Stephen J. Nesbitt: Good morning, and thanks for dropping by today's Pirates chat. What better way to prep for this afternoon's series finale against the Chicago Cubs than to get a little steamed about the fact the Pirates are now closer to the Cubs than to the first-place St. Louis Cardinals? Toss a few questions in the hopper, and we'll get going shortly.

Matt: If game 162 arrives and Pirates are 1 game (or less) back does Hurdle go all-in with his starting pitcher choice i.e. 2014?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Right now, the Pirates have a lot of winning left to do if they're going to catch the Cardinals. But if they get within a game, here's the set-up on the final day of the regular season: Pirates vs. Reds; Cardinals at Braves. There are a number of factors at play. First, the Pirates tried going for it all last year, and it backfired. Earlier this week, Clint Hurdle was asked whether he regrets starting Vance Worley, Francisco Liriano and Gerrit Cole in the final series last season when they were within striking distance of the Cardinals. Here's his reply: "Zero regrets. Zero. The day I'm fortunate enough to be sitting at this desk with an opportunity to win the championship and I don't go for it, I need to be removed, in my eyes. If I ever have that feeling, I need to get out." Last year, he took the decision to the team, he said, and they looked at him like he was silly for even asking them if they wanted to shoot for the division crown. "If you talk about winning the division and you have a chance to do it and don't [try]?" he said. "That cheapens it for me." The other factor, however, is how bad the Braves are. They are 4-25 since the middle of August. They can't be expected to win even a single game against the Cardinals. So, I think Hurdle throws *one* of his best pitchers in Game 162, but I think he'll play it safe and have Gerrit Cole ready for Game 163, if needed.

Bill: Props to Jaff Decker last night -- his at bat was a turning point and he was the first to really elevate Arrieta's pitch count. Why have the Pirates struggled to extend at bats vs. Lester and Arrieta? Decker seemed to present the blue print for getting closer to the Cubs' weak pen (which wasn't so weak last night)

Advertise with us

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Agreed, Bill. Always tough to come off the bench and try to get a few good swings off against an ace like Jake Arrieta, who is on top of his game like few else right now. But in a nine-pitch at-bat, Decker gave what Hurdle often calls a "battle at-bat," taking Arrieta from a very comfortable pitch count to a much more elevated trajectory. The Pirates had a shot at beating Arrieta with the bases loaded and Gregory Polanco at the plate, and it just didn't happen.

Matt: Who catches Cole in the postseason?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Francisco Cervelli. He's caught him enough, his non-stolen base numbers are good, and his offense is a cut above Chris Stewart.

Strikes Joey: I don't think it matters a whole lot where the Wild Card game is played; in fact, I was thinking I might prefer to play it at Wrigley. There would be a LOT more pressure on the Cubs that way. Am I just crazy?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Easy to look at it either way. Pirates are 50-24 at home, 37-34 on the road. That would suggest there's something to home-field advantage, in their situation. But the Cubs are 43-28 at home, 41-33 on the road — not much of a divide. What matters more than the stadium is the starting pitcher, and the starting lineups. In a one-off game, a crowd can impact things (like in 2013 wild-card game) but a lights-out starting pitcher still has that trump card (like in 2014 wild-card game).

Advertise with us

Ben: Given the struggles against the Central could the upcoming 7 games out west be a positive for the Bucs. They play well against the west and they will also go into each game knowing how the Cubs and Cards fared. No scoreboard watching will be needed, they can give total focus to the game.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: There might be something to that, Ben. The Pirates have killed the NL West this year, including an 8-2 record on the road. Now, they'll only have to face Zack Greinke and Clayton Kershaw in the first two games out there, but still I think there has to be a certain advantage to going into a night game on the West Coast already armed with the knowledge of how the Cubs and Cardinals did that night. In a division race, that has to help. And if nothing else, it helps media as we try to track the race for our game stories.

Bill: I'm puzzled by the hand wringing among Bucs faithful. 1 and done would is tough to swallow but even winning division means 5 game series seeing a minimum of 3 games from Lester/Arrieta or Martinez/Wacha. For all of the luck involved in a 1 and done the best team does not always win a 3 or 5 game series and it's often comes down to a decisive 'knockout' game

Stephen J. Nesbitt: To be honest, I think the hand-wringing is borne largely from the agony of watching the Pirates flail and fail to touch Madison Bumgarner in the wild-card game last year. If they'd torched him, and the Pirates, say, went on to lose in the next round again, I think there'd be a lot more fans saying with gusto, "Bring on Arrieta!" But they saw what a best-in-the-game starter can do to crush a season in Game 163, and now it's a pretty petrifying thought to know it might happen again. But, know what? Arrieta pitched last night, and he didn't even get the decision. More likely than not, he won't pitch a complete game in the wild-card game. His bullpen isn't nearly as good as the Pirates. Maybe that game is decided in the eighth, in the ninth, in extras. The Pirates have pitchers (a pitcher, maybe) who can hang with Arrieta, maybe even match him for one night. From there, it's all about whether the offense can string some things together.

Krodge: What's your take on the plate blocking rule and do you think they'll look at it in the offseason?

Advertise with us

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Kind of a surpring outcome last night, in my mind. It seemed to be a pretty textbook case of a catcher setting up directly in the runner's path to the plate, though I'll concede the catcher did have to go even farther that way to get the throw, which he's allowed to do. Would have radically changed the game if Pedro Florimon is ruled safe there, so maybe it's not such a surprise they stuck with the original call. I think more work will be done this offseason to clarify that rule. Still plenty of gray area.

Matt: Do you think the defensive and baserunning errors will get special attention during spring training next year?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: We'll see who the cast and crew of the 2016 Pittsburgh Pirates are by spring training, but, yeah, I think those would be pretty good areas to look at. Manager Clint Hurdle picks something every year he wants to use as a particular focus in spring training. This year, it was a focus on pitcher's contributing more at the plate. So, sure, it doesn't change the whole arc and direction of spring training, but it's a stated goal. And it seemed to have worked a bit this year. Nick Leyva and Rick Sofield would have plenty of game film to go over if they want to pick apart the defensive and base-running blunders we've seen this season.

Bill: should we fear Colorado? too much weird baseball there for my taste

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Oh, indeed. The Rockies, who were shut out by Dodgers lefty Alex Wood in Los Angeles last night, will host the Pirates for four games in the middle of a long, 10-game home stand. Coors Field is a remarkable ballpark. I was there just two weeks ago when the Pirates were on the road — Bill Brink was with 'em — and I took a trip out to Denver to rendezvous with my three brothers. We checked out a Rockies night game against the Arizona Diamondbacks, and it got wild. First, Nolan Arenado, who is a very good young baseball player, hit a homer to center that made everybody laugh because center fielder Ender Inciarte actually looked like he was going to catch it really easily. He drifted back, then set up shop about 15 feet in front of the warning track, only to look over his head and realize the ball was going to clear the fence behind him by a good margin. Later, Carlos Gonzalez, an even better baseball player, hit two homers late, including a grand slam, and had a career-high seven RBIs as the Rockies pulled away for a 9-4 win. Baseballs fly out of that place, man. It's pretty fun.

Advertise with us

Matt: Your top free agent target for this offseason?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I believe David Price, Johnny Cueto and Greinke are all free agents. Alex Gordon and Yoenis Cespedes, too. All are huge targets.

Strikes Joey: To your knowledge, is there anything us fans can do to invoke the Curse of the Billy Goat if and when the Pirates face the Cubs for the Wild Card?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: You know that triangular empty space between the Bowser Blast counter, the stands and the right-field foul-territory wall? Could definitely fit a small army of billy goats. Would probably work.

Bill: Cards play tonight and travel for day game Fri. vs. Cubs. How does the 'Cardinals Way' address fatigue? Half-firm handshakes after advancing runner on routine ground out? Moratorium on patting selves on backs for doing every little thing 'the right way'?

Advertise with us

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I laughed. As Hurdle says, that travel schedule is just a tax for success.

Ben: Off the wall question. The Indianapolis Indians are currently in the IL final. If they were to come back and win the series do the Pirates get anything from that or is it strictly the satisfaction that your Triple A won a title?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I'm not aware of anything extra.

Matt: What's your take on the "move Marte to CF" crowd?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: A move that very well could happen, but it hasn't been addressed yet, and it wouldn't happen during the season. It's a topic I'm sure will surface again next season around spring training. For now, enjoy Starling Marte's ability to make runners look very foolish from the left-field corner. His 13 outfield assists lead the National League by a wide margin.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Gotta jet! No, really, Southwest is lining up already. Thanks for all the questions. We'll be back next Tuesday and Thursday. In the meantime, I'm off to Los Angeles — First time! Send travel tips to @stephenjnesbitt or snesbitt@post-gazette.com — and then Denver, where my twin brother promises me I can sub in on his baseball team, the Cougars. Brink will finish up the roadtrip with a three-game series at Wrigley Field.