In the bottom of the fifth inning Wednesday night, Andrew McCutchen broke for second on a steal attempt. Arizona Diamondbacks left-hander Robbie Ray aborted his delivery in time to throw to first, and McCutchen was out.

That was the third time McCutchen was caught stealing, half as many as his six successful steals through Wednesday. McCutchen, who stole at least 18 bases in each of his first six years in the majors, and 33 in 2010, has seen his steal totals decline this year in part because of the left knee pain that bothered him early in the season.

"Physically wasn't that great in the beginning of the year, legs-wise," he said. "Didn't feel good. I had to battle a lot of that."

Though not advancing to scoring position as frequently hurts the team's run expectancy, baserunning coach Rick Sofield said the threat of McCutchen running aids batters behind him.

Advertise with us

"I definitely think that he's aware that he, at times, more so because of the attention he draws, that not going is just as effective as going sometimes," Sofield said, "in relationship to getting the extra fastball for [Aramis] Ramirez, for Pedro [Alvarez], for [Neil] Walker, for [Jung Ho] Kang especially."

Fast runners on first base draw more fastballs so catchers have more time to throw them out if they run. They also force the first baseman to hold the runner on, which can create a hole on the right side of the infield.

PG graphic: Stolen

(Click image for larger version)

But what Sofield referred to was the effect pitching from the stretch or using a slide-step, a speedier delivery designed to prevent a baserunner from getting a good jump.

Advertise with us

"When a guy gets into that 60, 70, 80 [pitch] mark, if they're in quick-step mode, if they're in any parcel of trying to prevent something from happening, if they are not physically on top of what they're doing - and we're all human - you get that [arm] up big-time, it's going to be 96 [mph] and flat," Sofield said. "And flat 96 in this league gets whacked all over the place."

All well and good. But doesn't game theory apply? Doesn't McCutchen have to run sometimes to keep the threat of running in his opponents' head?

"I think Andrew's very aware of the opportunities that present themselves for a steal versus not a steal," Sofield said. "There's no doubt he understands the concept."

McCutchen said he is now physically capable to run when the time is right.

"Trying to take the next base when I get an opportunity," he said. "It's never too late to try and go, so that's what I'm trying to do now."

Advertise with us

The Alvarez conundrum

What do the Pirates do with Pedro Alvarez this offseason?

In the past two-plus weeks, Alvarez has assembled a streak that reminds everyone what he was capable of in 2012-13, when he had two 30-homer seasons. In 13 games before Thursday, Alvarez hit .447/.462/.816 with four homers.

But then there's the rest of the season, when Alvarez has been an inconsistent hitter - prior to the streak he had a .301 on-base percentage, 15 home runs and 86 strikeouts - and the worst defensive first baseman in baseball.

His defense has reached the point where the Pirates asked Aramis Ramirez to work at first base. As of Wednesday, Ramirez has played 2,499 games in 20 years of professional baseball, none of them at first base.

Advertise with us

As far as whether or not that experiment might work: A rival executive said Ramirez can handle first base because he has good hands, and good hands translate.

Ramirez is retiring after this season, so he won't factor into the Pirates' decision-making process this winter. But when the Pirates traded for Michael Morse, they got a first baseman under contract for $8 million in 2016 with a track record of above-average production at the plate - despite a down year this year.

Alvarez is entering his final year of arbitration. He won his case in the offseason and is making $5.75 million, and another year of service time and another season of 20-plus home runs will earn him a raise. Do the Pirates look for upgrades in free agency or via trade? Roll with Morse? Or keep Alvarez and hope his defense improves and his offense becomes more consistent?

Winner takes all?

Three years later, the Pirates have all the players involved in both Travis Snider trades in their organization.

Advertise with us

When they acquired Snider from the Toronto Blue Jays at the 2012 trade deadline, they sent right-hander Brad Lincoln, their 2006 first-round pick, to Toronto. Lincoln rejoined the Pirates on a minor league contract this winter and has been pitching for Class AAA Indianapolis.

After sending Snider to the Baltimore Orioles in January for minor league left-handers Stephen Tarpley and Steven Brault, the Pirates re-signed Snider to a minor league deal when the Orioles released him last week. Snider is playing for Indianapolis now, while Tarpley and Brault are dealing.