Gerrit Cole knew he would have to be nearly perfect Wednesday night in the National League wild-card game at PNC Park, but he was nowhere close. Rather than match Chicago Cubs ace Jake Arrieta, who was spectacular in a 4-0 win, Cole lost the second elimination game of his career for the Pirates.
“It burns. It stings. … ,” Cole said afterward. “All the negative things you can come up with, that’s how it feels right now.”
It was a matchup a month in the making. Early in September, Pirates manager Clint Hurdle lined up Cole, a 19-game winner, to pitch the wild-card game on six days of rest. Arrieta, who went 22-6 with a 1.77 ERA, clearly was the Cubs’ pocket ace.
Wednesday, Cole’s parents and his fiancee, Amy, were in the stands at PNC Park. The baseball team at UCLA, Cole’s alma mater, gathered in its clubhouse to watch a former No. 1 overall pick make the biggest start of his young career.
But under the bright lights of baseball’s postseason Cole, a 25-year-old right-hander, was out of sync. He missed locations early and fell behind in counts. He allowed six hits and four runs over five innings, giving up two home runs in a start for just the second time this season.
“I just wasn’t good enough,” Cole said.
Read More
Dexter Fowler scored the first run of the game after taking advantage of Cole’s struggles holding runners. Fowler singled leading off the game, then, after a soft pick-off throw, swiped second to move into scoring position. Cole’s 25 steals against were fifth most in the majors this season.
Kyle Schwarber poked an RBI single to left, giving the Cubs a 1-0 lead before Arrieta even took the mound, then blasted a two-run homer over the right-field bleachers in the third.
Fowler hit a long solo shot to right-center field in the fifth to push the Cubs’ lead to 4-0.
“That first-inning run, those kind of things happen. So be it,” Cole said. “The mistakes later, with the two home runs, were tremendously unfortunate.”
By the time Arrieta was hit on the hip with a fastball in the seventh and both benches cleared, Cole’s only involvement was as a feisty fighter — he explained later he was trying to “diffuse the situation.” He yapped at the Cubs, his hair wild and eyes afire, but they would defeat him for just the second time in his career.
Cole entered the game 7-1 with a 2.88 ERA in nine career starts against the Cubs. The Pirates won his final five starts of the regular season, but none of that mattered in a do-or-die wild-card game. The six hits off Cole were all by left-handed batters. Fowler and Schwarber, the Nos. 1 and 2 hitters in the Cubs order, were a combined 5 for 6.
After the final out of the Pirates’ regular-season finale Sunday, when they clinched home field for the wild-card game, Cole clapped his hands and looked skyward.
“It comes down to the last game, it seems like, every year,” he said later. “We never find a way to take the simpler road to the postseason.”
The road reached a dead end Wednesday. The next time Cole will take the mound at PNC Park likely will be opening day, April 4, 2016, against the St. Louis Cardinals. That game will be important, too, only less so. This time, the Pirates could use a head start.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.