There is plenty of blame for the Pirates’ 20-win drop from 2015 to 2016.
The long list of underperforming players begins with five-time All-Star outfielder Andrew McCutchen, but nowhere else on the diamond did a position group decline as drastically as the starting pitchers.
For everything that went right in 2015, from right-hander A.J. Burnett’s first All-Star season to the J.A. Happ acquisition to Gerrit Cole and Francisco Liriano’s good health and effectiveness, little went right for the rotation the following year. Cole dealt with three separate injuries, Liriano and Jon Niese were moved at the trade deadline, and the Pirates used a total of 14 starting pitchers.
From one year to the next, the starting rotation’s ERA climbed from 3.53 to 4.76, its worst mark since the 2010 starters posted a 5.28 ERA. The opponent’s batting average, at .271, was fourth-highest in the majors. Despite a pitching philosophy predicated on generating ground balls, the staff’s ground-ball rate fell below 50 percent, to 47.6 percent, for the first time in four years.
No Pirates pitcher made more than 21 starts. None pitched more than 1271⁄3 innings. None had more than 138 strikeouts. The 2016 staff carried 102 fewer innings than the 2015 staff yet allowed 70 more runs. Strikeouts were down. Walks, homers and hard contract were up.
What impact did a wobbly rotation have?
Read More
“There is collateral damage that goes everywhere,” manager Clint Hurdle said at baseball’s winter meetings. “Number of pitches thrown, it actually leaks into the pace of game, the time of game. We spent more time on the field this year than any other time since maybe before ’13.”
At one point last season, Hurdle recalled, four of the Pirates’ five starters had ERAs over 5.00. The starters combined for five complete games yet averaged a hair over 51⁄3 innings per start. Their 8652⁄3 innings pitched were the fewest by a Pirates starting pitching staff since 1995.
“That makes it hard,” Hurdle said.
What now?
The good news last season came in the form of rookie right-hander Jameson Taillon, who after a midseason arrival had a 3.38 ERA over 18 starts, and veteran right-hander Ivan Nova. A trade-deadline acquisition, Nova was fantastic in 11 starts for the Pirates, posting a 3.06 ERA and 52 strikeouts to three walks. Unlike Happ, Nova re-signed with the Pirates in free agency.
On the surface, the Pirates starters look somewhat strong again. Cole, Taillon and Nova form the majority of the rotation, with right-hander Chad Kuhl likely to claim the No. 4 spot after making 14 starts with a 4.20 ERA last season. The fifth spot likely will go to left-hander Steven Brault or a right-hander, either Tyler Glasnow or Drew Hutchison, who was acquired in the Liriano trade.
But there is little room for error or injury.
The Pirates’ pitching depth was tested last season, and it provided a first chance for several prospects. They had four pitchers — Taillon, Glasnow, Kuhl and Brault — debut in starting roles, their most since 1903 when six rookies debuted as starters, according to Elias Sports Bureau.
While it wasn’t in pitching coach Ray Searage’s plans to use so many starters last season, getting the kids involved, to varying degrees, should aid their re-acclimation process this year. They figured a few things out, he believes. They worked with catchers. They faced major league hitters.
“That experience they got last year we’re just going to build on,” Searage said. “That’s basically the foundation of your house. That’s the cement pilings. We’re going to start putting the walls up, the roof, the whole nine yards.”
The construction plan calls for roughly 11 or 12 pitchers to be stretched during spring training and ready to start games, Searage said. That list will include all the regulars plus a few new ones, such as veteran left-hander Wade LeBlanc.
The fifth starter may not be a real surprise. Searage believes the right talent is within the Pirates’ ranks somewhere, and he is intrigued to see who will emerge in spring training.
Take Glasnow, for example, ranked by Baseball America as the Pirates’ No. 3 prospect. The kid looked a little rattled in the majors last season, a bit unprepared, but his stuff is golden. Searage has this vision for Glasnow that something is going to click this spring, and he’ll settle in.
“I think maybe about halfway through [camp], you guys are going to be going, ‘Holy Schnikes! What the …’ ” Searage said. “That’s all he’s got to do. No matter what happens, turn the page and work on the next hitter. That’s one of the biggest things with him, the maturity level.”
Who’s next?
The future, for the most part, is here. Taillon is a bonafide major leaguer, and Glasnow, Kuhl, Brault and Trevor Williams are not so far behind. The Pirates’ next top pitching prospect is right-hander Mitch Keller, ranked by Baseball America as the organization’s second-best prospect. Keller has pitched exactly one game above the Class A level, so he remains way down the road.
The Pirates have who they have. They also have a few others you may have forgotten.
Right-handers Casey Sadler, Brandon Cumpton and Angel Sanchez all had Tommy John surgery in 2015 and will be back in spring training, working at a slightly different pace than the rest, according to general manager Neal Huntington. Sadler and Cumpton have major league experience. Cumpton also had right shoulder subacromial decompression surgery in 2015.
Another interesting storyline is the return of right-hander Nick Kingham. The former fourth-round draft pick was nearly ready for the majors before he underwent Tommy John surgery in May 2015. After more than a year of rehab, he made 10 starts in the low minors late last season.
Kingham could be on a similar track to Taillon, with whom he lived and trained this offseason in Houston. Huntington said earlier this offseason that he expects Kingham, who has a 3.32 ERA over parts of seven seasons in the minors, will play a role for the Pirates at some point his season.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.