Ryan Vogelsong deserved a lot better than he got from his teammates Thursday night in Atlanta, and frankly, so did Pirates fans.
This, a 5-2 loss to the Braves, was the worst loss of the Pirates’ season, and it ruined what should have been Vogelsong’s feel-good night and return to the mound. Instead, it was a comedy of errors, poor base running, poor situational hitting, poor relief pitching and horrible defense by the third baseman.
The Pirates have lost a lot of games to bad teams over the past three or four years — all good teams do, as baseball is funny that way — but this one felt different. This one felt, for the first time in a long time, like some of those awful losses during the dark ages of 1993-2013, when every night seemed to be an adventure and the team was far too often the laughingstock of the league. This one brought back memories of jogging George Hendricks, operation shut down Derek Bell and 20-0 losses to the Brewers.
We have seen losses under Clint Hurdle, but very few like this one, where the effort was very questionable, the focus was even more questionable and the team seemed more interested in getting on a plane home than trying to win a game. That’s ridiculous, considering the Pirates are fighting to try to stay in the playoff race, desperately needing every win they can get.
Perhaps I’m being harsh, and maybe the past three years of success by the Pirates have earned them the benefit of the doubt when they lay a stinker like this. But I don’t think so, and mostly because the one thing we have grown to appreciate about the Pirates under Hurdle is that they always play hard, always fight until the end and always play the right way.
That wasn’t the case Thursday night. There’s no way you will convince me that all 25 guys on the roster could lay their head on the pillow and know they gave everything they had to win the game. How else would you describe a team that had not one, but two, guys fail to do the most fundamental thing in any sport — run — and in the process cost their team an opportunity when the game was still on the line.
Read More
The first was John Jaso, who hit into an inning-ending double play in the seventh inning because he didn’t bother to run. He just stood in the box, held his bat and watched the Braves turn the double play — then explained he thought the ball was foul. Wrong answer. The score was 1-1 at the time. Did I mention this team needs to win every game possible in order to get to the playoffs?
Not to be outdone, Jung Ho Kang, who played third base like he’s Edward Scissorhands, led off the ninth inning with a ball he hit high to shallow right field. The ball ended up landing between three Braves fielders, giving the Pirates a precious base runner, which is all well and good — except he was on first base, not second. Had he run out of the batter’s box as hard as he can run, he would have been at second. That wasn’t lost on color commentator John Wehner, who said as much on the broadcast. Kang jogged out of the batter’s box and down the line and ended up getting only to first base. This was the ninth inning. Did I mention this team needs to win every game possible in order to get to the playoffs?
Then there was the failed hit-and-run attempt by Eric Fryer and Jordy Mercer. Fryer missed badly, and Mercer, who led off the inning with a single, was thrown out at second by a lot.
There was Antonio Bastardo, who came in the eighth inning of a 3-2 game and showed the form that got him a one-way ticket out of New York. Bastardo, who gave up two runs and had to be lifted before the inning was over, was so inconsistent with the Mets, they were willing to take Jon Niese off the Pirates’ hands.
All of that added up to a horrible loss against a horrible team on the tail end of a horrible road trip in which the Pirates went 1-5 against two teams who long ago quit trying. It also ruined what was a great night for Vogelsong, who pitched for the first time since May 23, when he was hit in the face with an errant pitch and ended up with a fractured bone that required surgery.
There was a lot of fear that Vogelsong, 39, had played his last game immediately after it happened. But he took the long, hard road back and made his return Thursday. All he did was pitch six strong innings, giving up only three hits and one run while striking out six and walking one.
It was an inspiring effort, a wonderful story of a man’s will to come back from injury. His mental toughness and desire to win were evident in just how hard he made it on the Braves every single inning. Vogelsong reflected on his journey back and how it made his outing even more special.
“I made sure I hugged the trainers because without them I’m not standing here, that’s for sure,” Vogelsong said. “I should have hugged everyone in this locker room.These guys really did a good job of asking me how I felt almost on a daily basis.
“It makes you want to get back for them, really, not just yourself. You could tell it was sincere and there was concern.”
Vogelsong’s performance should have been the story. It should have been what we talked about after the game, but it wasn’t. That’s because a few of his teammates didn’t care about winning the game nearly as much as he did, and that’s ridiculous. Flat-out ridiculous.
The Pirates are running out of season to catch the teams ahead of them. But they won’t catch anybody if they can’t — or won’t — run hard to first base, and they won’t catch anybody if they can’t even catch the ball.
Vogelsong deserves a lot of praise and a lot of credit for the effort and his performance tonight because it was inspiring on every level. But he also deserves an apology because his teammates let him down and spoiled what should have been a signature moment for him.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.