The Penguins dropped Game 3 of their first-round playoff series against the New York Islanders by a 4-1 margin Sunday at PPG Paints Arena. New York now leads the series, three games to none. Here are some thoughts on the defeat.

It was over when: The Islanders’ Leo Komarov scored to give New York a 3-1 lead at the 10:27 mark of the third period. As it did in Game 2, the two-goal lead felt insurmountable for a Penguins team that’s had little momentum at any point in this series.

Heroes: Garrett Wilson created some havoc in front of Islanders goalie Robin Lehner, and it paid off with a tipped shot for the first goal of the game.

The Penguins need more of this. Not just from their fourth line. From every line. The defensive-minded Islanders aren’t going to allow many highlight-reel goals. Ugly ones count just the same. Go to the net and good things can happen. Wilson’s goal was a perfect example.

Advertise with us

Goats: Matt Murray had the angle on Jordan Eberle’s game-tying goal in the first period. He just didn’t protect his post well enough.

That’s a save he has to make 28 seconds after his team gave him a lead. The Penguins have had precious few advantages in this series, and that’s just not a good way to squander one of them. Murray’s effort on Komarov’s goal to ice it wasn’t much better, but by then, the damage was done. No, his offense isn’t doing much in front of him, but Murray needs to do more to keep them from playing from behind, too.

Moments later, aggression got the better of a Penguins defenseman yet again in this series. This time, it was Justin Schultz who tried to press the play after a Sidney Crosby turnover. Instead the puck got past him for a two-on-one the other way, which Brock Nelson converted into a go-ahead goal for the Islanders.

It was a bone-headed play reminiscent of teammate Kris Letang’s in overtime of Game 1. Combine those two moments, and you pretty much have the theme of the series. The Islanders sit back and wait for the Penguins to make a costly mistake. Then they pounce and make the most of their opportunities. The Penguins are obliging them at every turn and allowing New York to play almost constantly from ahead. That’s a great recipe for losing against a team that knows how to defend a lead.

Comeback suffocated: Other than those mistakes, it’s hard to really assign blame individually for this loss that puts the Penguins in a massive hole. They were, collectively, smothered. The stars. The grinders. Everyone had trouble getting north and south efficiently, as evidenced by their 16 total giveaways.That’s what happens when you fall behind a team like this one. They can make life so difficult, even if you have some of the best playmakers in hockey on your side. Still ...

Advertise with us

The stars need to be better. Much better: After playing irritated in Game 2, Malkin was almost invisible Sunday. He finished with just one shot. Even Phil Kessel, who generated a lot of offense in the first two games, struggled to find room to make plays. Paired with Malkin for much of the game, he also got just one puck on net. On the top line, Sidney Crosby and Jake Guentzel got better matchups and generated more chances than they did in Game 2, but they didn’t break through. Sometimes the simplest analysis is best. A team isn’t going to win a playoff series if guys like Wilson and Erik Gudbranson are providing the only scoring. If the Penguins are going to win the four straight games necessary to win this series in seven games, the big names need to solve this Islanders forecheck, give their team a lead and force New York to play from behind for a change.

What they’re saying

Next: The teams reconvene at PPG Paints Arena for Game 4 on Tuesday. Faceoff is 7:30 p.m.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.