Trading Olli Maatta was easy. He was expendable, not just because of the Penguins’ defensive depth but because he would have counted a little more than $4 million annually through the 2021-22 season. The primary return for Maatta from the Chicago Blackhawks was good. Dominik Kahun is about $3 million-a-year cheaper under the cap, can skate and score and should slot in as a top-nine forward, maybe even a top-six. Jim Rutherford did well with the deal.
Now comes the hard part. Just trading Maatta isn’t enough to make the Penguins a Stanley Cup contender again. Rutherford talked about the need for change after the team was swept in the first round of the playoffs by the New York Islanders in what seems like a lifetime ago. Certainly, injuries to Justin Schultz, Evgeni Malkin, Kris Letang, Matt Murray, Patric Hornqvist and Zach Aston-Reese factored into the inconsistent season. So did a bad season by Malkin and Derick Brassard, a bad playoff series by Letang and long periods without a goal by Phil Kessel and Hornqvist. But Rutherford identified the problem as something more.
“We still got 100 points, but it wasn’t a comfortable 100 points,” Rutherford said in April. “I didn’t see a point where guys came together as a team. I wonder if it’s because there’s too many guys content with where they’re at in their careers after winning a couple Stanley Cups, and is that a signal where some of that has to be changed, where you have that eagerness again?”
Trading Maatta — as fine a teammate as there was in the Penguins room — won’t solve that chemistry issue.
Something much more significant needs to happen.
I expect it will by the weekend when the NHL draft is scheduled, certainly by July 1 when free agency starts.
Read More
I’ll be surprised if Kessel, Hornqvist, Letang or even Malkin doesn’t go.
Rutherford said last week he and Mike Sullivan would welcome back Kessel if they can’t trade him. I’m not buying it. The team has been looking into moving Kessel for two years and had a deal last month with Minnesota for forward Jason Zucker that was vetoed by Kessel, per his contractual right. I believe Rutherford still wants to trade Kessel and will find a way to pull off a deal. The problem is getting anything back in return that even approaches equal value. Kessel, despite being a point-a-game player last season, brings a lot of baggage. He is difficult to coach and wore out his welcome in Boston, Toronto and now Pittsburgh. It’s a shame the Minnesota deal didn’t go through because Zucker would have fit nicely in the speed game Sullivan likes to play and averaged 25 goals in each of the past three seasons.
Rutherford will have an even harder time trading Hornqvist because he’s on the wrong side of 30, has a history of concussions and is signed for an annual cap hit of $5.3 million through the 2022-23 season. Letang has a no-trade list of 12 teams, and Malkin can’t be traded anywhere without his permission. Those contract clauses can be difficult but not insurmountable. Players have been known to waive them.
Malkin is the least likely to be traded, but that doesn’t mean a deal won’t happen under the right circumstances. I hear people say Mario Lemieux won’t allow a Malkin trade because he wants Malkin to be a legacy Penguin, but I don’t necessarily believe that. More than anything, Lemieux wants to win another Cup during the Sidney Crosby era. If Rutherford can find the right deal and Malkin approves it, I’m thinking Lemieux will give his blessing.
Good luck to Rutherford during these very challenging next two weeks.
One final thought about Maatta …
He never received the credit he deserved from Penguins fans, mostly because of the playing time he missed because of cancer and two shoulder surgeries. It’s sad he is remembered just as much for the picture of him being passed out on his balcony in the sun after the team’s Cup parade in 2017 as he is for his many contributions to the Penguins’ success. Sullivan knew Maatta’s value. He thought enough of him to make Jack Johnson a healthy scratch for the first time all season in Game 1 against the Islanders. Maatta had a rough night and was replaced by Johnson in the final three losses.
“Ollie’s a great kid,” Sullivan said before the playoffs started. “He’s a great teammate. He really cares about winning. Two things allow him to be the player that he is: His courage and his hockey sense. His positioning on the ice is terrific. He’s not overly mobile, but what he lacks in foot speed, he makes up for with his hockey sense and his intellect. He maximizes the skills that he has.
“He’s got a great attitude. He always takes ownership for his own game. He’s never a guy that points the finger somewhere else. When we coach Olli, sometimes we’re careful about how critical we are because he’s very hard on himself. He’s so hard on himself because he wants to be the best player he can be to help this team win. He’s a terrific person.”
Maatta deserves the video tribute the Penguins will give him on the PPG Paints Arena scoreboard when the Blackhawks come to town next season. He deserves to be remembered here exactly as he was.
A two-time, Cup-winning champion.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.