batting average to .283. He did not undergo an X-ray, but he said he’ll be good to go Saturday. On one condition: “If I can walk, I’m good,” McCutchen said, “and I’m walking right now.”
Andrew McCutchen on ankle injury, status for Saturday
The Pirates mounted an immediate response after Span’s leadoff homer. Adam Frazier and Josh Harrison singled, and McCutchen loaded the bases by walking. Bell’s ground ball nearly was a double play, but Cueto missed the bag as he covered first base. John Jaso struck a two-run double off the Clemente Wall, taking the lead, and Gregory Polanco added a sacrifice fly.
Recently, Hurdle has praised Bell, who converted from the outfield in the minors, for the strides he had made at first base. Earlier this month, Hurdle started to play Bell regularly for nine innings rather than rely on defensive replacements for the late innings.
In the second and third innings Friday, Bell showed both improvement and indecision. First, he laid out to snare a wild throw from Harrison, keeping his foot on the base to prevent a rally. Then, he miscommunicated with Cole on a Joe Panik dribbler and threw the ball away.
“That’s a play where there’s got to be immediate communication from somebody,” Hurdle said, adding once Bell picked up the ball, he needed to hold onto it.
The play was only one in a sea of singles, but this one seemed greater. Cole grabbed the ball by the grandstands and stewed, barking a few words at Bell or perhaps no one in particular. The Giants were in business. Pence hit an RBI single, stealing the lead. The next inning, he capped a two-out rally started by the Nos. 8 and 9 hitters by hitting a two-run single.
Left-hander Antonio Bastardo, making his first appearance for the Pirates since April 24, walked the only batter he faced. The runner belonging to Bastardo scored later in the inning, so Bastardo’s ERA in seven games this season is 17.55. Right-hander Jhan Marinez allowed three runs in an inning, and relievers Wade LeBlanc and Edgar Santana allowed a run apiece.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.