The way the series was going heading into Game 3 of the Eastern Conference quarterfinals Sunday at PPG Paints Arena, the Penguins would have taken an early goal from just about anybody.

Jeff Jimerson. One of their Zamboni drivers. The lady selling cotton candy in Section 221.

They ended up getting one from a guy with just two more goals than Jimerson this season.

Garrett Wilson — Yes, Garrett Wilson of all people — tipped a rising shot past Robin Lehner just under 13 minutes into the first period, giving the Penguins a 1-0 lead for a second game in a row. The arena roared and the bench rejoiced. Maybe this game would finally go their way.

Advertise with us

Exactly 90 seconds of action later, the shell-shocked Penguins were staring at a 2-1 deficit.

They never recovered. The Penguins barely registered a pulse in the third period before losing, 4-1. Now the New York Islanders on Tuesday will get a chance to sweep them at PPG Paints Arena.

“We haven’t found a way to either hold a lead or build on one,” Sidney Crosby noted.

Nope. Three games in, the Penguins have led just twice for a grand total of three minutes, 17 seconds. They have yet to score two goals in a row, making it difficult to win hockey games. The Islanders scored 2:49 after Erik Gudbranson’s opening goal in Game 2.

Jack Johnson

The first Islanders goal Sunday, which came 28 seconds after Wilson scored and should not have gotten past Matt Murray, sucked the life out of PPG Paints Arena and seemingly the Penguins, too.

Advertise with us

“This is a fantastic building to play in. The fans are great,” Islanders coach Barry Trotz said. “They get the first goal. … The people are happy. And then before they announce the goal, we get it tied up.”

Jordan Eberle, who has scored in every game this series, was nearly parked in the left corner — his left skate was just off the goal line — when Ryan Pulock whipped him a pass from the right point.

Murray shuffled across the crease as Eberle gathered the puck and was seemingly in good position. But he dropped to his knees to try to seal the post, creating an opening above his right shoulder. Eberle, a right-hander, buzzed a low-angle shot past Murray’s ear and underneath the crossbar.

Murray, asked after the game about that deflating goal, suddenly developed amnesia.

“Uh … I don’t really remember honestly right now,” he said. “I don’t really remember.”

Advertise with us

Just over a minute after Eberle scored, Justin Schultz stepped up in the neutral zone to try to poke the puck from Tom Kuhnhackl. The former Penguins forward won that battle, chipping the puck past Schultz to send the Islanders on a 2-on-1. Brock Nelson kept it, beating Murray blocker-side.

“We take a 1-0 lead and two, three minutes later it’s 2-1 for them,” Patric Hornqvist said. “It’s a 2-on-1, that second goal. Those things can’t happen. It’s playoffs and we have to be [smarter] at the line and make sure they don’t get those easy goals, because we’re not going to get any easy goals.”

Said Schultz: “That’s just a bad play by me. I can’t be pinching there. That one’s on me.”

The crowd mumbled, the game turned and the Penguins, who have just five goals in the series, would not score again. They didn’t exactly exude confidence when they walked out for the third period.

Afterward, they shook their heads when thinking about how quickly the game had turned.

Advertise with us

“All the times we’re scoring, they’re answering right away. We can’t have that,” said Wilson, a fourth-liner who after Sunday is now tied for the team lead in playoff goals with one. “We need to string a few shifts together after a goal to keep the momentum and we haven’t been able to do that.”

It might be too late now, but that must change for the Penguins to pull off the improbable.

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.