Sidney Crosby talks about better puck management against the Islanders
Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my weekly Penguins chat. Probably a lot to talk about after last night's Game 1 loss. Leave your questions here, and I'll be back at 11 -- or a little before -- to answer them. Thanks.
Jason Mackey: Alright folks ... let's do this.
Guest: This game reminded me of the Caps series last year. Pens just too aggressive sometimes with little situational awareness, and feel free to substitute Letang for “Pens”...the other team’s forecheck and pressure putting the Pens on their heels, and Trotz outcoaching Sullivan. I don’t understand why all these fans think the Pens will win this series. I honestly see the Isles winning this series in 6 games. Do you think Sullivan needs to change more strategically about how the Pens plays Trotz’s teams?
Jason Mackey: This seems like an appropriate starting point. The Penguins lacked awareness last night, but I don't see how it's relative to Sullivan. Dumoulin makes a horrible pass, and that's Sullivan's fault? Maatta doesn't change and turns it over, that's Sullivan's fault? Letang tries to go one-on-three and coughs it up, that's Sullivan's fault? Sullivan didn't get out-coached. His players got out-played, specifically his defensemen. Since 2016, Sullivan and Trotz have split 20 playoff games. I don't think one guy has the decided edge here either way.
Brian: How many chances is Maatta going to get? Every game you can see him laboring to get back into the play on defense.
Jason Mackey: I thought Maatta was actually decent toward the end of the regular season, but I agree he was bad last night. Perhaps bad enough to be in the press box for Game 2. We'll see. I'll also admit I would've started him up there. I like Olli, but I've seen nothing lately from Jack Johnson that warranted him being a healthy scratch last night.
Read More
Guest: Sullivan has to do more to help line 1 against the Isles’ fourth line. I know he doesn’t control the matchup on the road but what about putting Horny with Sid and Jake and moving Rust down with Malkin? Rust has been playing pretty poorly on the first line the last couple weeks. I don’t think he’s really helping with his tunnel vision and at least Horny is a little harder to play against when the Isles are matching their grinders against Sid
Jason Mackey: I don't totally disagree with you; however, I really liked Hornqvist with Malkin last night. I would be hesitant to break those guys up. Maybe you try it, see what happens, and if everything works, you keep it. Not against it, by any stretch. And also, at home, Sullivan can get those guys a better matchup. The Islanders fourth line is a pain. Crosby line might just have to play a little better/tougher than it did last night. Don't always have to change personnel.
Lindsay: Do you think we’ll Johnson in the lineup Friday?
Jason Mackey: I don't know how to Johnson. Is that something the kids are doing these days?
JohnAl: Am I the only one who didn't think last night was that bad? Couple of bounces away from a win and the Penguins ran the play for large portions of the game, all while withstanding the Islanders best punch. Did you feel like the Penguins spent a lot of time chasing hits and trying to match physicality, leading to some poor positioning?
Jason Mackey: I'm with you, JohnAl. It's a Game 1 loss, in overtime, so I know it's easy to freak out. The Penguins did a lot of things well. Kessel was terrific. So was Malkin, Hornqvist and even Simon. Power play scored. Yeah, defense was bad, Murray was so-so, but if you thought sweep, you're nuts. Fix it for Game 2 and move on.
Jason Mackey: And no, I don't think they chased hits. I think they were a little sloppy at times with the puck. Didn't break out clean enough. They have to match the physicality in some sense.
Mike M: Do you see jack Johnson sliding in for Olli Maata if gudbranson is available to play? Or do you believe Olli gets one more chance in game two considering he has the playoff experience?
Jason Mackey: Good question, Mike. If Gudbranson is available, my gut says Sullivan goes back to Maatta. However, I'm lying if I say I believe 100 percent in that. I'm just trying to be straight with you and not dance around the question. I think Sullivan has another fairly large decision on his hands if everyone is again healthy.
Mike M: Is it just me or did the first line look well below average last night? Do you see a big bounce back from that line in game two and going forward?
Jason Mackey: They did. Not a great night. Got killed in scoring chances -- believe 1-13 five-on-five, something like that. It was ugly. They need to adjust to the physicality of the Islanders' fourth line. Will also help if the Penguins can get out of their own zone better.
Mike M: Any chance McCann slides back on the first line? He seemed to do well with sid there at the end of the season.
Jason Mackey: I think there's a chance, yeah. I think Sullivan will try something, and McCann would be one of my two most likely possibilities.
Mike M: On paper the pens are the much deeper team. Why is it that Barry trotz system allows them to play stingy defense?
Jason Mackey: Because they sit back and defend. They buy into what Trotz wants to do with structure and sacrificing offense for team success. He has them playing a certain way, and they're believing in it because it has yielded results.
Mike M: Last night it seemed sid was not looking for his shot at all. Why is he hesitating to shoot? He has a great shot especially with the back hand and should utilize that more.
Jason Mackey: Mike, you've officially asked me more questions today than my wife. ... I'm not ready to make that judgement on Sid. They didn't have the puck enough. Rough night for that line. That's all. I'm not pulling from that that he's hesitant to shoot. It was just a bad night.
guest: hi jason, was just wondering: does sullivan have an issue with keeping mccann on the top line, even though they click? why does he keep moving mccann off?
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure. I know he likes Rust there a lot, for the speed he brings. But I agree with what you're saying: Doesn't seem like McCann has much staying power there. I think they maybe worry some about McCann's finishing ability. But I can't say that Rust has been red-hot scoring goals, either.
David: Hi Jason, I taught the lines used last night were very competitive. What are the chances Sully keeps them for a while? And regarding Oli, it’s time to move on and bring Johnson in, too many poor decisions and his lack of speed are hurting the team.Your taughts?
Jason Mackey: Gonna answer the top line and Olli/Jack questions one last time and move on, trying to avoid the repetition ... I think Sullivan will trying something with Sid. Got to. That line was a black hole. My guess would be McCann, although I could see him going with Hornqvist, too. ... As for the defense, I could see him swapping out Olli for Johnson. I'd put that at about 60/40 over staying status quo. I also worry about injuries to Dumoulin and Gudbranson.
Mike Sullivan talks about the Penguins' OT loss to Islanders
Manhattan Yinzer: Was there a review for goalie interference on the OT winner last night? The NBCSN crew seemed to think they were looking to see if the play was onside, but Murray seemed upset about the Islander who slid into him after he stopped the initial shot. He really had no chance to get over for the rebound...
Jason Mackey: They reviewed for goaltender interference, but the conclusion drawn was that Kris Letang pushed Mathew Barzal into Matt Murray.
MA: Did the ice look as bad live as it did on my screen?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, it was awful.
Guest: What are the chances of any of our upcoming free agents taking a “discount” to stay with the Pens? Schultz ....Kessel? I know ppl keep saying we can’t afford Kessel so the Pens should trade him and move on but he really seems to enjoy Pittsburgh and how he’s treated any thoughts on if he or others would stay?
Jason Mackey: Zero as far as hometown discounts. That's (mostly) a fan thing. It is a business, and players are gonna want paid. Yeah, things change when guys are in great situations and if they're comfortable, but they're not going to take less to stay here because they think it's neat to live near three rivers or something. That being said, Schultz isn't up until after next season, Kessel after 2022. Any sort of contractual "discounts" aren't going to come into play for awhile.
Guest: I feel so bad for Johnson . He did not deserve to sit . He has played well down and stretch and played every game . What a punch to the gut for him . How did his demeanor seem?
Jason Mackey: He seemed fine after morning skate, although I'm not sure he knew at that point he would be sitting. We didn't talk to him after. He's a total pro. Regardless of what you think of his game -- some like it, some hate it -- he's a total pro. Super nice guy, approachable, a team player. He'll handle it the right way.
Guest: Ok when did kunackle get good ? He looked like he lost some weight and was faster than I remember. Maatta is still looking for the clothes he undressed him from
Jason Mackey: Kuhnhackl and ... I think it's also opportunity. He's getting to do more on Long Island, stuff that wasn't necessarily available in Pittsburgh. Strangely, he also seems to play his best games against the Penguins. Earlier this season, remember, Kuhnhackl was back in the AHL.
Michael: The D played bad overall, Sid's line was quiet, and they lost in OT. They split on the Island and the series tilts back in their favor. I don't know how Pens fans get so out of control with so much playoff experience under their belts. I think they get the next one and win the series in 6 or 7. You?
Jason Mackey: I agree with everything you just typed. It's like people say Pens in six without realizing that doesn't indicate a sweep. They have to lose. They lost on the road, in a crazy building, in overtime, where they just did some stupid stuff. They didn't get blown out. They didn't get outplayed. They also got some encouraging signs with Malkin, Kessel and Hornqvist. This fan base -- and I love it, I say this in good fun -- is just conditioning to react with these wild swings all the time. I don't get it.
Ericm1212: Sullivan will never change the lineup, that be admitting he was wrong and it will never happen
Jason Mackey: I disagree there. Big time. Sullivan is one of the most competitive people I've ever met. Do you really think he would rather stroke his own ego than win a playoff game?C'mon.
Guest: “I beg to differ about that he had a bad year last year.
I don’t think he had a bad year. He was a healthy scratch at the end of the season. I know the reason why.
It wasn’t because of how he was playing,” Rutherford explained.
Jason Mackey: For those who don't know, this is what Rutherford said about Jack Johnson on July 1 ...
Guest: Sorry. Sent accidentally. “I beg to differ about that he had a bad year last year.
I don’t think he had a bad year. He was a healthy scratch at the end of the season. I know the reason why.
It wasn’t because of how he was playing,” Rutherford explained. Do we know the reason yet, or does Sullivan just love irony?
Jason Mackey: Johnson wasn't playing, as I understand it, because he had fallen out of favor with Torts, who wasn't happy with Johnson's leaked trade request. It had nothing to do with his play, as Rutherford said. Became more of a personal thing.
Guest: Time to panic?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so, no. It was one game. I think the Penguins did a lot of things well. If I'm thinking about this logically, I'm expecting Brian Dumoulin and Kris Letang to bounce back. I'm also not expecting the Islanders to score four goals many more times. Honestly, I think they're fine. There was plenty to like last night, just a few too many glitches.
Guest: How was it allowed by the NHL for a playoff game to be played in a rink that is in such terrible condition? The ice was noticeably bad, pucks taking crazy bounces off the partitions between the glass, and lack of up to date technology for video reviews.
Jason Mackey: Gotta be careful here because I love Nassau. I don't care if the ice sucks or the replays take awhile or whatever. It's just ... fun. There's not enough fun rinks anymore. They all look the same. They're all corporate. That place was rocking last night. ... They do need to improve the ice, though. That drove down play, in my opinion.
Hornqvist Fan: Jason why does this team do so many STUPID things game after game.
Jason Mackey: Ha. That's a simple question but a good one. I think part of it is personnel. They have guys who want to make skilled plays and do special things. Problem is, in games like last night, that's not always the ingredient you need. Just dump it in, skate, get it back, rinse, wash, repeat. The trick is convincing players to play a boring game sometimes. Sullivan doesn't have an easy job.
Guest: If Sid, Malkin, Kessel, and Guentzel could each have an individual goal scoring song like baseball players/fighters get walkout songs; what would they be (or what you'd want them to be)?
Jason Mackey: I would pick Sid to go with Tim McGraw. Something like "I Like It, I Love It." ... Malkin would probably be some sort of weird rap/dance thing I've never heard of ... or probably anyone else in the United States has heard of, for that matter. Kessel, that's the million-dollar one. Would have to be funny, right? I feel like "Walking on Sunshine" would work. Maybe Tom Jones' "It's Not Unusual" or Sonny & Cher's "I Got You Babe."
mustardbased: Along the "stupid things" line ... when the team adheres to Sullivan's system, really good things tend to happen. Why is the team seemingly so insistent on so often NOT adhering to Sullivan's system? Is it a coaching problem or a player-leadership problem?
Jason Mackey: I think it's a human-being problem. Nobody, in any walk of life, adheres 100 percent all the time to what their boss tells them to do. Either they think they have a better idea or want to it differently. The Penguins are no different. It just so happens that their office is in a rather public place. Trust me, what you see with them is hardly unique among professional sports franchises. And it drives coaches nuts.
First-Timer: Hi Jason, love the chats. Couple quick points; interested in your take on them: 1) seems Pens take a game or 2 to adjust to defensive-style teams (see; Ottawa, Nashville). 2) Perspective: Pens lose Gm 1, on the road, in overtime, to a team that was giddy for the playoffs after such a long wait. If the Pens can lose in OT while not playing their best hockey, that has to be seen as a positive. Thanks!
Jason Mackey: You're way too logical to be here, first off. Secondarily, you bring up a lot of really good points. I just don't understand the massive freakout over one game.
Rory : Am i the only one that thinks Rust and Maatta are playing with a whole lot of apprehension. Maatta is just getting out hustled in the corners and Rust is thinking way too much in getting hurt. You can never play on the edge when you let fear dictate your play.
Jason Mackey: I think it's hard to make that assertion when you don't know what's going on inside their brains. I sure as heck don't. I don't think you do, either. They've certainly made mistakes. Criticize those all you want. Rust needs to score more than he has recently. Believe one goal in 14, no points in his past six. But you can't tell me you watched the guy(s) play a hockey game on television and you know exactly what's going through their heads.
Matt Murray talks about the Penguins' loss to Islanders in Game 1
PortVue in VA: Do you see Geno righting the ship penalty wise? Didn't see why he was put in the bin yesterday
Jason Mackey: I thought the officiating left a lot to be desired. They were wildly inconsistent. Geno has been better in that department.
Guest: Nothing against Zar but he takes a few games to get going when he comes back from injuries and the playoffs are not the time to do that . Blueger did not deserve to come out
Jason Mackey: I agree with you. I expect to see Sullivan get Blueger in for Game 2, either for ZAR or Wilson.
Matt: Just want some validation on my thoughts, I was initially pretty upset but in hindsight, most if not all islanders goals came from dumb mistakes, other than that they weren’t given much and we shouldn’t be as worried as Twitter makes it seem?
Jason Mackey: Yes. The Twitter is an evil website.
John P: Do you the team will be distracted on Sunday knowing that Game of Thrones premieres that day too?
Jason Mackey: I hope not. Isn't GoT at night? (I've never watched an episode. But I am excited to watch the Masters.)
Hornqvist Fan: Jason you’re work & knowledge is very much respected. I appreciate the time & effort you put into covering this team. I realize the Pens can’t win every game. Thanks for letting us vent when we’re frustrated.
Jason Mackey: Ha. My pleasure. Thanks for coming here to do it. I need to be more understanding on where you guys are coming from, too. Never want to make it sound like I'm bashing anyone. Just trying to be a voice of reason here. It ain't that bad
Chicago_pens_fan: Why wilson over blueger, who brings a lot more to the table?
Jason Mackey: I don't understand why Blueger was scratched. He's the best offensive and defensive option of the three guys competing for those two final spots.
Joeco: I appreciate the articles about human side of the players
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Joeco. I like writing them. A really nice change of pace. I just like the variety my job presents, and I've been appreciating that more lately: Chats, notebooks, features, analysis, game stories, video, radio, whatever. There's a lot of different components. But the human-interest features are one of my favorite things to do.
Rain: Wow Sid got a lot of hate on his play tonight. I only caught the third period on, so was he really as bad as netizens are saying? Is it really time to worry that he might have been gassed carrying the team to the playoffs, or do you figure chances are he comes back with a vengeance on fri? i’m sure he’s practicing his head off after that loss
Jason Mackey: What's crazy to me is Sid not getting a pass here. He's been so damn good all season. Even if he played the worst game of his life, so what? It's Game 1 of the first round.
Dave P: What lines would you like to see Friday? I personally think McCann should be on the first line
Jason Mackey: I would flip McCann and Rust, Blueger in for Wilson (would stick with ZAR) and leave the other forward spots the same. I'd bring in Johnson for Maatta.
Snake Plissken: Am I wrong in thinking that the Penguins looked a little scared of the physicality last night, and are often bullied by Trotz teams?
Jason Mackey: I think you're wrong, Snake. Sorry. They made some mistakes, but I don't think it was because they were "scared." I think they were careless at times.
Jimmy from Long Island: For all those complaining about the ice, be happy the 1st round wasn't in Brooklyn. That ice in spring is 100x worse.
Jason Mackey: Everything (hockey-related) is worse in Brooklyn.
Joeco: I loved your articles on the human side of the players (Sully and his son/McCann and his mom). As a fan you get to appreciate the players more. Q - how are you able to approach players on those topics and are the willing to open up?
Jason Mackey: Yes, mostly. You do need to pick your spots. McCann is easy because he's one of the world's nicest people. But generally you wanna make sure a guy is cool with talking about something before you turn the recorder on. You also probably want to arrange time so he's able to compose his thoughts, TV guys don't jump your interview, you can speak in a more relaxed way. Pens media relations is always great about making that happen. And if a guy doesn't want to talk about something, you respect his space.
Guest: Big take away from last night was Kessel and malkin looked great . That is a good sign
Jason Mackey: Might be the biggest takeaway.
KM: How likely is it that the defense figures out the islanders forecheck tomorrow? Can’t remember seeing a team struggle with pressure that much in a while
Jason Mackey: Gonna be a huge key. I think Matt Vensel is gonna break that down tomorrow. And it's not just the defense, either. It's a five-man effort. Six in some cases when it involves Murray playing the puck.
Brian: I hardly ever hear about what Mark Recchi brings to the coaching table as far as systems and decision making. Does he have a specific role for game planning?
Jason Mackey: Recchi brings a lot. I can't sit here and accurately tell you specific roles -- or super specific roles when it comes to game-planning. I do know Recchi does a lot of the prescout stuff with Andy Saucier. Watching teams a couple games out on the schedule, figuring out tendencies, distilling what he sees down into important teaching points. He also works with guys after skates, on individual skills, specifically the forwards. He does plenty.
Dave P: Will the refs from last night officiate the rest of the series? They were terrible. I get letting them play but a lot of terrible no calls. Dumo hit high, a few slashing calls missed both ways, holding Sid multiple times in OT
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I agree with you. They missed stuff. They called stuff they shouldn't. Both ways. I'm honestly not sure on that first part. I'm gonna check on it.
Andy: I was screaming for Sullivan to not start the top line each period. It is harder to match up during the flow of play especially in the 2nd period and OT. Start one of the other three lines and make Trotz adjust. The other 3 lines dominated their matchups... get some momentum instead of starting each period on your heels.
Brian: For those of us with Islander fans as friends, can you give me one single comeback line that will quiet them when the chirping starts?
Jason Mackey: Did you try a mirror? I kid, I kid. ... Let them have their fun. This is cool.

Chuck: Heard that the Isles were a horrible face off team yet it seemed like they dominated??? Just a bad night for Sid and the guys or Isles play over their heads?
Jason Mackey: They won 55 percent. Faceoffs are overrated. I don't think it's anything to worry too much about.
Eddie Vedder: Are the Penguins allowed to suit up Sergei Gonchar for Game 2?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so, but do you really think he would be the Better Man?
BB: Jason - going to mix it up a little here because all the questions I would have asked have already been answered. Any chance the Pens wear their 3rd jerseys (gold) for a home game this playoffs to match the "gold out" for the fans? Are teams even allowed to wear alternate jerseys in the playoffs?
Jason Mackey: I don't think you're gonna see that, honestly. And I'll be honest: I don't know the answer off the top of my head. I thought you had to pick one home/road sweater and stick with it. But I can't say I'm 100 percent confident there. I also need to get this finished up and get ready to head over to practice. Sorry.
Kirby Hogenmiller: Do you think Sullivan needs to stop trying to achieve Balance on all three lines and load up the top 6 I.E Kessel with Malkin. Seems like what happened in 2016 with HBK is a hard thing to achieve. Also Why do you think Sullivan keeps taking McCann off the first line they seem to score at least 1 goal per game together doesnt he see that?
Jason Mackey: I think what Sullivan had last night with his second and third lines worked just fine. Those guys were just great. Although I don't know why he seems averse to keeping McCann on that line. It could have something to do with wanting Jake on the left side.
Hornqvist Fan: Jason this is my last thought in today’s chat. I don’t mean to overwhelm. In my earlier question about stupid things I guess it comes down to discipline. Despite all the skill & experience a team needs a certain amount of discipline to succeed. I think this team has too often gotten by on skill & lacks basic fundamental discipline in critical parts of their game.
Jason Mackey: OK, thank you for the thought and participating. ... I don't disagree with you. I think the Penguins just need to be a little smarter with their decisions.
guest: I agree with you on how crazy it is crosby doesnt get a pass. Why are pens fans so hard on him? Are we too pampered....
Jason Mackey: Sometimes I think Penguins fans forget what they have, yes.
Ron J: How can Letang make such a dumb play in overtime ?
Jason Mackey: He took a risk, Ron. A bad risk. Wasn't the first time he's tried something that was unnecessarily risk.
joeco: in a tight game like the islanders play, does home ice provide much of an advantage for the PENS? for example getting better match ups for SId's line?
Jason Mackey: Yes, I think that will actually be fairly important, to get that group away from the Islanders fourth line.
Guest: Do you think the NHL allows too much "subtle" interference plays to happen during games? I feel like the Pens have great forechecking players who are constantly interfered with when trying to force turnovers on a D-man. I don't think you can completely remove that part of the game, but sometimes it just seems way too obvious what the player interfering is doing
Jason Mackey: Yes, I do. But I think it's inherent in officials' eyes at this time of year. It's just gonna happen. I'm not sure that part of the game is ever gonna change. Sadly.
Guest: Is Maatta done in Pittsburgh after this season?
Jason Mackey: I think he's the most tradable asset they have on defense. You're not gonna keep him or Gudbranson. At this point, I have a tough time seeing them get rid of Gudbranson, especially given he's a righty.
RPK: Jason, isn't Sullivan responsible for the paly of his team? If not, why is he even there? Maata over Johnson? Simon over Blueger?
Jason Mackey: We've been through this, RPK. He's responsible -- but to a point. When a guy makes a stupid play with the puck, do you think that's what Sullivan is coaching him to do? You can put it on Sullivan because the buck stops with him, but how about talking about the guys who are playing the game?
Guest: Is there a chance Dumoulin isn’t healthy but is playing regardless because it’s crucial? And will we ever see DeSmith again? Murray has started 23 consecutive games...wheels might fall off soon.
Jason Mackey: You wanna start DeSmith after Murray had an average game in a one-goal loss in Game 1 of the postseason? Geesh.
Rob: In your opinion what is the one thing that has to happen for the Pens to win this series? (Aside from scoring more goals obviously)
Jason Mackey: They need to be more careful with the puck and not giving the Islanders stuff they didn't earn. They literally handed the Islanders the game last night. Eliminate that stuff, and the Islanders don't have enough firepower to beat the Penguis.
Jason Mackey: Penguins
Andy: Kessel missed an empty net. Hornqvist missed a cross crease half empty net where he shot it at the goalie. Malkin had a grade A chance on the doorstep. All of the NYI goals were direct results of a careless turnover, an absurd and unnecessary icing by Olli Maatta and Brian Dumoluin (of all people) blowing his in zone coverage. It wasn't like NYI were the superior team, who were whipping around tape to tape passes and dominating play. Pens clean up the sloppy and finish off more of the Grade A chances, things will get really tough for the Isles.
Jason Mackey: I agree with you. Penguins were right there.
Kirby Hogenmiller: Why Do you think People get hard on the Pens for losing one game when all they've done in the past 10 years is make the playoffs and win 3 cups? I feel like they deserve a bit more slack compared to other disapointing teams in Pittsburgh.
Jason Mackey: I would think so, too, but they usually don't get it. Tough standard, I guess, I don't know.
Who me?: I hope that was sarcasm on the Faceoffs is overrated comment....
Jason Mackey: I wasn't. Go back and look at faceoff percentages for successful teams over the last, say, five years. There's not much of a correlation.
Dave: I would like to see the Pens play a more patient game, I felt they were constantly trying to force plays that weren't there. The turnovers really fed the Isles attack. If we play more patiently, come back deep as a 5 man group, to help our D, our chances will come. We have way more fire power from an offensive standpoint, we will inevitably get our looks. Playing above the puck and not getting caught deep, we will create more turnover chances in the neutral zone as well.
Jason Mackey: I think Mike Sullivan has joined the chat, folks.
Jason Mackey: Just messing with you, Dave. You make some very good points. Anyway, I gotta go get ready for practice. Thanks everyone for participating. Talk to yinz again next week.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.