TORONTO — Monday was one of the greatest nights of Jim Rutherford’s career, a tribute to a legendary hockey life highlighted by three Stanley Cup titles and a chance to thank the many, many people who helped him get up there on that stage.
It also was, in his words, “probably the toughest seven minutes of my career.”
Two hours before the ceremony, the 70-year-old was antsy about his speech. He typically likes to speak off the cuff. But he wanted notes Monday night.
“It’s a one-in-a-lifetime speech. There’s been so many people that have touched my life and my career. … I don’t want to miss anybody,” he told the Post-Gazette before climbing in a limousine that took him to the Hockey Hall of Fame. “But I’m looking forward to it because this is what I’ve worked for and earned.”
Technically, his speech lasted nine minutes, 45 seconds. And he nailed it.
Welcome to the @HockeyHallFame, Jim Rutherford. pic.twitter.com/7Pol1oeaKC
— Pittsburgh Penguins (@penguins) November 19, 2019
After Rutherford was handed his Honored Members plaque by Penguins owner and a fellow Hall of Famer in Mario Lemieux early on in the induction ceremony for the 2019 class, the GM spent much of his speech showing gratitude.
Read More
He thanked his parents and sisters for the support over the years and his wife and two children for talking him off the ledge after losses. Peter Karmanos, the man who gave him his first GM gig and his longtime mentor. Old coworkers and former players in Windsor, Hartford and Raleigh and current ones in Pittsburgh.
Heck, even Phil Kessel, Marc-Andre Fleury and Matt Cullen got shout-outs.
Rutherford, with his dry sense of humor, got laughs when he thanked his young son, James, who was sitting next to his wife, Leslie, and daughter, Andrea.
“Thank you for all those trades you recommend we make,” he said. “If we could actually make those trades, you’d probably be standing here someday.”
Rutherford, who has made many trades for the Penguins since 2014, was elected by an 18-member selection committee in the builders category in June.
Sergei Zubov, Hayley Wickenheiser, Vaclav Nedomansky, Guy Carbonneau and Jerry York joined him in the six-person class inducted Monday into the Hall. Zubov spent the 1995-96 season in Pittsburgh, tallying 66 points in 64 games.
Rutherford is the seventh general manager since the NHL expanded in 1967 to win at least three Stanley Cups, one in Carolina and two in Pittsburgh. He is the only GM in the post-expansion era to win a Cup with multiple teams.
Rutherford arrived Thursday in Toronto. When he walked into the official hotel for the Hall of Fame and saw on the walls pictures of those who went in before him, that’s when reality cross-checked him. This was actually happening.
He received his Hall of Fame ring a day later. The inductees were honored at the Toronto-Boston game Friday night then he ducked into a suite to watch on TV as his Penguins played the New Jersey Devils. Saturday was a fan forum.
After the alumni game Sunday, when he was handed his Hall of Fame watch and sports jacket, Penguins leadership, including coach Mike Sullivan, celebrated him at a dinner inside the Hall of Fame. They then attended Monday’s induction.
Throughout the weekend, Rutherford was surrounded by Leslie and his kids, along with a number of other relatives. He joked that it felt like a family reunion.
“I pulled on my first pair of skates when I was 5 years old in Beeton, about 60 miles north of here,” Rutherford said to open his speech. “I never could have imagined coming here one day to be inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame.”
Rutherford thanked his late parents, John and Dorothea, for their support.
“My family lived paycheck to paycheck,” he said. “But they always found a way to get me equipment and they took me to every game and every practice.”
Oh what a night! A warm hearted congratuations to the Class of 2019 🥂#HHOF2019 | #HHOF pic.twitter.com/NbNJLpPdrn
— Hockey Hall of Fame (@HockeyHallFame) November 19, 2019
Rutherford was drafted by the Detroit Red Wings in the first round in 1969. He played for four NHL teams, including the Penguins, before retiring at 33.
In 1984, Rutherford accepted his first job as a general manager, with the Windsor Spitfires of the Ontario Hockey League. In four seasons with the Spitfires, he was twice named the OHL’s executive of the year and in 1988 they swept through the OHL playoffs before coming oh-so close to winning the Memorial Cup.
When Karmanos, owner of the Spitfires, purchased the Hartford Whalers, he hired Rutherford to be his team president and GM. Three years later, in 1997, the franchise relocated to Raleigh, N.C. In addition to putting a good team on the ice, Rutherford had to help them carve out a foothold in NASCAR country.
In 2006, his Hurricanes, formerly the Whalers, won their only Stanley Cup.
Rutherford was at peace and considering retirement when the Hurricanes and he parted ways in 2014. Then the Penguins came calling. Five years later, there he stood Monday inside the Hall, enshrined alongside other legends.
Early in his Penguins tenure, Rutherford acquired through trades Kessel, Patric Hornqvist, Carl Hagelin, Nick Bonino, Justin Schultz and Trevor Daley to bolster the supporting cast around All-Stars Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang. He also hired Sullivan, “a very special coach,” midway through 2015-16.
The Penguins won the Cup in Rutherford’s second season in Pittsburgh and a year later they became the first team in the NHL’s salary-cap era to go back-to-back. After that first Cup in Pittsburgh, he won the NHL’s GM of the year award.
“My time in Pittsburgh has been the highlight of my career,” said Rutherford, who knows the two Cups he won there got him over the Hall of Fame hump.
He added that “the most special aspect of his career” is working with Crosby.
“It’s hard to put it into words, but everyone in Pittsburgh knows what I’m talking about,” he said. “It’s remarkable to be able to watch Sid day in and day out, to see his work ethic, to see the impact he has on the team and the city.”
With Crosby, Malkin, Letang and Sullivan still around him every day, Rutherford is not done trying to add another Cup or two to his Hall of Fame resume.
The final words of his induction speech showed that the scrappy former goalie still has a chip on his shoulder, something that has served him well.
“What I’ve learned the most in my life and my advice to people is don’t let anyone tell you you can’t do something. Because that was the story of my career,” he said. “The more they told me I couldn’t do things, the more it turned out that I did.”
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.