A year ago, those with black-and-gold souls but no ticket remained on the Roberto Clemente Bridge until the Pirates recorded the final out, hoping just to be as close to playoff magic as possible. Wednesday, before “Take Me Out to the Ball Game” could even be sung, hundreds of fans trudged toward their homes over the treasured yellow landmark, their team on its way to a deflating, 8-0 loss to the Giants. Hey, they still had to make it to work today, after all.
This was how it looked from the other side of the one-game, winner-takes-all wild card format: As division after division of the Blackout Army waved the white flag and rode the escalators down the third-base corner of PNC Park onto Federal Street in the top of the seventh inning, Pirates manager Clint Hurdle, hard-nosed to the very end, limped once again on a bad hip to make another fruitless pitching change, the score already out of hand at 7-0. A few minutes later, a group mockingly chanted “CUE-TO,” a reference to that unforgettable night on the river in 2013 that now felt so far away.
Hurdle may be as connected with his fan base as any manager in baseball, but that won’t protect him from the ire of the legions who will second-guess his decision to pitch Gerrit Cole on Sunday with the National League Central still in play, forcing Edinson Volquez onto the mound for the most pressure-packed start of his career. Volquez gave up a grand slam to the Giants’ Brandon Crawford in the fourth inning, and, with Giants starter Madison Bumgarner throwing tranquilizer darts at the Pirates’ offense, the game was pretty much over from there.
The disappointment that will engulf Pittsburgh this morning is part of the deal, of course. In fact, it’s just one more sign that the Pirates are now operating in the game’s higher stratosphere.
They began this season with weightier expectations than they’d faced in two decades. Think breaking the playoff drought was hard? Try proving it wasn’t a fluke.
They would find that repetition was not at all simple. Every baseball season is a hand-wringing emotional journey, and somewhere along the way, the Pirates’ franchise third baseman, free-swinging slugger Pedro Alvarez, forgot how to throw the ball to first base. There were serious injuries to reigning National League MVP Andrew McCutchen and Cole, among others. A seven-game losing streak in August, and a three-game sweep by the Cardinals in early September, both had them left for dead.
Read More
Yet, there was the season-long spark of utility man Josh Harrison that never dimmed; the day-to-day gamesmanship of catcher Russell Martin; the timely emergence of a power-hitting Starling Marte in Alvarez’s absence; and the Jedi mind tricks of Hurdle, who showed that his positive juju was more than just practiced mantra. And so here we were once again on Wednesday night, a crazed city hosting a one-game wild card playoff in the most picturesque stadium in baseball.
Still, it was cruel, almost. The boys in black and gold had played 162 games to prove their worth. They had earned it, but they had to do it one more time. It didn’t seem fair. One game to rule them all is against baseball’s grand design. At least, after last season, Pirates fans understood the nerves that were to come.
About 5 p.m., Dave Madden, a 28-year-old nursing student at Pitt, hopped the “91” Butler Street bus in Lawrenceville with black shirt in tow. He was heading to meet his older brother, Zack, for the game, and he had skipped his pediatric nursing class.
“I couldn’t focus,” Madden said. “I was just going to be thinking about the game.”
Madden wasn’t ashamed to admit he was a bandwagon fan. He did not grow up following baseball and picked up the Pirates when he moved here two summers ago. The Pirates are now good enough to bring people to baseball … how about that?
Zack Madden waited for Dave in “The Mob” on Federal Street, which was covered in black by 6. He moved to Pittsburgh 10 years ago and has been going to 10 or 15 games ever since. He attended last year’s wild card victory over the Reds, and this one already felt different.
“This one is bigger,” Zack, 32, said, “because it’s more about the team and less about ‘Oh, my God, we’re here.’ There’s more … this is a team to be reckoned with who actually isn’t just psyched to be at the ball and can actually do something.”
Lou Pappa, 28, who stood out in the mob by wearing the Jolly Roger flag as a cape, felt the same way.
“It’s funny how we didn’t even make a big deal about 82 wins,” Pappa said. “We deserve to be here.”
Jerry and Kelly Kitterly of McCandless felt their 13-year-old son, Evan, deserved to be at PNC Park for this one, too. The Pirates’ finest moments had been touchstone moments in their lives. For Kelly, it was coming downtown to celebrate the 1971 World Series and buying a Roberto Clemente pin that she still has. For Jerry, it was partying in Market Square in ’79 as a student at Duquesne. Evan didn’t go to any of last year’s playoff games.
“This is awesome,” Evan said as he soaked up Federal Street. “This is great stuff to see the city loving baseball, because I’ve never experienced that.”
Evan remembers 2009 well, when the Steelers and Penguins both won championships. Now he goes to his home room every morning and talks with his friends about what the Pirates did the previous night.
That won’t be a happy discussion today.
“There’s something about baseball that makes it all worthwhile,” Jerry said. “In the postseason, everything is a bonus. You can’t take anything for granted.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.