If there’s one thing that has defined Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford’s Hall of Fame career, it’s that he’s not afraid to make a deal.

In the five-plus years he’s spent running the Penguins, he’s made 42 trades and dozens of other decisions that helped maximize stars such as Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin and bring Pittsburgh two more Stanley Cups.

As Rutherford enters the Hockey Hall of Fame, we ranked some of his best moves in Pittsburgh. It wasn’t easy. Moves like picking up Matt Cullen from the scrap heap, fleecing the Edmonton Oilers for defenseman John Marino in exchange for just a sixth-round pick and acquiring speedy Swede Carl Hagelin made our list of honorable mentions. That alone shows some of why Rutherford has become a Hall of Fame general manger:

10. Ron Hainsey solidifies the blue line for another Cup run

Advertise with us

As the trade deadline approached in February 2017, the Penguins blue line needed to be addressed. Kris Letang was out with an injury that would keep him sidelined throughout the postseason and Trevor Daley was dealing with an injury of his own.

Insert Ron Hainsey. In exchange for a 2017 second-round pick and minor league forward Danny Kristo, the Penguins got a seasoned NHL veteran whose experience proved critical in helping Pittsburgh bring home its second Cup in two years.

9. Marcus Pettersson for Daniel Sprong

The Penguins traded offense for defense when they dealt young winger Daniel Sprong for young defensemen Marcus Pettersson. While Sprong tallied 19 points in his first 47 games for Anaheim last year, Pettersson has evolved into a top-four defenseman — and someone the Penguins would like to keep in the organization long term. This year, Sprong has yet to appear in an NHL game while Pettersson has provided stability to the Penguins blue line, making the trade look better and better as time goes on.

8. Cutting bait on Brassard, while adding McCann 

Advertise with us

When Rutherford realized Derick Brassard wasn’t a good fit in Pittsburgh, he turned one failed trade into one of his best. He shipped Brassard, Riley Sheahan and three 2019 draft picks to the Florida Panthers in exchange for Nick Bjugstad and Jared McCann.

While Bjugstad has become a third-line center who has tallied just one point this year, the McCann part of the trade has made the deal more than worth it. At 23 years old, McCann fits the mold as one of the younger, faster, tougher-to-play-against Penguins. He’s shown versatility to play center or wing and is third on the team with 12 points in 18 games.

7. The HBK line begins to form with the addition of Bonino

In July 2015, the Penguins acquired forward Nick Bonino, defenseman Adam Clendening and a 2016 second-round pick from the Vancouver Canucks in exchange for Brandon Sutter and a 2016 third-round pick.

The stats alone show the lopsided nature of the deal. Bonino recorded 66 points for the Penguins, while Sutter tallied 43 points for the Canucks during the same stretch. But more than that, Bonino became a major piece of the HBK line with Carl Hagelin and Phil Kessel. That balance across three lines made the Penguins a matchup nightmare and, eventually, two-time Cup champs.

Advertise with us

6. Trevor Daley heist

In December 2015, the Penguins swapped a struggling veteran defenseman in Rob Scuderi for a veteran defenseman in a bad situation in Trevor Daley. It became one of the more lopsided moves in Rutherford’s tenure. Daley fit perfectly with the speed game coach Mike Sullivan wanted to play. After recording just six assists in 29 games in Chicago, Daley put up 22 points in the final 53 games of the 2015-16 season and 19 points in 56 games in 2016-17 while helping the Penguins win back-to-back Cups.

5. Not trading Marc-Andre Fleury

One Rutherford’s best moves as a general manager was actually not a move at all.

When Marc-Andre Fleury suffered a concussion at the end of the season, rookie goalie Matt Murray stepped in to lead the Penguins to the franchise’s fourth Stanley Cup in 2016. Over the next year, trade rumors swirled. With the NHL expansion draft looming, the Penguins could only protect one goalie and risked losing Fleury for nothing.

Advertise with us

But instead of shipping Fleury at the deadline, Rutherford kept two top goaltenders. When Murray suffered an injury during the 2017 Cup run, that decision looked genius. Simply put, the Penguins don’t win a second Stanley Cup without Fleury there to step in.

4. A third-round pick for a top-four defenseman in Justin Schultz

When the Penguins gave up a third-round pick for Justin Schultz, Oilers fans and analysts were happy to simply rid themselves of the defenseman. Many said his play had devolved, as he posted just 10 points in 45 games prior to being moved.

The risk was minimal (just a third-round pick) and the price tag manageable after the Oilers agreed to retain about half of what was at the time a $3.9 million contract. But in Pittsburgh, Schultz has become one of the Penguins most valuable defensemen. And the trade turned out to be another heist for Rutherford.

After helping the Penguins win the Cup in 2016, Schultz enjoyed a breakout year in his first full season in Pittsburgh in 2016-17, setting career-highs in goals (12), assists (39), points (51). He proved invaluable when Kris Letang missed the 2017 postseason with a herniated disc.

Advertise with us

3. James Neal for Patric Hornqvist gamble pays off

Rutherford’s first move as the Penguins general manager turned out to be one of his best. In summer 2014, the Penguins acquired Patric Hornqvist and Nick Spaling in exchange for James Neal.

The move initially looked like a big risk. Neal was still just 26 at time, a six-time 20-goal scorer and a fan favorite. But over the years, the deal proved to be a win for Pittsburgh. Hornqvist has produced significantly for the Penguins, recording 242 points in his five-plus years here. But more than the production, he brought an edgy playing style, a willing agitator in front of the net and a voice of leadership in the locker room.

2. Mike Sullivan proves to be the change in leadership the Penguins needed

In December 2015, the Penguins were a star-laden team that was failing to live up to expectations. They were just 15-10-3 and in fifth place in the Metropolitan Division. Rutherford acted swiftly, firing Mike Johnston and promoting Sullivan from the club’s AHL affiliate in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton.

Advertise with us

Six months after the coaching shuffle, Sullivan was hoisting the Stanley Cup. And a year later, another one.

Sullivan has brought a competitive fire to the bench and a commanding voice that players respect. This offseason, Rutherford took steps to maintain that consistency by inking Sullivan to an extension through the 2023-24 season — a move that might make another one of these type of lists in a couple years.

1. The Kessel blockbuster

Before the 2015-16 season, Rutherford pulled off a blockbuster trade when the Penguins acquired Phil Kessel from the Toronto Maple Leafs.

The compensation, at least on its face, was significant. The Penguins gave up first- and third-round picks in the 2016 draft, Kasperi Kapanen (a first-round pick in the 2014 draft), plus defenseman Scott Harrington and forward Nick Spaling. In exchange, the Penguins received Kessel, forward Tyler Biggs, defenseman Tim Erixon and a second-round pick in the 2016 NHL draft.

Advertise with us

One of the key elements of the trade was that the Leafs agreed to retain $1.25 million of Kessel’s $8 million salary. Almost immediately the deal paid off — big.

During the 2016 Cup run, Kessel led the Penguins in playoff scoring with 10 goals and 22 points. Had Sidney Crosby not played out of his mind, there’s an argument to be made that Kessel deserved the Conn Smythe Trophy as the playoff MVP. He followed it up with another Stanley Cup in 2017.

In total, Kessel produced 303 points and 110 goals with the Penguins. While his tenure in Pittsburgh ended after a trade to Arizona, the contributions he made to two Stanley Cup runs — and to Rutherford’s Hall of Fame resume — shouldn’t be overlooked.

Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo.