Back in 2004, Neil Walker’s senior year at Pine-Richland High School, a long line of rental cars trailed the Rams’ team bus after road games.

Since Walker only got three or four at-bats most games, and often walked at least once, major league scouts waited around after every game, home or away, to watch Jeff Rojik, the Pine-Richland baseball coach, throw batting practice to Walker at the Rams’ home field.

“Those were long days for Neil,” Rojik said this week, describing a scene of 15 to 20 scouts watching Walker hit, trying to discern whether this 18-year-old kid was worth a first-round grade.

The process was “sort of comical to watch,” said Rojik, now the principal at Burchfield Primary School in Allison Park. He would field calls every Sunday night from team personnel — then-Pirates general manager Dave Littlefield, for one — asking for Walker’s schedule the next week, what positions he would play and, of course, whether Rojik could throw late batting practice again.

Advertise with us

The extra swings paid off in the end, as the Pirates drafted Walker 11th overall that year. But Rojik's memory paints a picture of the innate risk major league teams accept by drafting position players directly out of high school. In this case, much of teams’ evaluations were based on seeing Walker hit against WPIAL pitchers and his coach. It’s a big jump from there to the pros.

“What he saw in the WPIAL wasn’t what he’d be seeing in [Class] A and AA,” Rojik said, with a laugh.

The Pirates haven’t shied away from the uncertainty that comes with drafting high school hitters, though. In 2005, a year after drafting Walker, they took Andrew McCutchen 11th overall. They’ve used three of their four first-round picks in the past two drafts on high school hitters — catcher Reese McGuire, outfielder Austin Meadows and shortstop Cole Tucker.

PG graphic: The Big Board

(Click image for larger version)

Advertise with us

The Pirates select 19th overall in this year’s draft, which begins Monday. They’ll draft again at 32, a compensation pick for having made a $15.3 million qualifying offer last fall to catcher Russell Martin, who signed with the Toronto Blue Jays.

General manager Neal Huntington said the Pirates are “very well-equipped” to help high school draftees mature on and off the field. But, he added, it’ll likely be another four to six years until that player reaches the majors, if he does.

“We love the fact that baseball is his job, that it’s his sole focus for that time,” Huntington said. “ … You can always dream on the high school guy. The college player, in theory, is always the safer pick. But the right high school guy beats the wrong college guy every single day of the week.

He paused.

“Just like the right college guy beats the wrong high school guy, too.”

Advertise with us

High school signability

Drafting a high school player doesn’t mean he’ll sign, either. Top draft picks have college offers as fallbacks should they get drafted lower than expected or offered a smaller signing bonus than desired. Walker, for instance, had a scholarship waiting at Clemson.

Some of the guessing game has been allayed, Huntington said, by a slotting system put in place in 2012 by which each draft slot is assigned a certain value — the Pirates’ No. 19 pick this year, for example, is valued at $2,284,500. The values for the first 10 rounds are added together to form each team’s bonus pool total.

The Pirates’ bonus pool this year, according to MLB.com, is $7,247,000 — that’s their budget for their signing bonuses for all picks through the 10th round.

“If Player X wants signing bonus Y,” Huntington said, “you need to get really creative if it doesn’t fit for you in the fourth round, in terms of creating money by taking lower signing bonus guys later.”

Advertise with us

If a draftee wants a $1 million signing bonus but his slot value is lower than that, a team can still pay him that $1 million; they would just have to sign other picks below their slot value to make up the difference.

High school players often demand higher signing bonuses than, say, college seniors, because they’re younger and can choose to go to college instead.

“So, the new system basically makes it: you’ve got to take a high school player where you can pay him or get creative,” Huntington explained.

Draft facts

What: 2015 First Year Player Draft.

Advertise with us

When: Monday-Wednesday.

Pirates: Select No. 19 in the first round and also No. 32 as compensation for losing Russell Martin in free agency.

TV: MLB Network will televise the first two rounds beginning 7 p.m. Monday.

On the Web: Fans can follow all three days of the draft pick-by-pick on MLB.com. Day 2 begins 1 p.m. Tuesday and Day 3 at noon Wednesday.

The risk, and the wait

Advertise with us

Rojik could tell early Walker was a special talent. In the coach's first year at Pine-Richland, an assistant pointed toward a freshman and said, "Walker’s a player.” Rojik shrugged it off. He threw batting practice in the cage later and Walker, first batting right-handed, said, “Coach, let me switch sides,” and stepped into the other batter’s box.

“Neil, I don’t have time for this,” Rojik said. “Get back to the side you’re supposed to be on.”

“No, seriously, I can switch-hit!” Walker replied.

“Just to humor him I threw five or 10 pitches,” Rojik recalled, laughing. “And he roped them.”

Not many kids are ready for the preps-to-pros jump Walker made, though. Three years ago, Ian Happ drew some interest from scouts as a senior at Mt. Lebanon High School, but not much. He went to the University of Cincinnati, and now is projected to be a top-20 pick Monday.

Advertise with us

“At the time, you have all the confidence in the world you can go out and [hit anybody],” Happ said. “But looking back, I wasn’t ready to face that type of [professional] pitching at 17, 18 years old.”

His first fall at Cincinnati wasn’t entirely smooth, but that was OK. He ironed out his swing and turned himself into a first-rounder. “I was able to struggle when it didn’t count,” Happ said, able to struggle when he wasn’t playing for a contract worth a couple million bucks.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.