I’m not sure we can quantify the depth of the Pirates’ dumpster dive last season. But we can try.
They used a franchise-record 55 players, including a franchise-record 32 pitchers, and saw their win total drop by 20 from 2015. That would have been a franchise record, too, if not for the 1993 team, which posted a 21-win drop and inadvertently launched a 20-year losing streak.
So while questions abound every year in Bradenton — and every other spring training site across the majors — this year seems especially provocative. And troublesome.
One could list 25 critical inquiries, topped, of course, by this one: Who was the Pirates’ most anonymous offseason pickup — Pat Light, Joey Terdoslavich, Nefi Ogando, Dan Runzler or Josh Lindblom?
For the sake of brevity, I’ll whittle my list of critical questions to five, in descending order of importance …
5. Will Gregory Polanco make the leap to stardom, or at least to consistency? One of the underplayed stories of 2016 was Polanco’s season slowly disintegrating over the final three months.
Read More
4. Will Josh Bell take to first base? His plate discipline is excellent. His power and defense are questionable.
“I envision him giving us some stability at first base, which has been a transient position for us,” manager Clint Hurdle told 93.7 The Fan. “I think since I’ve been here, we’ve had a different first baseman Opening Day every year.”
That is true, and the answer to the trivia question goes like this: Lyle Overbay, Garrett Jones, Gaby Sanchez, Travis Ishikawa (they’ll never get that one), Pedro Alvarez and John Jaso.
3. Will Andrew McCutchen regain his MVP stature from his new perch in right field?
“He’s in a good place,” Hurdle said.
I wonder about that, considering the Pirates looked into trading McCutchen and probably wouldn’t hesitate to do so again if they’re out of contention near the trade deadline (or maybe even if they’re in contention).
2. Will Jung-Ho Kang stabilize his life to the point where he can fulfill his potential?
“The young man’s made some decisions that have put him in a challenging situation,” Hurdle said. “He’s going to have every opportunity to have a comeback personally and a comeback professionally.”
1. Did Neal Huntington do enough to fix the rotation?
We can talk all we want about every other position — I didn’t even mention Tony Watson in the closer role — but it starts here. Nothing happens without a quality rotation.
Is starting pitching as important as it used to be, given the proliferation of talent-packed bullpens? Maybe not. But that question sent me on a mission revolving around an old-school stat.
I wondered: How often does a team finishing in the top five in starters’ earned-run average make the playoffs?
Short answer: All the time.
Over the past two years in the National League, the number is 10 for 10. It’s 22 of 25 over the past five years, or since the second wild card was added.
Go back to the beginning of the century, and the figure is 54 of 73, good for a Joey Terdoslavich-like batting average of .740.
Most of the playoff teams not in the top five in starters’ ERA were just outside of it. Nearly all in the bottom five had no chance. You have to go back 10 years to find an NL team that overcame a truly bad rotation. The 2007 Phillies finished 12th in starters’ ERA but made up for it with a league-leading offense before getting swept by Hurdle’s Colorado Rockies in the NLDS (more trivia: Josh Fogg was your Game 2 winner).
The Pirates finished 11th last season with a 4.67 starters’ ERA. They were the victims of bad luck (injuries) and too much hubris (we can heal anyone, so bring us your Jeff Lockes, your Jon Nieses, your Ryan Vogelsongs and Juan Nicasios).
At the very least, a rotation has to be an adequate bridge to the bullpen.
Did Huntington do enough? It doesn’t look that way from here. Looks to me like he still needs to add a major piece (Jose Quintana, anyone?) if the Pirates are going to have any hope of hanging with the Cubs.
That is the idea, right?
The man who could change everything is Tyler Glasnow, who has boom-or-bust-and-little-in-between written all over him. It seems likely Glasnow will start at Triple-A. If he returns and gives the Pirates something approaching what Gerrit Cole gave them as a rookie, or what Jameson Taillon gave them last season, the landscape shifts.
In the meantime, chalk up the 6-foot-8 Glasnow as the tallest question mark in a spring training brimming with them.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.cvom and on Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 the Fan.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.