Mike Sullivan talks about losing to the Islanders in Game 2.

UNIONDALE, N.Y. — The predicament the Penguins found themselves in those queasy moments after Game 1 hadn’t really manifested into all of its ominous implications until deep in Game 2, because sometimes in these ferocious hockey postseasons, you’re just going too fast to see how close you are to the cliff’s edge.

So as Friday night’s first 40 minutes clicked past like blurry fence posts and Mike Sullivan’s team still hadn’t gotten in touch with anything resembling its usual competence, one of those hard statistical truths swelled to its full import.

Teams that win the first two in these seven-game series at home, which looked for all the world like the precise intent of the underdog New York Islanders, go on to win them 89.5 percent of the time. The previous time the Penguins found themselves in a 2-0 hole was in 2013.

They were about to be swept by the Boston Bruins.

Advertise with us

At the second intermission, the turn of the screw had become nearly unbearable for the Penguins, who were again in a tied hockey game just as they were three times in Game 1. And of this series’ first 104 minutes and 39 seconds, the Penguins had led for all of 2:49.

“When you’re in those tied games, you’ve got to find a way to get the next one,” said Sidney Crosby in the moments after he and the Penguins had failed to do so. “We had our chances.”

The Islanders didn’t miss theirs.

New York’s Jordan Eberle stick-handled the puck around a backsliding Justin Schultz and flipped it past Matt Murray at 7:54 of the third period, but with more than 12 minutes to get even, the Penguins instead seemed more concerned with getting the Islanders the power play goal they already had failed to convert five times.

This second episode was thus memorable for a curious gambit on the part of the visitors — a clear attempt to try and win a game from the penalty box. This was no fatal subtext; it was a major theme. The Penguins took eight penalties — high sticking was the most popular — but it wasn’t until Patric Hornqvist went off for tripping midway through the third that the Islanders made them pay.

Advertise with us

Josh Bailey, who had gotten the game-winner in overtime Wednesday, got the dagger goal at 11:38. The Islanders were 38-2-2 this season when scoring three or more goals, and this particular goal extended a dubious streak for the Penguins penalty-killers, who have now allowed a power play goal in six of the past seven games. The only exception came in the final regular-season game against the Rangers, when they took the precaution of staying out of the penalty box entirely. Always a good idea.

But even though the Islanders didn’t score until their final power play, it would be wrong to suggest that the Penguins had gotten through unscathed to that point.

“It’s tough when you’re in the penalty box that much,” said Mike Sullivan, who has won 9 of 10 postseason series with the Penguins by avoiding this very 0-2 predicament. “It takes some guys out of the game. You’re overtaxing others. It’s hard to get into a flow.”

Evgeni Malkin, the most penalized player in Penguins playoff history (now 222 minutes and counting, 52 more than Kevin Stevens) seemed intent only on expanding his lead in that area, and Jack Johnson joined him in visitors penalty box they each went to twice in the first 20 minutes.

That the Islanders failed to capitalize was a testament to the Penguins’ not-always-reliable penalty-killers and to Matt Murray, who stopped 11 shots in a first period in which the Penguins fired only seven at Robin Lehner.

Advertise with us

Worse, Crosby and Jake Guentzel were still in the ditch the Islanders excavated for them in Game 1. Crosby neither scored nor assisted in the first two games, and his shot total through six periods plus an overtime is three, or three more than Guentzel’s.

Bryan Rust, again perfectly ineffective skating with Crosby and Guentzel, had hoped his teammates could generate some momentum after they killed off 54 seconds of an Islanders 5-on-3 in the second period.

“I thought it might have given our team a little bit of momentum knowin’ that we killed those off,” he insisted. “We had big kills but it did kind of take us out of the flow a little bit. So much of that first period was either 4-on-4 or short-handed, but that’s just how the game is. We’ve all been in games like that plenty of times.”

Funny thing is, the Islanders have not. They’ve won one playoff series in the past 35 years. The Penguins had not planned to be part of No. 2, so they didn’t sound the least bit panicked.

“We just have to execute better,” Crosby said. “They’re getting the big play, the big goal.”

Advertise with us

Maybe just a little panic wouldn’t hurt.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com