The way baseball works, and particularly the way the Pirates prefer to run things, spring-training position battles tend to take place on the peripheries of the roster. Since most of their regulars around the diamond signed contract extensions in years past, the Pirates have a starting nine mostly set. Changes to everyday roles more often come once the regular season has commenced.
But that’s not always the case. Last year, for instance, right-hander Juan Nicasio seized a starting job with a spectacular spring-training performance, forcing veteran right-hander Ryan Vogelsong to the bullpen. And some spots in the bullpen and on the bench are decided at camp.
The Pirates used a club-record 55 players last season, so hazarding a guess at their 25-man opening day roster is tricky. The roster will turn over, solidify, and turn over again. But let’s try.
No. 5 starter
For the Pirates to return to their 2015 form, they’ll need their top three starters — right-handers Gerrit Cole, Jameson Taillon and Ivan Nova — healthy and productive. If even one is on the shelf for a lengthy period of time, the starting rotation could be in serious trouble. The presumptive No. 4 starter is right-hander Chad Kuhl, who posted a 4.20 ERA in 14 starts as a rookie last season. Kuhl may not have a stranglehold on that spot, but he probably has earned the chance to start his sophomore season in the rotation. The Pirates let left-hander Jeff Locke walk, Vogelsong left in free agency, and they did not reinforce the starting-pitching depth with proven veterans beyond Nova. The primary options for No. 5 starter are left-hander Steven Brault and right-handers Drew Hutchison and Tyler Glasnow. Hutchison, acquired in a trade for left-hander Francisco Liriano and two prospects last summer, has a 4.93 ERA over parts of four seasons in the majors. His big-league numbers are decidedly underwhelming, but he has some experience and he’ll make $2.3 million. Brault, an under-the-radar prospect, made seven starts for the Pirates last season and had a 4.86 ERA. He represents the lone left-hander in the rotation battle, unless veteran Wade LeBlanc gets a real look there. The best-case scenario for the Pirates probably would be Glasnow, ranked by Baseball America as the organization’s No. 3 prospect, pulls away in the chase for No. 5. Glasnow, 23, was the youngest of the 55 Pirates last season. He’s too good for Class AAA, but is he ready for an extended shot in the majors?
Lefty relief
Read More
The back end of the Pirates’ bullpen is pretty well established. Tony Watson will close, with left-hander Felipe Rivero and right-hander Daniel Hudson gobbling up high-leverage spots in front of him. The day could come when Rivero usurps the closer’s role from Watson, who is in his final year under contract, but for now their roles are static. Right-handers Juan Nicasio, A.J. Schugel and Jared Hughes are all back, too, though there may not be room for all three at once. The real problem, however, is with the Pirates’ glut of left-handers. Beyond Watson and Rivero there are Antonio Bastardo, Tyler Webb and LeBlanc. Bastardo will make $6.5 million this season, while LeBlanc avoided arbitration by signing for $800,000 plus a club option for 2018. Webb, by virtue of being taken in the Rule 5 draft, seems likely to make the opening-day roster so long as spring training goes smoothly. If the Pirates drop the promising left-hander from their roster, they would have to offer him back to the New York Yankees or negotiate a trade. Unless Bastardo is traded before April, LeBlanc appears to be the odd man out in the bullpen.
Hanson’s big chance?
Perhaps this is the season Alen Hanson finally catches on with the Pirates. Blessed with elite speed, Hanson, 24, was rated as one of Baseball America’s top-100 prospects in 2013 and 2014. Now he’s out of minor-league options, and that could be what gets him on the roster this year. It’s hard to part with a switch-hitter who has some extra-base power, can hit for decent average and stole 35 and 36 bases the past two seasons. But Hanson’s offense stagnated once he reached Class AAA Indianapolis in 2015 — his OPS in two seasons there was .704. Friday, the Pirates traded for infielder Phil Gosselin, who has a .716 OPS in 501 major league plate appearances. Gosselin, 27, doesn’t have Hanson’s speed, but he is a capable defender who has played first base, second base, third base, shortstop, left field and right field in the majors. Hanson, a former shortstop, has played second, third and left field, but his defense is suspect. Hanson was 7 for 31 in 27 games for the Pirates last season. With Matt Joyce gone, the Pirates’ fourth outfielder is Adam Frazier, who is also their primary utility player. So the last man on the bench will need to be a reliable substitute for Frazier, able to play multiple positions and handle the bat.
LEFT: Alen Hanson had seven hits in 33 plate appearances with the Pirates in 2016.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.