Which people — not just players — provided the most on-ice value to the Penguins in 2021-22 as they made the playoffs for the 16th straight year while also finishing with a top-10 season in franchise record in terms of points percentage?

Yeah, it might be hard to appreciate what these Penguins have done considering their alarming finish. But zoom out and it has been a pretty successful campaign for Mike Sullivan’s squad, especially given all those injuries and illnesses.

Anyway, in the final From The Point of the season, we bring you the second annual ranking of the Post-Gazette’s most valuable Penguins. Again, this is a regular-season honor recognizing the people most responsible for their on-ice success. It could be the captain, the coach or a fourth-liner or even the Zamboni drivers.

The panel included columnists Joe Starkey and Ron Cook, my partner on the beat in Mike DeFabo and Jason Mackey, the only person I know who can still name five Pirates. We each submitted a list of seven people, in order. I then used a weighted 10-7-5-4-3-2-1 point system to determine the PG’s consensus ranking.

Advertise with us

With so many players missing time, the team needed contributions from all over the place to make the playoffs. And that was reflected in our varied lists.

Thirteen different people or groups got at least one vote. They included Brian Boyle for providing leadership, Evan Rodrigues for helping to keep the team afloat with his awesome first half, general manager Ron Hextall for practicing patience and the team’s trainers and medical staff for their work behind the scenes.

The top seven, however, was a bunch of Cup-winners and an All-Star goalie.

7. Bryan Rust. After a slow start and a pair of injuries, Rust exploded in the second half. DeFabo, one of two panelists to put Rust on their ballots, argued that he added value in several areas, including both special teams units. “If the Penguins could clone Rust,” DeFabo said, “they’d solve a lot of their lineup issues.”

6. Evgeni Malkin. Malkin showed up on just one ballot. That belonged to Mackey. As Malkin often does, Mackey went off the grid, giving him a valuable third-place vote. “Production-wise, people forget he’s still a point-a-game player,” Mackey, our former Pens beat reporter, explained. “The Penguins are also at their deepest and most dangerous when Malkin is on, whether that’s the power play clicking or how Sullivan can stack out his lines knowing what Good Geno can bring.”

Advertise with us

5. Jake Guentzel. The All-Star and 40-goal scorer made four of five ballots and was placed as high as fourth on three of them. DeFabo was the only one to put him ahead of Kris Letang. “His production speaks for itself and his chemistry with Sidney Crosby is second to none,” DeFabo said, adding, “But beyond that, his team friendly contract makes him even more valuable. Good luck finding someone who can score a goal every other game and is making $6 million a year in his prime.”

4. Kris Letang. Letang, who set a career high in points at age 34, was one of four consensus selections. I ranked him third. So did Starkey. I’ll let Starkey make the case for him. “Letang remains top five in the NHL in ice time and most of it is quality ice time,” he said. “He’s as good as he ever was.” No objections here.

3. Mike Sullivan. The Cup-winning coach was actually tied for second in total voting points. Three panelists ranked Sullivan second. He did not receive a first-place vote, though, thus his placement at this spot. I’ll admit, I had difficulty deciding where to slot him, ultimately placing him sixth. It’s hard to ignore how Sullivan guided the Penguins through tough circumstances in the first half. Ditto for their freefall down the stretch. He remains a fine coach, but this season was a mixed bag.

2. Tristan Jarry. He went from playoff goat to All-Star goalie, rewarding the team for sticking with him. Time will tell if he returns in time to get a shot at postseason redemption. But every panelist felt he was one of the five people most responsible for them getting back there. One put him atop his list — Cook. “No one was under more pressure coming into the season. No one stood up to it more,” he said. “He saved the season when they were 5-6-4 by winning the next five games with three shutouts and two one-goal games. They never looked back. … I know Sid will be MVP because he is Sid, but Jarry gets my vote.” Geez. Spoiler alert, Ron.

1. Sidney Crosby. Yes, the captain takes this honor for the second straight year. We are sure that one day when he reflects on his many, many accomplishments, this will be right up there with the Cup rings and Olympic gold. Anyway, Crosby returned from offseason wrist surgery to lead the Penguins in scoring — and pushed them to a 40-21-7 record when in the lineup. Not too shabby for a 34-year-old.

Advertise with us

POINT SHOTS

• Watching Connor McDavid blow the doors off the Penguins defense brought back memories of just how physically dominant Crosby was during his athletic prime. He was definitely not as fast as McDavid. Few, if any, players in NHL history were. But his acceleration, edge work and puck protection were all incredible.

All that said, if I could pick one player for a winner-take-all game, I am still going with Sid. His NHL peers this week once again voted him as the most complete player in the league, even in Year 17. And I’m not going to argue with them.

• So Sullivan and the Penguins put Rust back on the top line? So what?

Given how the Penguins are performing right now, with lapses in energy and their attention to detail, it’s a little foolish to obsess over line combinations. At this point, their issues go well beyond which wingers should play with which center. It won’t matter unless the players buy back in both mentally and emotionally.

Advertise with us

• Fine. I get it. Talking lines is fun. And I do like Rust next to Crosby, even if it makes the lineup top-heavy. Guentzel, Crosby and Rust not only lit it up this season, but they’re also such tone-setters with their two-way play, their effectiveness of the forecheck and their commitment to generating offense down low.

Sullivan has to hope that somehow permeates the rest of his forward group.

• The Penguins didn’t seem to care too much about whether they faced Florida or New York in the first round. They knew both were formidable opponents. Me? I’d want no part of Igor Shesterkin, the Vezina favorite. Because even if they suddenly rediscovered their game, Shesterkin might steal the series anyway.

• I’m sticking with Colorado, my preseason pick to win the Cup. The East is wide open, with several strong teams. Whichever one makes it through will be running on fumes in the Finals. And the Avalanche, with a top-three NHL player in Nathan MacKinnon, and a big, deep, fast lineup will be too much to handle.

THREE STARS

Advertise with us

3. Rickard Rakell. The new guy has fit in just fine in Pittsburgh, understandably overlooked given the team’s struggles. Sure, he only has four goals. But he has nine assists, a few of them real beauties, while making his mark in other ways.

2. Casey DeSmith. In five starts since stepping in for the injured Jarry, DeSmith has eased concerns about the crease by stopping 172 of 183 shots. The postseason is a different animal. But it looks as if he might not end up being a liability.

1. Kris Letang. With his strong play the last three weeks, Letang has skated his way back into consideration for Norris Trophy ballots. He had a couple of breath-taking assists in recent games while also steadying defensively in time for the playoffs.

YOU ASKED…

Drew (@ayteekay247 on Twitter) asks: Theoretically, if Letang, Malkin and Rust all leave as free agents this summer, do you think the Penguins could rebuild with the $20 million or so in salary cap space that would be opened up?

Advertise with us

The Penguins will actually enter the offseason with nearly $30 million in cap space, per CapFriendly, but don’t get excited. In addition to those three, there are six other players currently on the NHL roster who are scheduled to be free agents. That is a lot of holes to plug, starting with their top blue-liner and No. 2 center.

But it is an opportunity for the Penguins to reshape their roster if they want, getting younger and deeper while potentially adding vets with different skill sets.

The free agent class is OK. There’s no in-their-prime superstar for them to woo. But there will be intriguing players at a lower price point, such as Vincent Trocheck, Andre Burakovsky, Andrew Copp and John Klingberg. They could take a step at a restricted free agent. Or they could try to land a bigger fish via trade.

STAT N’AT

1.22 – One more note about the PG’s team MVP. Crosby is averaging 1.22 points per game. That is his second highest-average in the past eight seasons.

Advertise with us

FINAL BUZZER

If you are a regular reader of this column, first off, thank you. Second, you probably know I am pretty measured with my takes. I try to not speak in absolutes.

So I am still not ready to say with complete certainty that these Penguins are done, not with Crosby still leading the way.

But, man, do they sure look done.

The mental miscues and risky gambles made chasing goals are a major worry, no doubt. But what has been so jarring to see the last month is the lack of energy and urgency from a veteran club. They often look tired, old and a little slow.

Advertise with us

Maybe they flip the proverbial switch, embrace the underdog label and go on a run. It’s not impossible. But another first-round exit seems much more likely.

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.