The World Series figures to end on the far side of Halloween this year, but this just in: There will be no Bucvember.

Which will make Bucvember only nominally shorter than Buctober.

Don’t you dare act surprised.

The last surprise of this otherwise enchanted baseball season arrived six hours ahead of Wednesday night’s first pitch – Sean Rodriguez, Pirates manager Clint Hurdle announced, would play first base in the National League wild card game instead of Pedro Alvarez.

Advertise with us

So on an issue that wasn’t even fully formed externally, Hurdle went neither this way or that way; he went data way.

Reasoning with the help of the cherished advanced metrics that Cubs starter Jake Arrieta threw very few fly balls, and that therefore attempting to slug against the Cy Young winner-in-waiting would not be as impactful as putting his best defensive lineup behind Gerrit Cole, Hurdle sent to the bench his leading homerun hitter and the Major League Baseball record holder for driving in at least one run in his first six post-season games.

What followed once the focus went from the lineup card to the ball field surprised no one, regardless of lineup, strategy, spray charts, two-strike approach, the phases of the moon, or the location of the pierogi truck.

Arrieta did exactly what the contours of the 2015 baseball season made clear weeks ago could very well happen the night Oct. 7. He did exactly what San Francisco’s Madison Bumgarner did to Clint Hurdle’s team a year ago this week – snuffed it like a candle – and it was a virtual statistical replay.

No runs on four hits last year. No runs on four hits last night. Pirate “hitters” managed one walk against 10 strikeouts last time, no walks and 11 strikeouts this time. In both games, rather than the defense playing no doubles, the offense played no doubles. Eight harmless singles over two Buctobers.

Advertise with us

So here’s your fresh morning serving of baseball trivia: What do the two largest crowds in PNC Park history have in common?

Neither saw a Pirate cross the plate.

“An old friend once told me about bull-riding that sometimes you draw a tough bull,” Hurdle said 15 minutes after a sour 4-0 surrender. “Two years in a row we’ve drawn a tough bull. We pushed a couple times late, squared a couple balls up – they turned them into doubleplays.

“Arrieta was ahead of almost every count through five.”

Yes, Arrieta was Arrieta.

Advertise with us

He was 11-0 with an 0.41 earned run average after Aug. 3. He was 11-0 with 1.08 ERA in his previous 14 road starts. Now he’s thrown 31 consecutive scoreless innings back to September. Now he’s the first guy ever to throw a post-season shutout that included at least 10 strikeouts and no walks.

He went 0-2 to seven of the first 10 Pirates hitters and he outpitched Cole seriously enough that the winter should bring the Pirate ace ample reflection on what it takes to be among the game’s truly elite moundsmen.

But this third installment of wild card mania to visit the North Shore in the last three autumns will be better remembered for the stunningly fearful posture taken by a Pittsburgh team that had not only won 98 games, but had won more than 50 at home for the third consecutive year.

Hurdle may have been algorhythmically correct in playing defensively against Arrieta. He may have been emotionally correct as well, having seen too many comically bad defensive plays by Alvarez over the past two seasons. But this is what else he may have been: Too clever by half.

What that lineup card told his players yesterday was that their only chance to beat Arrieta was to be perfect in every way, rather than in the way they typically played this season, based on the way lineups typically got written.

Advertise with us

Instead, the team that had been baseball’s best over most of the season’s final five months, albeit in its sometimes shaggy way of doing things, came out looking skittish and wary. Josh Harrison fumbled a first-inning throw from Francisco Cervelli, keeping Dexter Fowler alive at second, from where he scored the only run necessary when Kyle Schwarber sliced Cole’s 10th pitch to left. Neil Walker made a first-inning error.

Schwarber hit the bone marrow out of Cole’s batting tee fastball with Fowler on again in the third, sending it over everything in right for a 3-0 lead. When Fowler homered in the fifth, the Pirates found themselves in a situation where Arrieta would have had to allow as many runs in the next hour as he had in the past two months for them even tie the game.

All right technically they didn’t have to be earned runs, but that train just wasn’t coming anyway, right?

In a very real sense, the wholly deserving Cubs won this wild card game because they refused to overthink it, and the dichotomy between the managers was therefore striking.

“I'm telling you, man, from the beginning of spring training, that’s all I talked about,” said Cubs boss Joe Maddon. “I don't want to play any different game when it gets to October than we played in spring training, in April, May, June, July, whatever. You play the same game, and if you prepare that way and don't apply more weight to any particular moment, chances are when you get to a more weighted moment from the outside, you can play your game.”

Advertise with us

In the Pirates most urgent moment, they seemed to be playing someone else’s game. In baseball’s post-modern era, you can watch the game for months at a time without coming across a complete game, let alone two, but in America’s Most Beautiful Ballpark, you can see one the first week in October, time after time.

There’ll be a time very soon when the ballpark isn’t enough anymore.

There will also be a time, sooner than you think, when advanced analytics (and the resultant impetus to overthink the game at every turn) will become so sophisticated that anyone who cares to study hard enough will know just about everything that’s going to happen well before it happens.

And when that happens, why will we watch baseball?

Click the image above to explore our 2015 season tracker and check out how the Pirates have fared so far, game by game. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.