Guest: Is it just me or does newcomer Jason Rogers look just like Kenan Thompson from SNL?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Rogers doesn't not look like Thompson, in that both are stocky African-American gentlemen. But I don't think I've seen Thompson with a beard save for his few appearances as Big Papi on Saturday Night Live. And Thompson also is about 10 years older than Rogers.
Guest: Stephen, I've always liked your writing and thought your work had a distinct European flavor and was then not surprised to find out that you are French. Anyway, do you think Jason Rogers can be an every day contributor or at least a platoon player for the Pirates? Thanks
Stephen J. Nesbitt: This, to me, is a compelling comment, but I'll skip right to the Rogers question. When I wrote this story in spring training about Rogers being Cam Newton's high-school football rival, my twin brother rang me and said, "Rogers will be the Pirates' starting first baseman by the All-Star break." He's sticking to that, too. The way John Jaso has hit, he'll be in the lineup most days. But, given that Rogers has more experience at first than David Freese, sure, there's a chance Rogers could end up getting more platoon starts than Freese.
BlogCog: Stephen my friend, long time no chat - how've you been??
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Been well, my friend. Welcome back.
Read More
BlogCog: First, why isn't the media holding Nutting and his cheapness accountable for him basically doing nothing the whole offseason. I'm sorry but he is a real cheapskate and if we had an owner that would invest just a little more on the team the past 3 seasons, I think we would have already gotten to a world series. Do you agree??
Stephen J. Nesbitt: As much as fans would like media trying to dive into Bob Nutting's pocket book to discover exactly how many pennies he has to spend on this team, there's a time and a place for such things, and it is neither today nor here. The Pirates don't have the lowest payroll in baseball. They continue to win, and they do it in their own, small-market way. They are one of the smartest organizations in the game. They get more out of a $100 million payroll than some teams get with two times that. And, no, I don't think it's as simple as saying another 10 or 20 million would have gotten the Pirates past Madison Bumgarner and Jake Arrieta these past couple years.
Guest: ANy chance Hurdle sits Cutch again tonight to give him more time to think about what he's doing to hurt the team when he bats so poorly?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Andrew McCutchen, who is 3 for 23 this road trip, will start tonight. He has a good split against left-hander Jorge De La Rosa, hitting a .316 average with two doubles, a triple and four walks against him in 19 at-bats.
Guest: Nesbitt, your chat is moving very slowly today. What gives?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: The wifi here at Thump Coffee in Denver is rather sluggish.
Guest: Was Locke good last night or did he just figure out how to be not completely inaccurate within a really wide strike zone?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: As I broke down in the game story, Locke pitched well, but a big key to his success was going back to the well again and again, expanding the strike zone after the home-plate umpire made it clear he'd call just about anything a strike. Locke wanted to work low in the zone. Once Lance Barrett began calling strikes below the knees, then well off the plate, Locke knew he had no need to test things up in the zone. He played his hand well, and it paid off in six scoreless innings. Credit Locke for being up to the task at Coors Field, and credit he and Francisco Cervelli for calling a good game, given Barrett's friendly zone.
Mark: Despite last night, I just don't see Locke and Nicasio as legitimate starters on a playoff team. When will Tailon be brought up?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: The Pirates won't rush Jameson Taillon. He looks pretty close to ready for the majors, but he needs to build up an innings load in the minors and show he can be counted on to take the ball every fifth day. That said, he certainly could be due for a call-up in the early half of the summer.
Guest: Cutch is hitting poorly, Polanco is hitting well with a new team-friendly contract. marte is solid as ever and the minor league farm system is strong. is it time to look to trade Cutch while his value is still high? I'm thinking we could get pitchers in return
Stephen J. Nesbitt: This — pardon my French — would be stupid. First, the Pirates don't have an outfielder ready to jump into an everyday starting role. Unless you'd like Matt Joyce or Sean Rodriguez giving it a go every day. And have you forgotten watch McCutchen did last year? This is another slow start, sure, but he was one of the best hitters in baseball from about May 8 on last season.
Guest: Where you ever a reporter for the Indy Star? I seem to recall you. If so , did you enjoy your time in indy or scout the pirates triple a team here?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: I wrote for the Star in 2013, the summer before joining the Post-Gazette full-time. I covered a handful of Indians games there. The most memorable was the day Gerrit Cole was called up to Pittsburgh. I wrote a story for the Post-Gazette off the event, but couldn't get Cole for an interview because he left in the middle of the Indians game, which went something like 12 innings before Andrew Lambo hit a walk-off home run off a position player.
Is it way too earl...: How can the Pirates keep Sean Rodriguez bat in the lineup while he is hitting well? It seams like this is going to get much harder once Jung-ho Kang comes off the DL. Do you think this year could be similar for Sean compared to Harrison when he actually got to stay in the lineup on a daily basis?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Did you somehow drop a question into your name, and then drop another question into the hopper? I'm not even mad — that's amazing!
Stephen J. Nesbitt: To your name: It is pretty early to evaluate the bullpen, particularly because they've all only had a handful of outings and also because of injuries to Jared Hughes and Cory Luebke. But the early signs certainly have been troubling. It's not just one or two guys who got beaten up this past week, but just about everyone. The sample size still is very small, and I'd expect the bullpen to improve markedly as we escape the first month of the season.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: To your question: There's a chance Rodriguez hits his way into the lineup just about every day, hopping positions to give guys days off, the way Harrison did. That's the role the Pirates envisioned for Rodriguez when they re-signed him to a one-year deal this year. Once Kang returns, he'll need plenty of days off to re-acclimate to the major-league game. So, should be plenty of chances for Rodriguez.
BlogCog: This whole JA Happ thing, c;mon there is no way Nutting made a competitive offer to the guy. My question is why? He was great for us and with AJ retiring, keeping bad Jeff Locke and getting rid of Morton - Happ would have been a great addition. Am I right on this?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: There were very few teams interested in giving J.A. Happ $12 million per year this offseason. The Pirates were not going to give him that money, nearly the amount they pay McCutchen and Liriano. Yes, the Pirates had players leave and money freed up this offseason, but if you actually break down where it went — most was spent on the large number of arbitration guys they had this year. They had some money for free agency, and they spent a bit, but they weren't going to surprise anybody and pay Happ like they're paying Liriano.
guest: Hi Stephen I asked you this on Twitter the other night but you never replied. If the pirates ran into a situation like Arizona had Sunday, which pitcher would take the field and at what position? Maybe you don't know
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Well, it's got to be a starting pitcher, because everybody left in the bullpen could potentially be brought in to pitch. I wouldn't have been shocked had Niese stayed in the game and played first base. At that point, Sean Rodriguez was playing first, if I recall correctly, so he could have been moved anywhere to make room for Niese.
Guest: Stephen, I know a lot of folks may not think youre qualified to cover baseball just cuz you are french. I disagree and think you do an awesome job! Are the cubs a legit threat to win the world series this year or is that bs?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: I did not know they said that about me. The Cubs, I'm afraid, are legit.
Guest: Stephen, you talk about your French heritage a lot in these chats and it is very interesting. How have you found your time in America so far? Is it all that different from Europe? How did you first learn about baseball?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: If we were to make a pie chart of my life, less than a third of the slices would represent time spent in France. So, America has been good to me, and I know it far better than I knew France as a boy. But, certainly, life there is different from life here. We lived in a rather remote region of France, when we lived there, and now I live in the hustle and bustle of Pittsburgh proper. My father grew up near Detroit and is a diehard Tigers fan. He taught us baseball very young, and we grew up playing Wiffle ball in the backyard. We began playing organized baseball in the mid-1990s at S.H.A.P.E, a NATO base in Mons, Belgium, and things took off from there.
BlogCog: Isn't it time to trade McCutchen after the season Stephen? I mean look, the guy will be leaving anyways in a couple of years and in my opinion he really does nothing late in the year and the playoffs. Add to that he now struggles early in the season as well. 3-4 months out of 6 plus being a playoff bust doesn't seem to justify keeping him here and getting nothing when he leaves anyways in 2 years. What do you think?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: I heartily disagree with just about everything you said here. He has a .321 postseason batting average, for one.
Guest: Do you have a favorite ballpark besides PNC?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Dodger Stadium, I think.
Guest: SLow start for Cutch - reasons to be concerned or just one of those things? I think cutch is awesome and i hope he starts hitting soon. he is a top player in this league and i believe will be assuming he overcomes this current slump
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Sure, there's reason for concern whenever he, like any player, looks rather lost at the plate. But given McCutchen's track record, there are many, many reasons to trust he'll bounce back after April.
Strikes Joey: What do you make of Neil Walker's power explosion in New York? Is it just the fact that he's playing for his one chance at a huge payday?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Fun to watch, isn't it? Walker is in a contract year, and if he continues hitting like this he'll get some serious money this offseason. Good for him. The Pirates made their decision to part ways in December, and they're doing just fine filling in for him at second base, but his power won't easily be replaced.
Guest: I know the bucs have guest instructors in in the spring to help with fielding, hitting, etc. Has the team ever looked into bringing Tony Gwynn in in this capacity? He was a tremendous hitter and i was a fan. THnak you
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Tony Gwynn died two summers ago, so, no.
BlogCog: He does not have a .321 postseason batting avg. He has .270 avg roughly with all useless singles. No RBI's in 28 at bat's and only 1 extra base hit.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: According to many laws of mathematics, McCutchen's 9-for-28 batting line does indeed entitle him to a .321 postseason batting average.
Guest: Who goes down when Hughes comes up?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Rob Scahill looks most likely lately.
BlogCog: Actually you are right about the .321 avg, sorry
Steve: On a scale of 1-10, how worried are you about the bullpen? With Hughes coming back, do you believe that will get the bullpen closer to where they were last year?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Two. It is April 26. Yes, Hughes' return should help buoy the bullpen.
BlogCog: Look at our awful bullpen Stephen. How could Bob Nutting not spend some money to keep some of last years guys like Blanton or Soria or Bastardo? Yes they kept Melancon but the rest are all minor league scrubs. Why didn't Nutting give NH more authority to sign some actual major league talent in the pen?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Can we talk for a second about middle relievers? Small-market teams — shoot, some large-market squads, too — don't pay for middle relief. You find guys to fill in there. You don't spend your free-agent money there. Joakim Soria is a back-end reliever the Pirates paid last year to bolster an already terrific 'pen. He was always going to go elsewhere in free agency and make back-end money. He got 3/$25M. Bastardo got 2/$12M. Blanton got 1/$4M. The Pirates got Ryan Vogelsong for $2 million. They weren't going to pay up for middle relief this year.
Guest: When your were growing up were the Expos popular in france due to their being in Montreal which is heavily french speaking. thank you for your time
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Not that I was aware. Thank you, too, for your time.
Guest: NEsbitt, I did not know you are a twin. HAs that been interesting way to grow up and did you ever think of rooting for the MN Twins?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: It has been a very interesting way to grow up, and very fun. I'm staying at my brother's place in Denver this week, in fact. I was never a Twins fan. My dad did have a Twins hat given to him, I believe, when we were born.
BlogCog: yeah I said I was mistaken for that but still, 0 RBI's doesn't do it for me from our "superstar", sorry.
BlogCog: More McCutchen stats for you to ponder Stephen - in his mvp year of 2013 his WAR was 8.2
BlogCog: Also, as you may know, I mainly root for the Braves, but live in Pittsburgh. I wish the NL would adopt the DH. Do you think it may happen?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: or a Braves fan, your Pirates takes are blistering and brave.
BlogCog: Did anyone expect Jaso to be so great thus far with us? That came out of nowhere huh? Same with Joyce. I kinda wish we could get Joyce ino the starting lineup more - if Cutch continues to struggle will Hurdle start sitting him more?
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Lately, Hurdle has emphasized that he wants to rest guys not only when they're doing poorly. So, he schedules off days no matter how well the guy is doing — he joked that he thought he'd sat Joe DiMaggio the way fans and media reacted when John Jaso sat last week. But if McCutchen slumps terribly, sure, he'll get some days off to work on things. So far, it's not reached that point. With Starling Marte and Gregory Polanco swinging pretty well, it hasn't left many chances for Joyce to start.
BlogCog: 2 years ago his WAR was 6.4 and last year it was 4.8. Look at his start for this season, yikes. I say trade him in the offseason.
BlogCog: Stephen that wasn't me about the Braves. I don't root for the Braves at all. I am a native Pittsburgher and root only for the Pirates, hence all the Pirates questions.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Apologies for questioning your allegiance.
Strikes Joey: But Stephen, another $10 million or so, spent on something like keeping Volquez, would have meant they wouldn't have needed to beat Arrietta in that one-and-done game. $10 to $20 million would have been the difference between a division title and a wild card. And then this team could well have gone on that World Series run.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: A fair point. Look, we can sit here all day wringing our hands about what the Pirates could do with a payroll of $120 million, $150 million, $200 million. But that's not what they've got, and it ain't gonna change this year, so if you would like to dream of ways to spend a few tens of millions extra, do as you please.
BlogCog: Tell StrikesJoey that is my point exactly.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Hey, StrikesJoey, that's his point exactly.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: Bye everyone.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.