Jim Rutherford created some Penguins news this weekend when he traded Olli Maatta to the Chicago Blackhawks for forward Dominik Kahun. The deal enabled the Penguins to get younger, add a little more speed and, most importantly, create some much-needed salary cap breathing room.

It was an excellent trade for the Penguins, but it was mostly a minor deal as Maatta no longer fit with the Penguins’ plans. Rutherford has a lot more work to do in order to rebuild the Penguins into something resembling an actual Stanley Cup contender.

Rutherford has said he knows he has to make a few major deals in order to give the Penguins the kind of makeover they need. It isn’t going to be easy, though, as the Penguins have some bad contracts that will be tough to move, and while they need to get younger, they don’t have the luxury of going with a complete youth movement.

The Penguins have aging stars — a core of players with one or two legitimate runs left in them — and Rutherford knows it. The team isn’t good enough anymore to just show up at the start of the season and be considered a favorite. The superstars are still among the best players in the world, but they are 30-somethings now and their best days are behind them.

Advertise with us

The Penguins appear to be paying the price for years and years of “going for it” at the trading deadline. The Penguins have routinely traded away prospects and draft choices to bring in established players in hopes of making Stanley Cup runs.

And even though the Penguins’ farm system is barren on many levels, that was the right approach to take. The Penguins have enough star power that they were a threat to make a run every season if the right moves were made. I believe it was the right approach then, and I believe it is the right approach every year until the core of superstars can no longer deliver.

That’s why the Penguins should look to trade their first-round pick this weekend. There have been some reports surfacing that Rutherford is open to trading the pick, but let’s hope they are more than just reports. The Penguins need to flip that pick into a player that can help them win in 2019-20. That has to be Rutherford’s focus, and he cannot worry about the future when he makes any deal.

The Penguins aren’t likely to get a franchise-changing player with the 21st pick. They aren’t even likely to get a player who can help at all this year, which means the pick is far more valuable to them as a trade chip than anything else. I know the Penguins have traded away their last four first-round picks, but that isn’t a reason for them to hold on to this one.

There are some who think the Penguins should start the process of rebuilding or at least preserve their draft choices and flip some of their veterans into prospects. That would be silly. The Penguins are likely going to take a huge step back in the year or two after the Sidney Crosby-Evgeni Malkin-Kris Letang group retires, anyway.

Advertise with us

There is no reason to worry about the rebuilding process until it is actually time to rebuild. Rutherford has delivered two Stanley Cups, and Penguins fans have enjoyed a long stretch of playoff runs and winning seasons. They aren’t starving for a winner and will likely be patient and willing to wait through a down year or two, especially if it means the Penguins are able to make one more Stanley Cup run now.

Rutherford should absolutely try to add some youth, though, as the core of the team is aging. He should also try to shed the contracts of Patric Hornqvist and Jack Johnson, and he should work hard to move Phil Kessel. Those players should bring back something in return — especially Kessel — but more importantly, the amount of salary cap money that is freed up would really help Rutherford’s cause.

Currently, Rutherford has almost no cap space to work with (though he did free up a decent chunk with the Maatta deal), but if he makes a few deals involving Kessel, Hornqvist and Johnson he will have some room. And that will enable him to perhaps add a few free agents that fit into the category of “younger, faster player that can help win now.”

This is a big offseason for the Penguins because the window to win is closing rapidly, so Rutherford must get it right. This isn’t a franchise that can afford to add anyone who won’t help immediately and who won’t give them a chance to hoist the Stanley Cup at the end of next season.