In the summer before the 2015 season, the NHL Board of Governors changed the rules for overtime, moving the format from 4-on-4 to 3-on-3.
Here was the thinking: Eliminate a skater. Add some extra ice. And games that used to be decided in a shootout would instead be finalized in the five-minute overtime period.
Sure enough, the change worked… Just not from the Penguins’ point of view.
Tuesday night against the New York Islanders, Penguins defenseman Justin Schultz turned the puck over when trying to find Jake Guentzel exiting the zone. It created a 2-on-1 opportunity that Brock Nelson squeaked by Matt Murray for the decisive 4-3 overtime loss.
The Penguins (11-7-3) had already squandered a two-goal lead and wasted a two-goal night from Brandon Tanev, the 10th goal of Guentzel’s season and Bryan Rust’s 11th point in 10 games. But by failing to put the pieces back together in overtime, they also missed out on a critical second point on a night that Sidney Crosby, Patric Hornqvist, Kris Letang and Nick Bjugstad all sat out with injuries.
Asked how he would evaluate the overtime period, coach Mike Sullivan didn’t mince his words.
Read More
“I didn’t think we were very good at all,” Sullivan said. “I thought our details were brutal. We have to be better.”
The same could be said about the Penguins in overtime over the last 14 months, as Pittsburgh has struggled to get the extra point in games that have gone to overtime.
In 18 games that went beyond regulation last year, the Penguins lost 12 (nine in overtime and three in a shootout). They won just four in 3-on-3 situations and two in shootouts.
This year, the stats are slightly better. The Penguins have gone to overtime six times. They’ve now lost three in overtime. Twice they won in overtime. And once they won in a shootout.
“There’s not tons of strategy in overtime,” Sullivan said. “There’s only three people on the ice. You’ve got to defend when it’s called upon. You’ve got to support the puck. You’ve got to out-change a team. We did none of the above.”
Mike Sullivan discusses ovetime loss to Islanders
It’s a cruel irony in some ways. This season, the Penguins have worked hard to forge an identity as a team that plays a disciplined, structured brand of hockey. And for the most part, they have by cutting down odd-man rushes and opponents’ Grade-A scoring chances significantly from last year.
However, overtime is almost like a different sport.
Instead playing with “collective effort” as Sullivan has preached so much over the first two months of the season, the game really becomes almost like pickup hockey, where skill and individual effort replace the five men working in unison that typically defines winning hockey teams.
Sure, it can create a wildly exciting style of hockey for fans to watch. Earlier this year, the Penguins and Edmonton Oilers traded chance after chance in a fast and furious overtime period, which by the way, the Penguins also lost. But it’s still a different type of challenge for players who spend almost 5,000 minutes a year playing 5-on-5.
“OT is 3-on-3, man-on-man,” Evgeni Malkin said. “We’re a little bit confused, because in D zone on 5-on-5, we never play man-on-man. It’s still our job… Maybe we need to work a little bit more in practice.”
Every bounce is magnified in OT. Turning the puck over, like how the Penguins did at the end of the game doesn’t help. But Sullivan said it starts in the faceoff circle.
“Overtime is a lot about possession,” Sullivan said. “When you lose the faceoffs, you’re fighting for that possession constantly. It started there. We’ve got to be better on the faceoffs. But our attention to detail just wasn’t there.”
And because of that, neither was the second point.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.