Olli Maatta speaks after Thursday's morning skate: 3.21.19
NASHVILLE, Tenn. — It’s a question on the minds of most Penguins fans.
For good reason, too, considering the team finds itself in the thick of a playoff push.
When Olli Maatta comes back, who sits?
With Maatta taking contact for the first time Thursday, it appears likely he’ll receive the green light at some point on this road trip.
Here’s a few routes the Penguins could take:
Play the matchups
Read More
Erik Gudbranson has exceeded pretty much every reasonable expectation since the deadline deal that brought him to Pittsburgh.
But coach Mike Sullivan could feel that Gudbranson’s physical presence may not be as necessary against certain teams — likely the ones who employ more of a speed-based approach.
That means Sullivan could decide who his most useful six defensemen are for a given game and adjust his lineup accordingly.
Change nothing
Sullivan could also keep Maatta out of the lineup until he’s forced to make a move, either because of injury or underperformance.
It’s a fairly logical route in one sense: The guys who have been playing have comported themselves well since the Penguins incurred the injury bug on the back end.
But it could be problematic if you think about this summer.
With so many defensemen under contract, and the Penguins always needing to be mindful of salary-cap space, they could be scratching someone (Maatta or Gudbranson) who would have legitimate value to other teams.
Would that raise any red flags? Would it lessen what general manager Jim Rutherford could get in return?
Maatta and Gudbranson — who both make $4 million or more and could create some much-needed breathing room under the cap if they were moved — would both benefit from playing and showing other teams that they’re useful players.
The young guy
One option could be sitting Marcus Pettersson, although that doesn’t appear likely given his emergence as a reliable contributor.
Pettersson ranks second among rookie defensemen in assists (20) and plus/minus (plus-14). He’s third in points (22).
If the Penguins are intent on winning now — which they absolutely are — it might not be smart business to remove someone who has been so solid and also contributes on the power play.
An unorthodox option
Given the fourth line’s struggles — no goals in 19 games before Thursday — Sullivan could use seven defensemen and 11 forwards.
The problem with that is a big one: Sullivan has never been a big fan of the idea.
While he didn’t rule it out following Thursday’s morning skate, he also seemed to brush it aside as a realistic option.
“We’re open to anything,” Sullivan said. “As a coaching staff, as a rule, we’ve never been a believer in seven D, but obviously with the complement of the defensemen that we have, it’s something that certainly we could take into consideration.”
Whatever happens, it appears the Penguins’ ability to kick the can is lessening. A decision must be made soon. And no matter what happens, it should certainly be interesting.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.