The Penguins have not picked a player in the first round since 2014, Jim Rutherford’s first year as general manager. That likely changes Friday, when they will be on the clock with pick No. 21 in the first round of the NHL draft in Vancouver.
“Our scouts have liked the draft for some time,” he said last week.
Rutherford believes this draft class is “real deep.” It is stacked throughout the first round, which should leave the Penguins with a handful of intriguing prospects to consider regardless of what unfolds in the 20 selections before theirs.
“I think there’s a lot of really good players into the second round,” said Craig Button, the former Calgary Flames and Dallas Stars executive who is now an analyst for TSN in Canada. “I’m talking about top-six forwards, top-four defensemen, goaltenders if you want goaltenders who can be starters in the National Hockey League.”
The Penguins shouldn’t be picky when it comes to position, except for perhaps between the pipes. Their prospect pool is considered among the NHL’s shallowest.
The Penguins do not presently possess a pick in the second or third round, leaving open the possibility that Rutherford could trade out of the first round in the hopes of changing that. But Chris Peters, a draft analyst for ESPN, said it is probably best for the Penguins to stay put and grab their top guy at pick No. 21.
Read More
“I would rather take a chance on a player that is going to be there,” he said.
Added Brian Lawton, the former player, agent and NHL executive who is now an NHL Network analyst: “I’d be excited if I were the Penguins. I think it’s a draft where one or two years down the line you might have a really good player in your lineup.”
So who might be on the board and under consideration when the Penguins are on the clock? Button and Peters provided seven names with quick scouting reports.
Arthur Kaliyev | forward | 6-2, 190 pounds | Hamilton (OHL)
“A 50-goal scorer in the Ontario Hockey League, and he can make plays, as well. He’s a good-sized winger you can add to your lineup.” – Button
Stat that stands out: Only four current NHLers scored 50 in the OHL at age 17.
Raphael Lavoie | forward | 6-4, 198 | Halifax (QMJHL)
“A big-bodied goal-scorer. He reminds me a lot of [Los Angeles Kings center] Jeff Carter with the way he shoots the puck and the way he scores.” – Button
Stat that stands out: 20 goals, 12 assists in 23 QMJHL playoff games this spring.
Brett Leason | forward | 6-4, 221 | Prince Albert (WHL)
“Leason is [20 years old], a big forward. He’s probably got a shorter NHL timeline, which is why he might be intriguing to a team like the Penguins.” – Peters
Stat that stands out: 89 points this season after scoring just 33 in 2017-18.
Connor McMichael | forward | 5-11, 174 | London (OHL)
“Connor McMichael is a really good player. I call him a Swiss Army knife because he can play offense. He can play [responsibly on defense]. He can play wing. He can play center. You can move him around your lineup.” – Button
Stat that stands out: Led London in “Three Stars of the Game” honors in 2018-19.
Matthew Robertson | defenseman | 6-4, 192 | Edmonton (WHL)
“Matthew Robertson reminds me a lot of Mattias Ekholm of the Nashville Predators, a really good skating defenseman that moves the puck up the ice. Players like Robertson and Tobias Bjornfot, [a 6-foot, 203-pound potential first-round pick who plays in Sweden], could really play a strong game among your top four defensemen, skate, move the puck by passing it or skating with it.” – Button
Stat that stands out: plus-18 rating after posting a minus-18 mark last season.
Philip Tomasino | forward | 6-0, 181 | Niagara (OHL)
“Kind of skates like [New York Islanders All-Star center] Mathew Barzal. I don’t know if he’s as fast, but he’s so smooth and he’s got quickness. And he’s a guy who is high on a lot of lists but could be there in the 20s.” – Peters
Stat that stands out: five points in six games for Canada at the 2018 WJC.
Cam York | defenseman | 5-11, 172 | U.S. Development Team
“Cam York could be there [when the Penguins pick]. Listen, if someone took him in the top 10, it wouldn’t surprise me. But I think he’s a really good-skating defenseman that has a really good career in front of him.” – Button
Stat that stands out: 65 points in 63 games for the NTDP this past season.
Note: Prospect measurements and statistics courtesy of EliteProspects.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.