UNIONDALE, N.Y. – Jack Johnson’s return to the lineup Friday, other than a pair of fluky penalties, was going about as well as he could have hoped until the Penguins got caught in a quick transition.
Evgeni Malkin lost the puck in the neutral zone and the New York Islanders, as they have done in both of their victories in this Eastern Conference quarterfinal series, quickly pounced on an opportunity.
Johnson, with just over 12 minutes left in the third period, was put in a tough spot, with both Mathew Barzal and Jordan Eberle skating down his side of the ice. Eberle briefly ran interference while Barzal dangled the puck across the blue line. Eberle then darted along the side boards and behind Johnson.
Johnson, showing respect to Barzal, stood his ground, allowing Barzal to slip a pass by him to Eberle. Eberle took it on his forehand near the goal line and cut towards Matt Murray. Johnson pivoted to help but it was too late. Eberle flipped a backhand shot under the crossbar for a go-ahead goal.
“Whenever someone scores, you wish you could do something differently,” Johnson lamented.
It would hold up as the Islanders won, 3-1, in Game 2 to ruin Johnson’s return to the blue line.
Read More
Johnson, a healthy scratch in Wednesday’s 4-3 overtime loss, found out before Friday’s pregame skate that he would be reinserted into the lineup and that Olli Maatta would replace him in the press box.
“I was just happy to be back out there with my teammates,” he said. “Overall, I was pretty proud of my game. But honestly, that doesn’t matter. That’s not really the story. We’re in a series here. There’s going to be highs and lows, guys in and out of the lineup. We’re just looking to home and turn it around.”
Keeping Johnson on the blue line might give the Penguins a better chance of doing it.
In Friday’s loss, he was reunited with Justin Schultz. That pair had played well to help the Penguins survive injuries to Kris Letang, Brian Dumoulin and Maatta down the stretch, thus the surprise when Johnson was the odd man out Wednesday.
Johnson was penalized twice in the first period, first for high-sticking and then for interference after he collided with Islanders blue-liner Adam Pelech while booking it from the box to the bench. Johnson said he never saw him.
The penalty kill bailed him out. Johnson returned the favor in the second period, playing a role in the Penguins killing penalties to Sidney Crosby and Erik Gudbranson, which overlapped for 54 seconds.
Through two periods, the Penguins had an advantage in shot attempts (12-5) and scoring chances (4-3) with Johnson on the ice at 5-on-5. But then the Islanders took the lead with Eberle’s goal. It was one of five scoring chances for the Islanders in the third period with Johnson on the ice at 5-on-5.
Johnson signed a five-year, $16.25 million deal last summer. After a shaky first couple of months to start his Penguins career, he had a plus-8 rating from Dec. 1 on. But Wednesday, he became the first player in team history to play all 82 games of the regular season then sit for Game 1 of the postseason.
Thursday, Johnson said it was “real hard” to sit. Coach Mike Sullivan called it “a very difficult decision.”
Sullivan added: “But he’s going to be ready for us, and I know he’s going to help us win.”
It turned out that Johnson would only need to wait a couple of days to get back into the mix.
“We thought we needed more of a physical presence out there. He brings a lot of bite to our blue line. That was one of the reasons that we talked about,” Sullivan said. “And I thought he played well.”
Friday was the first time that Maatta, a two-time Cup winner, was a healthy scratch during the playoffs. Maatta was a healthy scratch the third game of the regular season but did not sit out another until a separated shoulder sidelined him for 21 games. He returned March 29.
Maatta was on the ice for a pair of Islanders goals Wednesday, including Nick Leddy’s go-ahead goal in the third period, which came directly after Maatta got stripped of the puck. Ex-Penguin Tom Kuhnhackl later danced around him in overtime, forcing Murray to come up with a big save.
“It could be better, for sure,” Maatta said of his play after Game 1.
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.