Jake Guentzel is a Stanley Cup champion who’s been extremely productive in his three years with the Penguins. And yet some experts don’t feel he’s even in the top 20 at his position.
NHL.com’s David Satriano released his top 20 NHL wings list Sunday, and Guentzel’s name was nowhere to be found.
So, what do you think? #NHLTopPlayers pic.twitter.com/dkK26mRH9G
— NHL Network (@NHLNetwork) August 12, 2019
Some folks immediately balked at the notion of Guentzel not even cracking the top 20 of hockey’s best wings.
Jake Guentzel?
— Tom McCarthy (@T11Mac) August 12, 2019
— Kileym88 (@Kileym88) August 12, 2019
Jake Guentzel is better than Phil Kessel. Don’t @ me
— JB (@JB_HockeyTalk) August 12, 2019
I genuinely don’t understand why Jake Guentzel isn’t between 14-20? Someone please explain
— Garrett (@GarrettMcElwain) August 12, 2019
um..... are we forgetting that Jake Guentzel exists?? I love Phil but.... JAKE????? https://t.co/GqozrBcufs
— Scar (@scarlettfarlee) August 12, 2019
I have a hard time believing Jake Guentzel isnt in the top 20. https://t.co/5ERz7kayn0
— Wraith (@SuperVillain8) August 12, 2019
Fans who saw that list clearly felt strongly about Guentzel’s omission; they voted him the 13th best wing in the NHL.
How does your list compare to ours? #NHLTopPlayers
— NHL Network (@NHLNetwork) August 12, 2019
Check it out below ⬇️ pic.twitter.com/56lZxsjh04
Is there a statistical argument for Guentzel to be included among the NHL’s elite wings? Let’s investigate.
Guentzel had a career year last season, putting up 40 goals and 36 assists while playing in every game for the Penguins. He also has scored 24 goals in 41 career playoff games, including 13 during the team’s 2016-17 Stanley Cup run.
Read More
That’s a solid resume for a guy selected 77th overall in the 2013 draft. It’s also at worst comparable to a few players at the bottom of NHL.com’s list of best wings.
Coincidentally, none other than ex-Penguin and current Arizona Coyote Phil Kessel came in at No. 20. His numbers last year were in the same range as Guentzel’s, as Pittsburgh’s favorite weirdo still managed to put up 27 goals and 55 assists in what was considered a down year for him.
The difference in plus/minus — the stat indicating how the team fared with a player on and off the ice — between Guentzel and Kessel last season, though, is staggering. While Guentzel’s plus/minus was a respectable plus-13, Kessel came in at an eye-popping minus-19.
Plus/minus is admittedly a flawed stat on which to judge a player, as it has as much to do with the line they play on and the opponents they face while on the ice as actual individual performance. But it does indicate that there’s an argument for Guentzel to be at least in the same class as his ex-teammate.
Guentzel also provided much more help to his team last season than the Winnipeg Jets’ Patrick Laine, who’s No. 19 on NHL.com’s list. Laine scored only 30 goals and assisted on 20 with a plus/minus of minus-24 last year. Guentzel would have a legitimate gripe seeing that guy beat him out given his 2018-19 numbers.
Some might say Guentzel is a product of Sidney Crosby’s brilliance and that his only elite skill is scoring goals. The counter to that would be that he still had to find the back of the net consistently to have those statistics — with or without Crosby’s help. And if an NHL player were to have one elite skill, goal-scoring is possibly the best one to have.
It’s also worth mentioning that Satriano ranked Crosby No. 2 among all NHL centers and Evgeni Malkin No. 13.
You’re welcome to feel however you want about those rankings.
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxel222







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.