Welcome back, Pirates fans. I hope you’re sitting down, because Andrew McCutchen certainly is. The Pirates bid adieu to Turner Field by closing out a 1-5 road trip Thursday night, and so I fielded a number of questions from huffy fans and attempted to answer them.
If you’ve got a question for next week’s mailbag, email snesbitt@post-gazette.com or send them on Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.
Here we go.
Brent: How can Neal Huntington justify the salary and prospect dump he just made?
Huntington would (and has) justified the trade that sent Francisco Liriano, Harold Ramirez and Reese McGuire to the Toronto Blue Jays for Drew Hutchison like this: “Our goal in that transaction, our primary goal in that transaction, was to acquire Drew Hutchison and have him plug right into our future rotations.” Huntington said a starting pitcher who will be under contract for a couple more years is “an extremely expensive commodity in the market.”
If you’re asking me — which it seems you are, because you tossed a letter in the mailbag — I would say this actually was a pretty smart trade, but not one I’d expect fans to like right away.
Read More
I also think Huntington’s above statement was somewhere short of true. I believe acquiring Hutchison, who should impact future Pirates teams, certainly was a goal of the move, but the primary goal of this trade obviously was to shed Liriano’s salary. Huntington, ever a shrewd negotiator and a cautious speaker, never said this was a salary dump. He said it gave the team financial flexibility. He said the phrase “financial flexibility” at least 10 times in 20 minutes. Why won’t he just call a salary dump a salary dump? Because he’d be publicly criticizing the team’s ownership by asserting he needs to drop salary in order to add this offseason. (Huntington said, in fact, there was no mandate from ownership to lower the payroll.) And because he’d threaten burning a bridge with Liriano’s camp, with whom he worked on a team-record free-agent deal that at the time was happy news in Pittsburgh. So why not deflect and say the focus all along was Hutchison?
The truth is, the Pirates shopped Liriano’s contract around the league, according to sources, and the only taker was the Blue Jays. The only way to unload Liriano while fetching a young starter in return was to toss in two quality prospects. Look at it this way: One for Hutchison, the other for Liriano’s contract.
Now to the actual trade.
Let’s start here: Why don’t fans like this trade? It’s not that they still want Liriano, because the numbers say he is among the worst handful of starters in the major leagues this season. Fans disliked it, from my perspective, because since he arrived in Pittsburgh, Huntington’s credo was that the Pirates’ most valuable commodity is its prospects, its homegrown talent. He for years resisted the temptation to flip prospects for major league talent. He said this two weeks ago (emphasis mine):
“You can look out at every young Pirate that came through our system and is on our major league club right now, and every single one of them could have been traded for a player that’s not here and might have only been here for two months. It’s easy to give away something you don’t know about. Our challenge is we want to be good for many years. In our minds, the only way to do that is to have a lot of good, young players in the system. That doesn’t mean we won’t trade prospects. We have, and we will. We just need to be careful and diligent about it and make sure we understand the big picture as well as the short-term impact.”
Clearly, one day the Pirates were going to trade away some quality prospects. But I think the outcry now largely is that when that day finally came, these prospects were sold not to make the major league club better today … they were sold in order to convince another team to take money off the Pirates’ payroll. To say nothing of these particular prospects and their futures with the Pirates — and we’ll get there — the bottom line is this: Whereas some teams can just eat a bad contract themselves, Huntington had to ship away two quality prospects in order to get another team to eat the salary for the Pirates. It’s the cost of doing business as a small-market club.
To the prospects.
The Pirates moved McGuire and Ramirez when they were still top-10 prospects, and those I’ve spoken to in the industry these past few days believe they were trending downward. The Pirates liked them as prospects and as people but did not see them as un-moveable. McGuire has struggled to hit in the minors and has a current projection of major league backup. The Pirates are OK with catching depth, though they did use six already this season. Ramirez has little power and little speed, a singles hitter who projects very similarly to Jose Tabata. The Pirates won’t need a corner outfielder soon, and they don’t need another Tabata. One or both of these prospects could pan out higher and haunt the Pirates down the road. That’s the risk they took.
To the return.
Huntington said the Pirates believe Hutchison’s “surface numbers are not reflective of the potential.” Which is evident, because the right-hander’s 4.92 ERA in 406⅓ innings in the majors isn’t impressing anyone. His FIP is a little more promising, at 4.23, but the 57 home runs are troubling. The Pirates scouts have tracked Hutchison for a few years, according to a source, and believe they have identified commonalities between Hutchison and former recent reclamation projects who turned things around with the Pirates. “There are some things he does that we believe we can help,” Huntington said. “There are also some things we believe a change of scenery will help him with naturally.” There will be pressure on Hutchison to prove the Pirates right in this trade, and that’s a tough spot for a guy who is still being stowed in the minors.
To the optics of the trade.
Here’s the thing: I don’t think Huntington spends too much time worrying about public perception, and that’s probably for the best, given the nature of his job. He’s willing to publicly take blame, in certain spots, and would rather do that than bury a team or ownership. But I don’t think he did himself any favors with his defense of this trade. Imagine if he comes out and says, “We needed to get out from under Liriano’s contract, and we were able to do that and get a young starter with upside. The prospects we gave up we simply aren’t as high on any more but believe they still have value. We saved money, and now I’ll get to spend it.” Well, that sounds a lot better, right? But there are some things a general manager can’t or won’t say. Huntington is deliberate with his talking points and, honestly, sometimes I think he might miss a few opportunities to remind people of what’s gone right. The points he hammered home on the conference call Monday were A) the cost of acquiring a controllable starter, B) the dreaded “financial flexibility,” and C) that the team was trading from positions of strength. What he neglected to hammer home were these points D) that $17 million had been freed up to spend on players better than Liriano, E) that teams badly wanted Josh Bell, Austin Meadows, Kevin Newman and Mitch Keller, according to sources, but none was traded, and E) that the Pirates could have traded Matt Joyce, David Freese and maybe Sean Rodriguez to help the future, but moving them would have crippled the 2016 Pirates, so they didn’t. There’s an argument to be made that they should have punted on this season, but maybe that’s just the 1-5 Atlanta-Milwaukee road trip talking.
Cocktails: Have we seen the end of Vogey?
No.
Cocktails: Well, is that the last we’re going to see of Jeff Locke?
Perhaps the last time you’ll see him start for the Pirates, but likely not the last time he’ll pitch. If Pirates wanted out, they could simply have designated Locke for assignment yesterday to make room for Ryan Vogelsong. Instead, they sent down Max Moroff and released Wilfredo Boscan.
Gil: Where exactly on the Sisyphus cycle are we now as Pirates fans?
Neither at the top of the hill nor near the bottom. Between smack in the middle and the top.
Steve: Enough for Mark Melancon? Seems light, but I trust your judgment.
From the fans’ perspective? No. From the front office’s perspective? Yes. Sure, they would have liked to get an Aroldis Chapman-like haul for Melancon, because over the past few years Melancon has had about the best numbers of any closer in the game. But they weren’t going to get what the New York Yankees got for Chapman. Melancon just doesn’t have the sexy stuff Chapman does. He makes it work with a low-90s cutter and a killer curveball, not 104 mph. Plus, the Pirates were looking for a major league-ready reliever in addition to a prospect. How many teams could afford to part with a late-inning reliever to pick up a new closer? One. The Washington Nationals. So, in return for two months of Melancon, the Pirates got a lottery ticket (Taylor Hearn) and a seventh-inning reliever (Felipe Rivero) — and they’ve got ‘em under contract for many, many moons. I’m certain the Pirates didn’t leave a better offer on the table here. It’ll be a while before we know whether Hearn will help this club at the big league level. From Rivero, we’ve already shown why there’s reason to believe in his future. He throws heat, and if his secondary pitches continue to develop, he has huge upside these next five seasons.
Bill: Looking past this year, when you look at what the Pirates’ have now, what they have in the minors, and compare that with the personnel (and ages) other top NL teams have, what do you think the competitiveness “window” for the Bucs looks to be?
It’s hard to look too far down the road. For instance: Will the Pirates be contenders in 2021? They’ve got one guy, Gregory Polanco, under contract that far in the future, and today’s rookies will be well into their arbitration years. So, we can only forecast out a few years. From that perspective, yes, the Pirates’ window extends through at least 2018 or 2019.
If my spreadsheet is correct, the Pirates lose team control of these players after these years:
2016: Ivan Nova, Neftali Feliz, Freese, Rodriguez, Vogelsong, Joyce
2017: Antonio Bastardo, John Jaso, Tony Watson, Juan Nicasio, Chris Stewart
2018: Andrew McCutchen, Jeff Locke, Jared Hughes, Jordy Mercer
2019: Francisco Cervelli, Jung Ho Kang, Gerrit Cole, Hutchison, Josh Harrison
2020: Starling Marte, Eric Fryer, Arquimedes Caminero, Rivero
2021: Polanco
In 2018, you could be looking at an opening-day defensive lineup of: Cole 1, Cervelli 2, Bell 3, Harrison 4, Kang 5, Mercer 6, Marte 7, McCutchen 8, Polanco 9. That’s without adding a single piece — and assuming none of those players is unseated by a youngster just yet.
In 2019, you could be looking at an opening-day defensive lineup of: Cole 1, Cervelli 2, Bell 3, Harrison 4, Kang 5, Kevin Newman or Gift Ngoepe 6, Marte 7, Austin Meadows 8, Polanco 9.
Of course, this all changes if options aren’t picked up or if extensions are signed. It’s a fun exercise.
Looking around the National League, there are many teams that will keep their strong cores together. A couple notable free agents from notable teams over the next two offseasons?
Chicago Cubs: Chapman (after 2016), Jake Arrieta (2017), Miguel Montero (2017), John Lackey (2017).
St. Louis Cardinals: Brandon Moss (2016), Jhonny Peralta (2017), Lance Lynn (2017), Jonathon Broxton (2017).
Washington Nationals: Jonathon Papelbon (2016), Melancon (2016), Wilson Ramos (2016), Ben Revere (2017), Jayson Werth (2017).
San Francisco Giants: Jake Peavy (2016), Angel Pagan (2016), Sergio Romo (2016), Santiago Casilla (2016), Javier Lopez (2016), Gregor Blanco (2016), Eduardo Nunez (2017).
New York Mets: Neil Walker (2016), James Loney (2016), Bartolo Colon (2016), Alejandro De Aza (2016), Curtis Granderson (2017), Lucas Duda (2017), Addison Reed (2017).
Marian: I oppose strongly limiting number of relief pitchers. Their part is essential to the outcome of games. One way to speed the pace is for decisions from NY on challenged calls to be made more quickly. Sometimes they take almost 5 minutes. Pgh Post Gazette, please pass that on.
How far up the ladder do you want me to run this? Will forwarding it to Rob Manfred be enough?
Stan: Watching the Pirates play tonight there is a way to speed up play: Problem: The batters adjust their batting gloves after every pitch even if they don’t swing at the ball. Resolution: The clubs must be buying cheap imported gloves and [need] to buy better gloves. Or have the players play like the men years ago that did NOT wear gloves. Eliminate the gloves altogether.
It’s rare in this business to read a take you’ve never heard before. This take is in a league of its own, and I’m equal parts stupefied and honored to have met it. Baseball players are creatures of habit, and when they approach the plate they show off their quirkiest quirks. They take peculiar practice swings. They tug at their sleeves. They draw designs in the dirt. And, yes, they adjust their batting gloves. Have they loosened over the course of the previous 20 seconds? I’m gonna go on a limb here and hazard a guess: No. But good luck stopping them. It’s hard to kick a habit, particularly when there’s no incentive to do so. As far as I know, these gloves are not cheaper nor more imported than any other piece of the players’ armor, so, their quality probably is not a problem. Some players still don’t wear batting gloves, but they are the exception nowadays. I have a hard time seeing the league step in to make them, and their ungloved hands, the rule.
Bob: Is there any reason other than they say Jaso is a better defender for not calling up Bell? I can’t find any scout reports.
Hey, I feel you. Scouts don’t usually just hand over their reports. The Pirates really haven’t given other reasons for keeping Bell at Indianapolis. They want to give him a chance to play every day — to hit at Indy, to field at Indy — rather than bring him up to be a bench bat in the majors. So, why not play every day in the majors? We might be getting close to that. But the Pirates have not yet fully given up on Jaso, who had a great April and a rough go ever since.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.