Every Wednesday, as the Penguins make their push toward another Stanley Cup, reporter Matt Vensel will answer your questions about the team. If you would like to submit one for next week’s installment, you can email Matt at mvensel@post-gazette.com or send one to him on Twitter @mattvensel.

Matt: Seb, assuming Brian Dumoulin returns to the lineup early in this first-round series — him being good to go for Game 1 is a possibility but not a lock — and no other defensemen get injured before then, I believe the odd man out initially would be Olli Maatta. The key word is initially.

If someone struggles due to mental miscues or a bad matchup and Maatta, a steady two-time champion, is chilling in the press box, Mike Sullivan won’t hesitate to change his lineup. He showed he was willing to make tough personnel decisions in postseasons past.

Back to Maatta. His skating can be a problem against speedy opponents. It’s not for a lack of effort, as he spent much of the offseason trying to attack that weakness. But Maatta being the likeliest candidate to be a healthy scratch has less to do with him than it does with everyone else.

Advertise with us

Unfortunately for Maatta, while he missed 21 games with a separated shoulder, a couple of pairs clicked. It also helped that Matt Murray started cleaning up more of the team’s messes.

Jack Johnson, as I argued in this space a couple of weeks ago, has been fine since a rocky start in Pittsburgh, and Justin Schultz and he have been solid since Schultz returned. Marcus Pettersson and Erik Gudbranson have worked well together, too, since Gudbranson arrived at the deadline. And Dumoulin and Kris Letang have long been a dynamite tandem.

Thus, Maatta likely watches Wednesday if Dumoulin is ready to rock. If not, it could be Johnson. But as Sullivan said Tuesday, everyone will probably need to pitch in to go on another deep run.

Matt: Just looking at the makeup of the roster, one thinks it comes down to Zach Aston-Reese and Garrett Wilson for the last spot. And, if practice the previous two days was any indication, that is indeed the case. Those two rotated in as Matt Cullen’s right wing on the fourth line.

Teddy Blueger, in my opinion, has earned his spot in the lineup with responsible two-way play and surprising scoring touch, though he needs to keep doing what he’s been doing to stay there.

Advertise with us

Aston-Reese and Wilson, meanwhile, do some of the same things. They throw their bodies around on the forecheck, they can be used on special teams and they are both willing to fight.

But while Wilson is the heavier hitter and presumably packs more punch, I don’t need to tell you that Aston-Reese is a more skilled offensive player than Wilson, who has two career goals. All four lines need to score in today’s NHL, and I want to see what Blueger, Cullen and ZAR can do.

I bet Sullivan does, too, which is why I expect Aston-Reese to step into that slot soon, Brandon.

Matt: It comes down to whether he skates with Evgeni Malkin or with Nick Bjugstad, Ken.

We know what Kessel and Malkin can do together. They can take over games with their quick-strike ability. But when they’re not scoring much, they can be a net-negative for the Penguins.

Advertise with us

We have not seen much of Kessel with Bjugstad. I thought they showed promise early on following the acquisition of Bjugstad. Those two skated together in a few games because Malkin was out with his first injury. But Sullivan must not have been too impressed. He didn’t keep them together for long and they didn’t play together much while Malkin was hurt again to close the season.

That’s why I was a little surprised when they skated together at practice Monday and Tuesday. But we know Sullivan likes to spread his top talents throughout the lineup. We’ll see if this sticks.

I usually liked what I saw from the previous third line of Bjugstad, Dominik Simon and Patric Hornqvist. Their collective style should translate to the playoffs, particularly this first-round matchup with the Islanders. I would keep them together and leave Kessel with Malkin and see how that goes. If that third line struggles, making the Penguins top heavy, sure, change it up.

Matt: This makes sense to me, David, but not because of the pressure part. This is a veteran group, so they won’t be fazed if the Nassau Coliseum is indeed rowdy.

I don’t think it’s the worst thing that the Penguins are away from home to start the series and will have to play their “road game,” which is probably more a regular season thing than a playoff thing but is still something. With the way the Islanders play, a tight defensive structure that can frustrate flashy teams, maybe being on the road to start helps them be patient and keep it simple.

Advertise with us

Matt: Thomas, I felt that way until March rolled around and the Penguins, specifically their starting goalie, settled into a groove. No, they didn’t win every game. And there were a couple of real duds in there. But they were usually, as you and the head coach say, “playing the right way.”

Now, I feel better about their chances of making some noise in these playoffs. Murray needs to keep it going. Malkin, Kessel and Hornqvist have to produce as they are paid. Letang must stay in the lineup. Johnson and Gudbranson need to hold up. The power play has to deliver.

That’s a lot of ifs, I know. Every team has them. But if the Penguins keep picking up steam, they’ll have a decent chance.

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel. Click here to subscribe to our weekly Penguins newsletter, From The Point.