Welcome back, baseball fans. The regular season’s end is drawing near. At 78-80, the Pirates would need to win three of their last four games to finish at .500 and eclipse the 80-win mark.

If you have a question for next week’s season wrap-up mailbag, send it to snesbitt@post-gazette.com or to @stephenjnesbitt on Twitter. Thanks for participating. It has been good time.

Here we go.

Azulia: Do you remember a few seasons back when someone analyzed teams’ luck in the season and Pirates had the worst? Where do you think they are this year, luck wise? Either with the fancy criteria or your own opinion or both.

Advertise with us

Other than how just about everything has gone wrong for the Pirates this season, they actually have been one of the luckiest teams in baseball, according to the specific metric you mentioned. In 2014, the term “cluster luck” got some air time and claimed the Pirates were very, very unlucky. Here is a description of cluster luck from Jonah Keri: “When a team’s batters cluster hits together to score more runs and a team’s pitchers spread hits apart to allow fewer runs, that’s cluster luck. Say a team tallies nine singles in one game. If all of those singles occur in the same inning, the team would likely score seven runs; if each single occurs in a different inning, however, it’d likely mean a shutout.”

In 2014, the Chicago Cubs actually were the unluckiest team in baseball, with -67.81 runs. The Pirates were fourth-unluckiest, at -40.53, but the most unfortunate on offense, losing 42.8 runs to chance. Their defense was 2.26 better than expected, perhaps because of defensive shifting, etc.

This year, the Pirates have been the third-luckiest team in the majors, per The Power Rank. The same metric, cluster luck, ranks their 46.2 total number behind only the Los Angeles Angels (70.7) and the San Diego Padres (54.2). It should be noted none of them is postseason-bound.

On offense, the Pirates have had average luck, generating -0.5 runs below expectations.

On defense, they have benefitted from tremendous fortune, allowing 47.3 fewer runs than expected.

Advertise with us

So there you have it. The Pirates can’t point to luck — or cluster luck, to be exact — as the reason for their subpar season. But this metric can only control for and measure so much. The best teams in baseball land somewhere in the middle of the cluster luck chart. The only playoff team in the top or bottom five is the Boston Red Sox, who have a poor -28.0 total number.

Baseball Prospectus also shows the Pirates to have been on the lucky side of things this season. In weighing the team’s actual number of wins versus the number of wins that would be expected of them based on actual runs scored, projected runs scored, quality of opponent and “other underlying statistics,” the Pirates are in the black (lucky side of average) for each category.

Stephen: Did Andrew McCutchen start hitting consistently when he switched his arm band from his right arm to his left arm?

Another astute observation, as we have come to expect here in the mailbag, but an observation I must shoot down, to some extent. McCutchen really got back on track once he was benched for the Atlanta Braves road series in early August. Since then, he’s batted .284 with an .866 OPS, nine home runs, 34 RBIs and as many walks (33) as strikeouts (33).

Has he switched on which arm he wears his yellow armband? Yes. It was right. It is now left.

Advertise with us

Did that coincide with his resurgence? Not exactly. Here’s how he looked Aug. 5.


Arm band? Right side. (Matt Freed/Post-Gazette)

And here’s a snapshot of his three-hit day Aug. 30.


Still on the right. (Dylan Buell/Getty)

Hmm. How about Sept. 5?

Advertise with us


Downright disappointing, right? (Justin K. Aller/Getty)

The switch you noticed started, best I can gather, with his two-homer day Sept. 15 in Philadelphia. McCutchen is a superstitious sort, so he’s kept the armband on the left side ever since. Over 14 starts with the armband on the left, he has batted .333 with a 1.023 OPS.

Hmm.

Makes you think.


Looking fine in Philly. (Matt Slocum/AP)

Advertise with us

Elaine: Should McCutchen grow his hair back? He cut it and went downhill this year.

Don’t know exactly know how put this, because I understand yinz still prefer Samson with his dreadlocks, but it’s been a little while now. McCutchen cut his hair before last season and went on to finish fourth in the National League MVP voting. He’s been clean-cut since March 25, 2015. Locks are a deeply personal matter, and I’d rather not stray far down the strand of hair-shaming.

Christy: I wonder what the pirates record is since Clint Hurdle stopped chewing bubblegum?

Not sure the exact date he kicked the habit, Christy, but it was somewhere in the middle of August. If we say Aug. 15, then, we’re looking at a record in the ballpark of 17-24.

Joey: What are the odds, percentage wise, that the Pirates actually, sign Ivan Nova to an extension?

Advertise with us

Let’s see … $14+ million per year … so I carry the one … round to the nearest full number aaaand …

Seven percent.

Signing him to an extension is exceedingly unlikely. Re-signing him as a free agent? Maybe.

Chuck: What is the plan for Gerrit Cole this offseason? What is his contract status and will his recent arm troubles affect his future $$?

Cole is in “active recovery” mode now, which means he got his offseason routine started early by shutting things down in September. He’ll rest for a time, trying to get the right elbow right, and then build back up with a more structured offseason plan than he had last winter.

Advertise with us

“Every conversation we’ve had with Gerrit, the No. 1 priority is for him to get healthy first,” Hurdle said Wednesday. “He tried hard. He played catch-up all year, from spring training on. Every time he got some traction, there was something that got him off track physically. Health will take care of everything.

“I really don’t want to get in front of myself after that. I believe getting him healthy is the biggest priority for him and for us to give him a chance to be the best pitcher he can.”

The Pirates expect Cole will be ready for spring training. That seems like a reasonable thought.

Cole is entering his first arbitration year. Rather than be paid somewhere just north of the major league minimum ($507,500), he’ll make a few million dollars next season and continue to earn hefty annual raises until he reaches free agency after the 2019 season. The Pirates could, of course, attempt to buy out his arbitration years with a contract extension, but Cole and his agent Scott Boras are unlikely to delay his arrival on the lucrative free-agent market for starting pitchers.

Frank: Why is it that the Pirates have treated Ryan Vogelsong this year the same way that the Yankees treated Derek Jeter in 2014?

Advertise with us

I haven’t heard a peep about Vogelsong’s defense, so this has been nothing like Jeter’s farewell.

Look, you might not like the Pirates trotting him out Vogelsong for five or six starts in September, but it’s not like they plugged him into the rotation all season, wound him up and watched him go. He signed a cheap deal to spend a year in Pittsburgh. He started in the bullpen and was OK there. He got his face broken by a 93 mph fastball and didn’t know if he’d play baseball again. He made a really impressive recovery and then, even better, looked great for a handful of starts when the Pirates rotation needed stability worse than ever. And then he faltered. That coincided with all the kids coming up in September, so it makes sense folks would rather see Tyler Glasnow or Trevor Williams or Drew Hutchison get those starts. The Pirates were going to ride the veteran until they were out of the playoffs. Now they can decide whether he gets one last start, one last farewell, Sunday before he rides off into the offseason. The 39-year-old Vogelsong hasn’t said yet whether he plans to retire, but it’s all right for him to start in September for a sub-.500 ball club.

Tony: How much faith do the Pirates have in these young pitchers? What’s your opinion of these young pitchers?

The rookies have shown a good bit of promise. Jameson Taillon especially. What more could you have wanted to see at this stage, right? After two seasons when he didn’t pitch a single inning for a Pirates minor league affiliate, he was locked in from opening day at Class AAA Indianapolis and didn’t skip a beat in the majors. He’s a lock for the 2017 rotation.

As for the rest, there were peaks and valleys that are expected for rookies. Chad Kuhl got an extended look in the rotation and certainly looks like a good option for next season. Glasnow, Williams, Hutchison and Steven Brault got involved, too, and should battle for spots at the back end of the rotation. It’s pretty clear the Pirates will need to go out and get a starting pitcher in free agency, or via trade, this offseason. Hurdle basically said as much Wednesday, admitting it would be nice to have another veteran alongside Cole to bolster a youth-heavy rotation. Of course, Nova could be that guy, if the Pirates are willing to pay the price he’ll demand this fall.

Advertise with us

“We’ve talked about different ways to cut it up,” Hurdle said. “It’s going to depend on who’s available, what budget is available. Then guys we’ve put our eyes on. Sometimes [veterans] can be available in the free agent market, sometimes through trade. You don’t know.”

The Pirates could keep Jeff Locke, but given the way they handled him in August and September it looks increasingly obvious Locke will be a non-tender candidate in December.

Kraig: Might as well just “mail “ it in Stephen. Pirates sure have. From 98 wins to this is shameful & sickening. Thx for Nutting.

Klever.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.