Decades before he took the reins as Penguins general manager, Jim Rutherford sat at the bargaining table with the club’s first GM, Jack Riley.
When his NHL career began, Rutherford wasn’t yet the savvy negotiator who built three Stanley Cup-winning hockey teams to earn an enshrinement in the Hockey Hall of Fame. The goalie took the first offer set on the table soon after the Red Wings drafted him 10th overall in 1969. No agent. No counter offers. Nothing.
However, after a few years between the pipes and a move to Pittsburgh, Rutherford began to wise up to the business side of the game. In the early 1970s, contract talks with the Penguins reached a stalemate. It eventually led Rutherford to an arbitration hearing at Toronto’s Royal York hotel — this time with his agent, Bill Watters, by his side.
Both camps meticulously laid out their prepared cases. They presented their rebuttals. But something in the room didn’t feel right.
“You go through this whole process,” Rutherford said. “Low and behold, at one point during the arbitration, we realized that Jack Riley and the arbitrator were very close friends.”
Well, so much for the idea of an independent person to settle the dispute. After fighting over about $10,000, the two sides decided to just meet in the middle.
Read More
“What a difference. Just in legal fees alone, we pay like $50,000 to build our case for arbitration now,” Rutherford said. “Here I was fighting over $10,000.”
The NHL’s salary arbitration hearings began Tuesday, and the players involved will find a much different landscape. The salaries are higher. The stakes are greater. To get to this point, however, took decades and several messy labor disputes.
In some ways, it’s almost comical how little leverage players had until relatively recently. Through the ’70s and ’80s, there was no salary disclosure. That kept income down and also made it almost impossible to compare players at arbitration. So-called “live” stats such as blocked shots, hits and even ice time were kept in-house by the league until the early 1990s, so players couldn’t use those quantifiable metrics to back their assertions.
And, as Rutherford found out the hard way, it took all the way until the 1992 strike for players to finally earn the right to an impartial arbitrator from the National Academy of Arbitrators.
That final step was the key turning point to creating a level playing field for players. From 1992 to 2004, arbitration became a powerful and relatively common tool for players. Players with Penguins connections won some of the most lucrative arbitration rulings during that span. Mark Recchi earned what was at the time a record $4.5 million award from the Montreal Canadiens in 1998. Bill Guerin pulled in $5.1 million from the Bruins in 2001, at that time the second-richest arbitration ruling.
Today, arbitration remains a key piece of offseason negotiations but a far less common one. Since the 2004 lockout changed the unrestricted free agent age from 31 to 27, fewer years of team control means fewer messy contract disputes that need an independent party to settle. In 2004, 19 players earned awards at arbitration. Just six did last year.
The Penguins fall in line with this league-wide trend. In Rutherford’s six-year tenure as Penguins general manager, five players have had an arbitration hearing scheduled. All were avoided. That includes last season when he inked Zach Aston-Reese to a one-year contract just moments before the hearing was set to begin.
Once again, the Penguins avoided arbitration this offseason, even though they entered the offseason with a number of significant restricted free agents. That was partially by design. They traded Matt Murray, signed Jared McCann to an extension and chose not to issue a qualifying offer to Dominik Simon.
The decision with Simon, in particular, was the most direct link to arbitration and the club’s desire to avoid it. As a result of letting Simon become an unrestricted free agent, the Penguins took control over their salary cap situation, which is always dangerously close to the upper limit. It also gave them a clear budget to take advantage of the buyer’s market in free agency that was created by the flat $81.5 million cap.
Not convinced the Penguins should have let Simon walk? The three players whom the Penguins signed instead — Evan Rodrigues, Cody Ceci and Mark Jankowski — are three interesting case studies in arbitration and why the Penguins look like they made the right move from a cost-saving standpoint.
Consider that Rodrigues won an arbitration case for $2 million last year from the Buffalo Sabres. The Penguins got him for $700,000 on the open market. Ceci won $4.3 million in an arbitration case with the Ottawa Senators in 2018-19. The Penguins signed him for $1.25 million. Two years ago, Jankowski had an arbitration meeting scheduled with the Calgary Flames and applied his leverage into a two-year, $1.675-million deal that narrowly avoided it. The Penguins signed him for $700,000.
Looking ahead to next year, John Marino, Teddy Blueger, Jankowski and Aston-Reese are some of the most significant restricted free agents. If history is any indication, Rutherford will work to avoid arbitration again.
After the way his first experience with arbitration unfolded in the 1970s, can you blame him?
Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.