In the summer of 2017, Jim Rutherford shrugged off the most scrutinized decision of his tenure as Penguins general manager. To him, it was a no-brainer.

Marc-Andre Fleury was a homegrown All-Star who bloomed out of the dark days before Sidney Crosby. He was one of the most beloved athletes in Pittsburgh. Without him, the Penguins would not have three of their five Stanley Cups, and Rutherford might not have a bronze bust in the Hall of Fame.

But Matt Murray, the only goalie in NHL history to win the Cup twice as a rookie, was 10 years younger, much cheaper and significantly steadier.

So Rutherford did what most, if not all, of the league’s other GMs would have done. He let Fleury leave for Las Vegas and committed to Murray as the Penguins’ goalie of the future. After all, the skinny, unshakable 23-year-old seemed poised to blast off to a Vezina-caliber level and orbit up there for a decade.

Advertise with us

“If you’re asking if he took a step forward, I would say no, he did not,” said NBC Sports analyst Brian Boucher, the former Philadelphia Flyers goalie, last week.

Unexpectedly, the Penguins are approaching another crossroads in the crease.

With Murray and All-Star backup Tristan Jarry both scheduled to be restricted free agents whenever this offseason takes place, Rutherford and the Penguins face a much more complicated decision than the one three summers ago.

Murray, with two Cups under his belt, wants big bucks in his bank account. And the Penguins must decide how much money they are willing to spend to reaffirm their commitment to an inconsistent regular season performer who ranks 37th in the NHL in save percentage over the three seasons since Fleury left.

“I thought he would really run with things and be a goaltender that plays 60-plus games. That hasn’t happened yet. That doesn’t mean it can’t happen,” said NHL Network analyst Brian Lawton, the former NHL player, GM and agent.

Advertise with us

Lawton added: “He’s a year from [unrestricted free agency]. So that’s going to make this situation dicey for Jim Rutherford and the Pittsburgh Penguins.”

If they can’t find common ground, might Murray be elsewhere next season?

Failure to launch

When it comes to the playoffs, Murray has arguably been the best in the business since 2016, when he became one of the youngest goalies in NHL history to start a playoff game. Murray is 28-19 all-time with a .921 save percentage. In six of his 12 starts in the Stanley Cup final, he had a shutout or allowed one goal.

“Pretty damn good, obviously,” Sportsnet analyst and ex-NHL goalie Corey Hirsch said. “He’s like Gerry Cheevers and Billy Smith. They were very average regular season goalies but when the Cup was on the line, you wanted one of those two guys in your net. His regular seasons have been very inconsistent.”

Advertise with us

Murray had his best one in 2016-17, while Fleury was still around to push him for playing time. He set his career highs with 32 wins, a .923 save percentage and a 2.41 goals-against average before winning another Cup-clinching game.

The following regular season — as Fleury led the first-year Golden Knights all the way to the Stanley Cup final — Murray’s save percentage dipped to .907.

In 2018-19, Murray got off to a dreadful start then spent a month on injured reserve. He was stellar in the season’s second half, pulling the Penguins into the playoffs and his save percentage up to .919. But this season, he went through another November swoon and watched Jarry bump him to the bench.

Murray’s .899 save percentage ranked 50th out of 57 qualifying goalies when the league suspended its season March 12 due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Boucher said opponents pick up on vulnerabilities and goalies must adapt.

Advertise with us

Murray’s glove remains an issue, though that’s common for bigger butterfly goalies. He’s not the smoothest while moving side to side. And when his confidence in himself or his teammates wanes, he tends to drift deeper into his crease.

“There’s been changes [to the NHL’s style of play] that haven’t exactly helped Matt Murray,” Hirsch said. “He’s got a pretty wide stance and the game’s become quicker and more lateral. So he might have to make some tweaks.”

One silver lining in what could be a lost season is that Murray stayed healthy. He was previously sidelined by that nagging lower-body injury last season, a broken hand in 2016 and three documented concussions, among other injuries.

“I don’t have any question that Matt Murray has the capability to win the big game. He’s proven it twice now,” Boucher said. “But I think he is a guy that needs to share the load during the regular season. [The regular season] is a whole different animal. It’s a big process to go through to get to [the playoffs].”

Boucher would know. He burst onto the scene in 1999-2000 and was stellar as the Flyers came within a game of the Cup final. He couldn’t replicate it in the regular season, lost his starting spot to Roman Cechmanek and was eventually traded. He lasted 13 years in the NHL but never became an established starter.

Advertise with us

“I know this sounds crazy, but in the playoffs, it can almost be easier. … What’s difficult is when it’s October, November, December, when you don’t have 100% buy-in from everyone,” Boucher said. “Can you be a guy that keeps your team afloat when maybe they don’t have their A-game or their B-game?”

Five seasons into his career, Murray hasn’t done that often enough, at least not for someone who hopes to be among the highest-paid goalies in hockey.

What’s Murray worth?

Given his spotty play in the regular season and his two sparkling Cup runs, good luck finding a contemporary comp to Murray, who turns 26 in May.

That dichotomy led contract talks with the Penguins to stall last summer.

Advertise with us

Back in 2016, after Murray won his first Stanley Cup, the Penguins talked Murray and his representatives into signing a bridge deal similar to what Tampa Bay had just given its budding youngster, Andrei Vasilevskiy. Over the last three seasons, Murray earned an average annual salary of $3,750,000.

Vasilevskiy has been one of the NHL’s best regular season goalies since then. He earned three straight All-Star nods and won the Vezina Trophy in 2018-19.

Last summer, the Lightning rewarded him with an eight-year extension that will pay him $9.5 million annually. Only a pair of fellow Vezina winners in Montreal’s Carey Price and Florida’s Sergei Bobrovsky will make more in 2020-21.

Murray was watching. He sought something in the same stratosphere, certainly a higher salary than what Anaheim goalie John Gibson makes. The Ducks are paying the Whitehall native an average of $6.4 million through 2026-27.

“If I was [his agent] a few months ago, I would have been screaming ‘Vasilevskiy’ as a comparable,” Lawton said. “You can say his numbers are better, his team is better. But you can also answer back that Matt has two Stanley Cups.”

Advertise with us

The Penguins were unconvinced then. It’s unlikely this season swayed them.

“I’m all for goalies getting paid because I was one,” Hirsch said, chuckling. “But Matt Murray didn’t do himself any favors this year. He just didn’t. So you can’t give him that kind of money in my eyes. He’s going to have to back it up. He’s put himself in a position where he’s got to prove that he’s still what he was.”

Boucher, pointing to Murray’s injury history as one reason for the Penguins to be hesitant, wondered if they would even be willing to top $6 million a year.

“In a perfect world, you’d keep Murray and Jarry as a great 1A-1B combination. I think that would be the best scenario going forward,” Boucher said. “But you just wonder if that’s something Matt Murray wants to do. ‘Do I want to get paid or do I want to be on a [contender] but I may share the workload?’”

The NHL is trending toward timeshares, anyway. Last season, only 10 goalies made 55 starts or more. Minnesota’s Devan Dubnyk led the league with 66.

Advertise with us

If Murray is back on an expiring deal, he can salvage his value. Lawton said Murray and his agent should be comfortable with that, knowing big bucks may await him in the 2021 offseason, when Murray reaches unrestricted free agency. And with Seattle joining the NHL, another expansion draft looms next summer.

Maybe Murray has a monster season and takes the Penguins on another deep playoff run, raising his price tag closer to Vasilevskiy’s. At that point, Rutherford may just have to tip his cap as Murray skates away to another team.

Or maybe it’s another “meh” regular season, and this is simply who Murray is — a pretty good NHL goalie, not an elite one worth one-tenth of your payroll.

An uncertain future

Jarry will also want a raise — maybe more playing time, too — after he became an All-Star this season, something Murray hasn’t done. Jarry also set the longest shutout streak in team history, and his .921 save percentage ranks eighth in the NHL.

Advertise with us

But while Murray could be awarded a 2020-21 salary of $6 million or more if he goes to arbitration this summer, Jarry will have little leverage if he does.

Precedent has been set that if a goalie starts fewer than 41 games in a season, he is considered a backup. So Jarry, who turns 25 later this month, may be looking at a short-term deal between $2 million and $3 million in arbitration.

A pricey offer sheet from another team would put the Penguins in a pinch. But they are rarely signed by restricted free agents. It’s happened only once since 2013.

So the Penguins will probably be able to keep both goalies around for another season. Do they want to? Or will they look to trade one? With the 2019-20 season not yet canceled, Rutherford politely declined an interview last week.

The Penguins dealing Murray, while not out of the question, seems unlikely.

Advertise with us

“Goaltending, it’s still between the ears. And this is a guy that’s won two Stanley Cups,” Hirsch said. “So it would be pretty hard to just give up on that.”

Still, both Boucher and Hirsch independently wondered what they could get for him. Buffalo, Chicago, Detroit, Edmonton, Minnesota, Ottawa and San Jose are teams that could be looking for a long-term answer between their pipes.

“If you have enough confidence in Tristan, you could probably get some pretty good players for Matt Murray. I think you can, anyway,” Hirsch said. “If you’re Buffalo, Murray is 25 years old. He’s got seven or eight pretty good years more in him. He’s a competitive guy. I would take a chance on that. Why not?”

Jarry impressed both of those former puck-stoppers turned talking heads, though across the board his numbers after Jan. 1 were a tick below Murray’s.

“He’s really talented. I love the way he handles the puck,” Boucher said. “He seems to be a pretty calm kid, seems pretty business-like. He’s progressing along nicely. … It would be interesting to see if he was handed the keys to the car, could he be the guy that can carry them? I certainly think he has the ability.”

Advertise with us

He added: “My only question about him is handling the increased workload.”

Behind Murray and Jarry, the Penguins have Casey DeSmith under contract at an affordable $1.25 million salary for another two seasons. Veteran Dustin Tokarski and Finnish rookie Emil Larmi also suited up for their American Hockey League affiliate in 2019-20. Rutherford has picked just one goalie in six drafts.

All that said, the Penguins could just run it back with Murray and Jarry and worry about it later. After all, Rutherford — a former NHL goalie who knows the value of a big save — intends to chase that Cup as long as Crosby and Evgeni Malkin are still going strong. That’s why he hung on to Fleury for as long as he could.

“You could still have another season with these two guys together,” Hirsch said. “Eventually, one is going to have to go. That’s inevitable. But when is that?”

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.