On paper, the Penguins and New York Islanders look like completely different teams.
Coach Barry Trotz’s team wants to play defense-first and will be playing in just its fifth playoff series in the past 13 years.
Coach Mike Sullivan’s Penguins, meanwhile, prefer to play fast, keep the puck in the offensive zone and have the NHL’s longest active postseason streak — now at 13 years.
It should be a fascinating push-and-pull starting with Game 1 of their Eastern Conference quarterfinal series Wednesday at Nassau Coliseum.
Before things get going, though, here are five reasons the Penguins could win and five factors that could conceivably contribute to them losing the series:
Why they might win:
Read More
1. Evgeni Malkin, Phil Kessel and Patric Hornqvist are all good at hockey, specifically scoring goals.
OK, there’s some intentional oversimplification there, but these guys have a history of producing in crunch time. Why should anyone expect anything less?
Malkin had 10 goals and 28 points the last time the Penguins won the Stanley Cup, and he appears ready to put a frustrating regular season behind him.
Kessel and Hornqvist, meanwhile, have shown significant signs over the past few weeks of getting their respective games back in order.
2. With Malkin and Kris Letang back, the Penguins power play has the potential of erupting at a huge time, especially against a penalty kill that has struggled. In their final 11 games of the regular season, the Islanders killed off just 17 of 25 power-play opportunities for the other team.
For the season, Trotz’s team is below 80 percent, and the Islanders were just 18-15-5 during the regular season when they allowed a power-play goal.
It’s easy to forget because their struggles have been sort of clumped together, but this remains an extremely dangerous part of the Penguins’ team concept.
3. Matt Murray has been lights out, and the offensively challenged Islanders aren’t the team to change that.
Since Feb. 23, Murray is top-five among qualifying netminders in wins (11, second), goals-against average (2.33, fifth) and save percentage (third, .928).
The Islanders have the third-worst power play in the league and just three guys with 20 or more goals. Nobody has exceeded 30. Meanwhile, their leading point-producer, Mathew Barzal, would rank fifth on the Penguins.
4. The Penguins are finally healthy.
Even if he doesn’t start the series — officially he’s a game-time decision — Brian Dumoulin is close. Everybody else on the back end is back, and the same goes for the forwards. It’s the healthiest the Penguins have been in months.
Add to that how the Penguins defensemen have been playing without their best true defender — allowing an average of 2.25 goals per game — and there’s plenty to like here.
5. The Penguins are experienced. The Islanders are not.
Did you know the Islanders have won just one playoff series since David Volek crushed the hopes of a city in 1992-93?
Since then, the only other time the Islanders won a playoff series was 2015-16, against the Florida Panthers, with three of their four wins requiring overtime.
The Penguins have navigated their way through 10 playoff series over the past three years, losing just one of them.

Why the Penguins could lose:
1. At times this season, their offense hasn’t been diverse enough.
If the extended scoring slumps that plagued Malkin, Kessel and Hornqvist during the regular season persist, the Islanders could focus their efforts on stopping Sidney Crosby’s line.
The Penguins have also gotten inconsistent goal production from their fourth line, at one point going 22 consecutive games without a goal from that group.
If they’re going to make a first-round exit, it could be a shortage of goals, especially …
2. If the Islanders are just too difficult to solve.
This won’t be an easy task for the Penguins, who are going to have to be patient and take extra special care of the puck. The Penguins would not be the first team the Islanders have frustrated and smothered into submission.
But some of their defensive marks are deceiving.
During five-on-five play, they allowed the ninth-most scoring chances (1,829) during the regular season, the 14th-most high-danger chances (724). The difference was goaltending, as Robin Lehner and Thomas Greiss compiled the best five-on-five save percentage in the entire league at .937.
Game 1 figures to be the first time Lehner will start a playoff game.
3. The injuries could also be a ruse.
Malkin has been dinged up, the same for Letang. Dumoulin has been battling something for the past few games.
Add to that Hornqvist’s previous concussion issues — two this season, five since December 2014 — or the freaky things that have happened to Murray throughout his career, and it could wind up becoming too tough of a hurdle to overcome.
4. The Penguins could also stink on special teams.
Sure, it’s easy to say that Malkin and Letang will propel the power play, and they might. But the Penguins have the third-worst penalty kill in the league since Jan. 18 and have allowed a power-play goal in five of their past six.
Also, since 2015, the Penguins are 10-11 when allowing a power-play goal in a playoff game compared to 28-12 when they do not.
As mentioned, the Islanders aren’t a huge threat on special teams, but the Penguins have run a little more hot and cold here than they’d like.
5. What if that weird late-goal thing pops up again?
It’s easy to forget because Murray was otherwise terrific, but the Penguins went through a bit of a freaky, 14-game stretch in March.
During that time, they allowed eight goals within the final 3:01 of regulation or overtime. In a few cases, it was enough to cost the Penguins a point.
It might be a stretch to call it the yips, but whatever it was, the Penguins will want to keep it from coming back.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.