The North American sports world felt the first ripple of the COVID-19 pandemic in a most trivial way: hockey sticks.

As the virus began to spread, several of the major hockey equipment manufacturers closed their Chinese facilities. Many players worried the missing link in the supply chain might create a shortage of their favorite gear. Before long, they wouldn’t need their sticks at all.

By Friday, March 13, sports stood still. Games were canceled. Leagues suspended. Stadiums empty.

Now, almost seven weeks have passed and a popular question is growing louder and louder: When is it all coming back?

Advertise with us

It's impossible to say for sure. But optimism is growing. The NHL released a memo on Wednesday saying it hopes players can return to team facilities at some point in May, as long as everything continues on its current trajectory. Likewise, Major League Baseball reportedly is making plans to return at some point this summer, as well.

Two infectious disease doctors in the Pittsburgh area — Dr. Gavin Harris from UPMC and Dr. Tom Walsh from Allegheny Health Network — helped to explain the unique challenges associated with this virus and what factors will need to be considered before sports can return.

The bigger the game, the bigger the risk

The sight of 70,000 fans packed inside Heinz Field, screaming and waving Terrible Towels is what makes sports in the Steel City special. It’s also the problem.

“Sporting events will be one of the largest type of gatherings you can have, especially when you’re talking about so many people in a really tight setting,” Dr. Walsh said.

Advertise with us

Sneezing, coughing or even cheering produces respiratory droplets that could waft around in an enclosed environment. This virus, in particular, adds a new layer of risk for two reasons. It has been known to remain active on surfaces for hours — or even days. And it can be spread by people who show very mild symptoms or no symptoms at all.

“The majority of people that are infected don’t know that they’re posing a risk to others,” Dr. Walsh said. “They may be spreading the virus just by touching their face and touching different surfaces. At a large public gathering, such as a sporting event, there are a lot of people touching those same surfaces over and over again.”

The beauty of sports is that it brings people together from all over the country and sometimes all over the world. But in this scenario, Dr. Harris said that’s not always a good thing. People from different communities could come to the same mass gathering and become exposed unknowingly. When they travel home, they could be the spark what turns into an “additional wave” of the virus in their home city and, possibly, in every train, bus or plane they travel in along the way.

Eliminate the fans, decrease the risk

As the outbreak began to hit U.S. shores, mass sporting events with fans were one of the first things health experts recommended eliminating. Fans will likely be one of the last things to come back, too.

Advertise with us

But that doesn’t mean there won’t be any sports.

“The biggest challenge with this to begin with would have been to the fans,” Dr. Walsh said. “The way it would appear sports on a large scale would be able to return would be to really limit it to players, coaches, umpires, referees and other essential personnel where you’d have more control over being able to perform social distancing.”

The nation’s top infectious disease physician, Dr. Anthony Fauci, recently said he could envision sports returning this summer under a very specific set of circumstances. No fans. Players quarantined in hotels. Plenty of testing.

This so-called “bubble” scenario has been floated in a couple major professional leagues. The NHL is reportedly exploring the idea of playing in a handful of “hub” cities where the risk of the virus isn’t quite as significant. Major League Baseball reportedly has several ideas on the table, including playing in one location, like Arizona.

“What you may see is screening everyone when they’re entering,” Dr. Walsh said. “Maybe even screening again a week later and really limiting the ability of those people to interact with anyone outside of that cohort. If everybody there does not have an infection and they’re not really interacting with other people, the ability to introduce virus would be very low.

Advertise with us

“But you’d also have to be very vigilant about looking for fevers and other symptoms, so that when somebody may begin developing symptoms, you rapidly test and isolate again any of those individuals.”

These bubble scenarios have never been tried in the sports world. However, similar testing, sanitizing and isolating techniques have been employed effectively at hospitals when they’re dealing with viruses and other diseases.

It makes sense in theory and in models. But, as Dr. Harris said, these are people, not numbers on a spreadsheet. They could be affected “psychologically” by living in a bubble for months on end.

“The world that we're talking about would not allow these players to see their families for a period of time while they're sequestered,” Dr. Harris said. “I think that's a big deal that we often might miss.”

So why not just let players bring their families? Well, each additional person who joins the “bubble” increases the scale and, therefore, risk. All these factors need to be weighed before a league chooses to pull the trigger.

Advertise with us

“For the fans themselves, I think it'd be fantastic, because in this country right now, we're really deprived of sports,” Dr. Harris said. “They fill such a big part of our lives and there's been really a hole. We could give people some hope, give people some diversion and give people really a sense of oneness.

“But again, I think we have to temper it with the risks. We could end up having these players become exposed and then really having a disease run rampant through an entire team, even though they're kind of sequestered and isolated.”

Testing makes it possible

In these hypothetical scenarios, medical professionals would need to monitor heart rates, blood pressure and temperatures daily. Equipment like pads, balls, bats and other gear would all need to be sanitized much more thoroughly and frequently.

But beyond that, before leagues can be opened up, testing is the most critical factor.

Advertise with us

“I think the rapidity and the scale of testing definitely needs to improve,” Dr. Harris said. “And I think that really is applicable to any aspect of our society right now.”

Because so many people have very mild symptoms or no symptoms at all, it’s the only way to know for sure who has been exposed to the virus. This comes in two forms. The most common form of testing right now is polymerase chain reaction (PCR), in which a swab is inserted inside an individual’s nose to detect active virus. The other form of testing that’s being explored now is serologic testing, which measures antibodies.

“I think we need more data and more studies to show, does that positive antibody equate to immunity?” Dr. Walsh said. “We know for other infections it does. But sometimes it does not necessarily mean that you’re immune.”

Dr. Harris said that the rapidity and scale of testing needs to improve, not just in sports but in all aspects of society.

“The issue is that there are a lot of tests that have not been validated by the FDA, so they are of dubious quality,” Dr. Harris said. “I think that's something we also need to be aware of, in terms of thinking about rapid diagnostic tests.”

Advertise with us

What the sports community — and the world as a whole — really needs is widely available, highly reliable, rapid tests to identify individuals who are exposed and keep them from infecting others.

Even for the young and healthy, there are risks to consider

For the most part, young, healthy individuals have better outcomes when they’re infected than older individuals with pre-existing conditions.

Sure, most athletes are, indeed, young and healthy. However, the risks might be higher than it initially appears for some.

Type I diabetes is believed to be a risk factor. Several NHL players would fall into that category, including New York Rangers forward Kaapo Kakko, the No. 2 overall pick in the 2019 draft. It’s still unclear if asthma is a risk factor. But Penguins defenseman Zach Trotman keeps an inhaler in his locker to treat exercised-induced asthma.

Advertise with us

One of the cases the Penguins might also have to consider is Kris Letang. Doctors are now learning that COVID-19 can cause blood clots and, in some cases, strokes for young, healthy individuals.

In 2014, Letang suffered a stroke. It is believed that a very small hole in the wall of his heart led to a blood clot that was pumped to his brain.

Dr. Harris declined to address any specific cases but said in general the pre-existing conditions are “definitely something I think we should be cautious about.”

“I think it’s too early to say for sure whether those might be deal breakers in allowing athletes or players to compete in sports," he said. "But I think it's definitely something that needs to be looked at before we think about opening up some of these sports.”

The other factor for the sports community is the age of the coaches and front office personnel. In the NHL, for example, four coaches are 60 or older, including 65-year-old Dallas Stars coach Rick Bowness. Penguins Hall of Fame general manager Jim Rutherford is 71.

Advertise with us

“That equates a lot to why we had to close down schools,” Dr. Walsh said. “There may not be as much risk to the young, healthy teenager or 20-year-old, 30-year-old. But if that person may be infected, they might have very mild symptoms and now they’re interacting with a person who is more likely to have a bad outcome.”

Different sports will face different obstacles

Both doctors agree that the unique differences between sports will mean they’ll need to be treated differently. For example, golf can be played in an open field with athletes wearing masks and no fans. That’s very different than 85 scholarship football players on a campus with 40,000 students.

“Something like baseball may be facing unique challenges based on the number of games and the number of cities that they’re in,” Dr. Walsh said. “Whereas something like football may be a little different because you’re in your own city most of the time. You’re traveling to one city one a week for two or three days, where you’re able to more easily socially isolate and socially distance.”

This all leads us to one critical question that most everyone in Western Pennsylvania wants to know: Are we going to see the Steelers this fall?

Advertise with us

“Looking in the fall, I think optimistically there may be an ability to have football,” Dr. Walsh said. “The way we’re trending in the United States, I don’t know how hopeful I would be that you’re going to have fans in stadiums. But I believe there may be an opportunity with more large-scale testing and the ability to cohort to have some sort of product.”

When will this all go away?

While both doctors are optimistic that there can be some type of sporting events on TV sooner than later, returning to a normal schedule with travel and fans could take some time.

Dr. Walsh said the sports world won’t completely return to normal until “we really have an effective vaccine or really effective therapeutics to treat people quickly when they develop symptoms.”

“I think we would really need to have much more wide-spread testing so we can easily detect who is infected and have them isolated at that time,” he said. “We would also need to have either a vaccine, which is probably 12 to 18 months from when it started being worked on, or effective therapeutics.”

Advertise with us

Dr. Harris echoed some of those same sentiments.

“Honestly, I think we need to be smart about it,” Dr. Harris said. “I think we need to be safe about it. I'm worried that we may have secondary waves and peaks and valleys in terms of numbers of cases”

Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo.