Mike Sullivan discusses ovetime loss to Islanders

As well as the Penguins have played this season, with maybe one or two glaring exceptions, they still have squandered a handful of points in the standings.

There were two tough losses in Florida. Goalies from Vegas and Edmonton stole wins from them. Shaky goaltending spoiled their comeback in Boston.

And then there was Tuesday, when they coughed up a late two-goal lead before losing, 5-4, in overtime to the New York Islanders at PPG Paints Arena.

Josh Bailey scored with 4:19 left in regulation, just after a penalty to Bryan Rust expired, to make it a one-goal game. With New York’s goalie pulled for an extra attacker, Ryan Pulock ripped a shot from the point through Matt Murray, who said it nicked a shin guard and changed direction, to tie it with 1:32 left.

Advertise with us

After a giveaway by Justin Schultz in OT, Brock Nelson followed up on his shot and poked the puck sitting behind Murray into the net to stun the Penguins.

“It sucks. I thought we were in control there but it slipped away,” Schultz said. “It doesn’t feel good right now. We’ll learn from it and try to get better.”

The Penguins did appear to have a second straight victory in their grasp. But it began slipping through their fingers when Rust was called for tripping with 6:23 left in regulation after he got tangled up with Nick Leddy of the Islanders.

“The ref saw it one way,” the winger said. “I was just trying to play hard.”

The Penguins killed that penalty, making it 23 straight over the last 10 games, but Bailey scored four seconds after Rust busted out of the box. They had four defenders back as two Islanders entered their zone. But Jordan Eberle bought time and the Penguins lost track of Bailey, who buried his backhand pass.

Advertise with us

“The third goal, I think, was the killer,” coach Mike Sullivan said. “For the most part, I thought we did a really good job on the penalty kill. The penalty was about to expire. It was a 2-against-4 rush. We just have to do a better job.”

Still, the Penguins were in position to escape with a win. The Islanders pulled Semyon Varlamov for an extra attacker at the 2:27 mark and for nearly a minute the Penguins prevented them from getting the puck anywhere near Murray.

But a pair of icing infractions meant they couldn’t get Teddy Blueger’s line and blue-liner Marcus Pettersson off the ice. They chased around the Islanders for nearly two minutes before Pulock’s slapper from 46 feet made it through.

“I think we got tired at the end,” Sullivan said. “If we could have gained the blue line and gotten a line change, I think we would have been alright.”

For the Penguins, overtime was a mess. The Islanders controlled play in the extra period because the Penguins lost two faceoffs and gave the puck away. Murray made a couple of big saves. But after another turnover by Schultz, Nelson’s shot dropped into the blue paint behind Murray. Nelson got to the puck first.

Advertise with us

“They kept coming. You’ve got to give credit to them, too. That’s a good team over there. They’re on that run for reason,” said Murray, who made four of his 37 saves in OT. “They kept coming at us and gave us all we could handle.”

The structured, stingy Islanders entered Tuesday with victories in 13 of their last 14 games. Their lone loss during that span came Nov. 7 in Brooklyn, when the Penguins rallied back from a 3-0 deficit in the third period before beating them in overtime. They had given up 25 goals in the 13 games against other teams.

For 55 minutes, the Penguins appeared to have the Islanders’ number again.

During the first period, Bryan Rust scored on a power play, snapping a shot from the high slot past Varlamov’s glove, and Brandon Tanev tipped a John Marino shot through the goalie’s legs to put the Penguins up, 2-0, after one period.

The Islanders answered early in the second with two quick goals from Anthony Beauvillier and Nelson, who redirected Leddy’s shot over Murray’s left pad.

Advertise with us

Tanev gave the Penguins the lead back with 5:29 left in the second. After Dominik Kahun and he battled to win back the puck behind the Islanders’ net, the winger scored his second by banking a wraparound off the skate of an Islander.

The free-agent addition has four points in two games since Sullivan, who was looking for more physicality and feistiness on Pittsburgh’s second line, moved Tanev back up in the lineup to play with Kahun and center Jared McCann.

Jake Guentzel made it 4-2 with a power-play goal 2:39 into the third period. After the Penguins gained the blue line, Alex Galchenyuk slid a pass to Guentzel, who made a quick deke then shot inside the left post for his 10th of the season.

The Penguins now have a power-play goal in three of their last four games despite being without regulars Sidney Crosby, Kris Letang and Patric Hornqvist.

But they would blow that two-goal lead to their Metropolitan Division rivals.

Advertise with us

“When we got up, 4-2, they turned it up a notch,” said Rust, who has a point in eight of 10 games since returning from injury. “And we didn’t match it.”

The Penguins, now 11-7-3, will play the Islanders again Thursday in New York.

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.