Brandon Phillips knew he’d done it, just like Todd Frazier six innings before.
Frazier’s home run in the seventh inning drew the Cincinnati Reds into a tie with the Pirates, and Phillips homered in the 13th to give the Reds a 5-4 victory at PNC Park.
The Pirates have now lost five of their past six games, including two of three against the Reds. Their record is 40-32 entering their three-game series against the Atlanta Braves this weekend. Against division opponents, the Pirates are 14-20, but take away their 6-3 record against the last-place Milwaukee Brewers and the Pirates have lost 17 of 25 games against NL Central rivals. They are 2-7 against the Reds this year.
“It’s a good battle against those guys, always is,” said A.J. Burnett, who allowed two runs, one earned, in six innings.
Leading off the 13th, Phillips hit the fourth pitch Rob Scahill threw into the seats in left field to break a 4-4 tie.
Andrew McCutchen seemed to think he had a walk-off homer against Pedro Villarreal in the 12th, but the ball hit the base of the wall in left-center field for a double. The Reds intentionally walked Neil Walker, but Joey Votto caught Jung Ho Kang’s liner and doubled Walker off first. Pinch-hitter Jose Tabata walked, but Francisco Cervelli grounded out.
Read More
Jordy Mercer and Gregory Polanco each hit balls to deep center field off Aroldis Chapman in the 11th, but Billy Hamilton ran them down each time.
“Mercer’s ball, Polanco’s ball, Cutch’s ball,” Hurdle said, “and then Phillips hits a ball that obviously had some length and distance.”
The Pirates put men on in the ninth against Ryan Mattheus, who pitched for the third day in a row. Reds manager Bryan Price chose to pitch to McCutchen with runners on the corners and two outs, but McCutchen flied out. The Pirates went 4 for 13 with runners in scoring position and left 12 men on base.
Arquimedes Caminero replaced Burnett in the seventh, when the Pirates led, 4-2. He allowed a leadoff single to Votto that Josh Harrison, playing right field Thursday, misplayed into a two-base error that put Votto on third.
It ended up not mattering which base Votto reached. Caminero started Frazier with a slider, which Frazier fouled off. Then Caminero left a fastball up and over the inner half of the plate, and Frazier knew he had his 24th homer moments after he hit it. The two-run homer tied the game at 4-4.
Antonio Bastardo entered and struck out both batters he faced. Tony Watson pitched a perfect eighth inning, Mark Melancon worked a scoreless ninth and Vance Worley pitched three scoreless innings.
“Bastardo came in and did a really nice job again,” Hurdle said. “He continues to pitch well, become more effective, throw more strikes. He’s doing a real good job for us. Worley again shows up in big fashion. Gives us length, gives us three innings, works through the middle part of the lineup twice. Pitched extremely well.”
The Reds recorded eight hits off Burnett, raising his total to 22 in his past 122/3 innings, but the quality of contact belied the outcome. Hard-hit line drives from Marlon Byrd and Phillips went right at Pirates outfielders, while weak dribblers from Brayan Pena and Reds starter Anthony DeSclafani turned into base hits.
“They came out attacking, they know what we want to do,” Burnett said. “I know what they want to do.”
DeSclafani matched Burnett, pitching six innings and allowing four runs, one of them earned.
Phillips reached base in the first due to Kang’s error. He stole second and advanced to third on Votto’s grounder before Frazier ripped an RBI single up the middle. The Pirates have allowed runs in the first inning in four consecutive games.
“We went through a stretch where we didn’t miss many locations and we’ve missed a few locations here, especially in the early parts of the game,” Hurdle said.
Kang reached on a fielder’s choice after Walker’s leadoff walk in the bottom of the second, and this time a Reds error led to runs. After Pedro Alvarez struck out looking at three pitches, Eugenio Suarez bobbled Cervelli’s grounder. Jordy Mercer’s double bounced over the short wall in right field, scoring a run and bringing Burnett to the plate with two outs.
Burnett took a fastball for a ball, then lined a fastball into center field to drive in both runners and put the Pirates ahead, 3-2. Burnett drove in two runs in one game for the first time in his career, which included 557 plate appearances prior to Thursday night.
“I just tried to swing as hard as I could and he hit my bat in the right spot,” Burnett said. “It’s always fun to get a hit, especially when you get some ribbies to help out.”
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.