The ability to respond to adversity defined the Penguins through the first part of the 2019-20 season.

When injuries to their biggest names and best players piled up, somehow, so too did the wins. They overcame Evgeni Malkin’s monthlong absence. They posted the most points in December even without Sidney Crosby. When two-time Stanley Cup-winning goalie Matt Murray slumped, Tristan Jarry turned himself into an All-Star.

Now, with just 14 games left, a team that has overcome so much this season has encountered its biggest obstacle: itself.

On Sunday, the Penguins were routed, 6-2, by the Carolina Hurricanes in a game that turned in the second period, with a post on one end and a penalty on the other. This came about 24 hours after the Penguins weren’t just beaten by the Washington Capitals, they were bullied in their own building. Two Metro Division opponents. Two losses.

Advertise with us

Less than three weeks ago, the Penguins (39-23-6) sat atop the Metropolitan Division and looked every bit like a Stanley Cup contender. Now, they’re going to have to take a long look in the mirror after losing their eighth game in 10 outings.

For a team that overcame so much early in the season, how the Penguins answer the latest test very well might define how this season is remembered.

“We’ve got to make sure we respond the right way to the adversity,” coach Mike Sullivan said. “I think that’s the most important takeaway. We’re obviously not thrilled with the position we’re in over the last few weeks. We all have to take ownership for it. We’ve got to take responsibility for pulling ourselves out of it.”

The reasons for Sunday’s loss were multiple. For one, a power play unit that has been inconsistent at best – and anemic at worst – this season went just 1-for-7. Dating back to the Feb. 20 loss in Toronto that started the tailspin, the power play is just 5-for-38 (13.2%). They’ve also allowed two short-handed goals in the last three games.

“We had a lot of chances tonight,” defenseman Justin Schultz said. “Just getting out-worked I think and not getting enough shots through.”

Advertise with us

But really, the power-play struggles are almost to be expected at this point.

What’s hard to rationalize is how a team that was able to overcome those early injuries by cutting down on odd-man rushes, winning puck battles, limiting turnovers and generally playing the simple game that Sullivan has preached has lost touch with its identify. And it’s happened overnight and at one of the most critical junctures of the season.

Aside from the fact that 40-goal-scorer Jake Guentzel is sidelined, which is obviously a huge loss, the Penguins might be the healthiest they’ve been all season. Adding reinforcements from injured reserve like Brian Dumoulin and John Marino – coupled with deadline additions of Jason Zucker, Patrick Marleau, Conor Sheary and Evan Rodrigues – figured to be the shot-in-the arm that would help propel what was already being touted as a Stanley Cup contender.

Somehow, it’s the opposite. The Penguins have seemingly come undone just as they’ve finally gotten healthy.

“There are details of our game that have slipped that we have to get back to to be the team that we want to be,” Sullivan said.

Advertise with us

Sunday's game started out promisingly enough. Marleau scored his first goal as a Penguins. Malkin ripped top shelf on a 5-on-3 power play to send the Penguins to the dressing room with a 2-1 lead.

But after Carolina’s Jaccob Slavin tied the game at 2, things changed about as quickly as the outlook on the season.

During the second period, Rodrigues – who was one of the best Penguins on the ice for a good portion of the game, drawing three penalties himself – collected a pass from Brandon Tanev and fired it off the iron. But after nearly giving the Penguins a one-goal lead during a short-handed situation, he committed a holding penalty.

Carolina defenseman Jake Gardiner took advantage, blasting a shot over Jarry’s right shoulder to give the Hurricanes a 3-2 lead. Jarry finished the day making 30 of 36 saves for his fourth consecutive loss.

Instead responding in the third period, the Penguins came completely unhinged. Justin Williams scored twice and Morgan Geekie, who scored his first career goal in his first career game in the first period, padded his career stats with a second goal late.

Advertise with us

“Tonight, I thought we had a pretty good start,” Zucker said. “We started chasing the game after they got a couple. Started forcing plays and trying to do things that are not like us. That got us in even more of a deeper hole.”

The Penguins remain in third place in the Metropolitan Division with 84 points.

At least for now, a playoff berth isn’t in serious trouble. However, the way the Penguins performance has regressed of late, they need to get it together if they hope to do more than just earn an invite to the dance.

“We hit a slump,” defenseman Marcus Pettersson said. “We’re the only ones that can get out of it. There’s nobody else. It’s us in this room. We’ve got to push back here and accept the challenge.”

Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo.