Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my Thursday chat. Thanks for participating. Let's get started. FYI, we're going to have a hard cap at 3; I have some copy to turn around. So I'm going to avoid answering questions that have already been answered. Hope you understand.

LordDale: How long is Malkin & Reece gonna be out ?

Jason Mackey: Malkin is week-to-week, ZAR longer-term. They're expected back by the postseason. I do not believe either is skating at this time.

Popa: Kessel's gone 24 games without a 5v5 goal. It's been 28 for Hornqvist. No goals for the fourth line in 19 games. Does this team have enough scoring depth to make a run even if Malkin comes back?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Not with those numbers, Popa. They might win a round like that, not much more. Even with Malkin back, that's too many passengers to make a run. That said, they have capable people. But they have to get more five-on-five from those guys, and they have to get the occasional contribution from the fourth line.

Jeremy/ Springfield,Mo: So are the pens ever going to get out of this slump? And the coughing up game tying goals with under a minute is really driving me nuts.

Jason Mackey: I think they will. I think they're gonna be OK. But I hear ya. As a fan, I'm sure it's maddening right now. I just have a hard time seeing this team, with what it's been through, with what's at stake, failing to rise to the challenge here.

Mike : Do you have a feel of the overall vibe the penguins have about everyone getting back healthy for the playoffs?

Jason Mackey: The vibe is that they expect to have everyone back. I also think there's a vibe -- confidence, something -- of feeling like they're going to be just fine playoff time.

Advertise with us

Rob: Hi JM, big fan of the Post-Gazette's Penguins coverage all the way from St. John's, Newfoundland. When Mike Sullivan took over as HC he seemed to instill in the team a level of composure vis-a-vis the referees that it previously lacked. Does it appear to you that the team is losing/has lost that composure? Are the Pens re-acquiring (assuming they ever lost it) a reputation among the officials for being whiny/disrespectful?

Jason Mackey: Hi Rob, you bring up a good point. I don't know about acquiring a reputation, but I do think they yap more than they used to. Just last game, look at Crosby and Letang. That stuff doesn't happen on March 19, 2016. Sullivan would've put an end to it. I think they need to stop worrying about the officials so much, right or wrong, and just play. Feel like someone should coin that phrase.

Syl Apps: I've always been struck by how professional the pens are in post-game comments, even after they lose and are expressing frustration. How much of this is attributable to the example set by Sid, who is clearly seething at times but is unfailingly polite? Considering how good they seem to be in answering questions from the media, is it challenging to get a sense of when to not push too far? I really can't think of the last blowup by someone in the locker room. Thanks.

Jason Mackey: I think some of it is Sid, but I also think it's attribute to the Penguins employing good people -- regardless of what you think about how they play hockey -- and also the culture of the sport. There's not a single Big Chest in the entire league. It's one of the reasons I (and others) love it so much. They're frustrated, sure. But hockey players are a different breed of professional athlete.

Mike : When Olli Maatta is healthy who is the odd man out on defense?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: When everyone is healthy ... two points. ... It looks like it could be Maatta, honestly. He was full go today -- and not in the lineup. I think you could see Sullivan potentially play matchups, using Gudbranson against more physical teams, or go 11/7, though he has always hated 11/7. ... I think they can kick the can for one more game, but probably Saturday in Dallas they'll have to make a legit decision. Tonight could have a lot to do with who's scratched.

Hairyest True-man: Why hasn't Dominik Simon ever been mentioned in discussions of possible fourth-line centers, despite having been a successful center for WBS?

Jason Mackey: Sullivan has said a few times that he doesn't view as an NHL center. You can disagree -- and probably do. But the coach likes his playmaking ability on the wing more.

Guest: What’s gonna happen to Olli? Will he come back in the lineup? Is he gonna be traded this summer? The defense seems to have held up well and it seems like they can move on from him.

Jason Mackey: First part: It's TBD. They also might juggle. ... Same for his status. Let the season play out (I know that's hard, that we all have to have answers now.) That will dictate whether he's actually traded. I know this: GMJR will likely move a defenseman over the summer. Olli is in the conversation of guys who are candidates.

Advertise with us

Guest: What do you think the terms on the ZAR and Pettersson extensions will look like?

Jason Mackey: Too early to accurately predict anything there, but they're not going to be bank-breaking.

Guest: Olli Maatta: traded or no by July 1st?

Jason Mackey: My gut says no, but I wouldn't rule anything out.

Frank: Would it be wise for the Pens to seek to trade some of their above-30 players with limited no-movement clauses before having to protect them in the next expansion draft?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Yes. And I think you will see them do that this summer, although I don't think it's as much related to the expansion draft as it is trying to skew younger and sustain their championship window with the right guys and cheaper contracts.

GSMP: Is Juuso Riikola's demotion a sign team has lost faith in him or a case of Zach Troutman passing him on the depth chart?

Jason Mackey: They haven't lost faith in him, No. 1. But Trotman has played very well. Riikola can go to WBS and work on stuff. They like that. I think they have a pretty good idea what type of player Trotman is and can be. With Riikola, I think he's still figuring out who he is over here. So, Trotman has passed him, but I think there's a bit of an asterisk attached to it.

AB420: Do you think Dumo only thought the hit from Simmonds was clean because he can't remember it all that well due to being concussed by such a dirty hit.

Jason Mackey: No. I think someone probably showed him the same camera angle I saw, which honestly absolves Simmonds. They should release it.

Advertise with us

Stephan: What do you expect the Dcore to look like going into next season? Are we going to move Maatta?

Jason Mackey: It's too early to tell, honestly.

Christian: Hi Jason, what is wrong with Phil? Is it his conditioning, his age? He doesn’t look confident and isn’t playing with assertiveness. He loses a lot of 1 on 1 battles and is a turnover machine. He looks nothing like the player he was 2-3 years ago.

Jason Mackey: I think there's a couple things going on with Phil. One, confidence. It's lacking. He's mentally twisted up right now instead of playing instinctual hockey. Two, I think he's in a spot -- maybe it's age, maybe it's not -- where he's not getting as much separation as he used to, thus he's not shooting as much. I think he needs to get over that ... or do whatever he has to do to shoot more. It's not conditioning, I don't think. And c'mon, when he was producing, how many one-on-one battles was Phil winning? He's a goal-scorer. There's a problem because he's not scoring goals, which is fair. But I'm not about to start questioning his board work or something like that.

guest: Hi Jason, it has been a very frustrating roll coaster year to be a Pens fan. I think it best to just accept they are one of many above average teams that will not get past Wash or Tampa. Too many things to correct to right the ship.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think it's too early to make that sort of determination. Also, how many "fans" just say, "Welp, they stink. I'm done." C'mon now.

guest: It was interesting watching the Philly game in that it never seemed to get nasty or too physical. Do you attribute that to Simmonds being gone from that team and he was the route cause of alot of the nastiness?

Jason Mackey: I don't think so. I think Philly knew it needed that game to keep its playoff hopes alive, and any sort of stupidity would only take away from that. Or at least that's what I keep telling myself.

Matt in Cleveland: When Matta returns, doesn't he have to replace a left hander (Petterson most likley) since the right/left combos have seemed to stabilized the D?

Jason Mackey: He could. It depends on how Sullivan wants to construct his six. I think he likes having everyone on their strong sides, but I don't think he's married to it, either. I think he'd rather have his best six on the ice.

Advertise with us

Matt in Cleveland: Do the Pens and/or the Pens Media have an NCAA pool?

Jason Mackey: I think the Pens do. The media does not have anything together, although I'm sure we're all doing them with our outlets, wives, etc.

Frank: What percentage of NHL officials are not Canadian? If the NHL hired an amoumt of European officials proportionate to the its European players, would the game be called more by rule than by Canadian tradition?

Jason Mackey: Per Scouting the Refs, it looks like 20.7 percent (17 of 82) are not Canadian. https://scoutingtherefs.com/nhl-officials/

Jason Mackey: And no, I don't think that would change anything. I think the NHL wants its product to look a certain way -- you might debate that, but it's true -- whether its on-ice officials are from the United States, Canada, Finland or Australia.

Advertise with us

Guest: Kessel has been terrible. Rutherford’s recent comments saying Phil will be fine, worry me. Is he being truthful? Do you think the front office will finally trade Phil this summer becUse

Jason Mackey: What do you want GMJR to say in that context? Yep. I'm freakin' out and couldn't sleep the past three nights because of Phil. Of course he's going to pump his player's tires, hoping Phil reads it.

Guest: Do you think this Pens team is as tight as the Cup-winning teams? To me, it looks like they’re not having as much fun out there?

Jason Mackey: It's tough to say. You're comparing those others (who had playoff experiences, which is where the most fun was had) with one that has not experienced that. I don't think we'll know until playoffs. Yes, things can kinda look mundane right now. But the regular season is loooong.

JohnAl: In your talk with Scott Young and he mentioned Lauzon going to development camp, do they expect to sign him to an ELC or would it be an AHL only deal?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I did not talk to him specifically about that. I think that's a little too far down the road. I think they need to see his health keep improving because thinking about that stuff.

Guest: What do you think the Pens chances are of, first, avoiding the WC2 spot and Tampa in the first round, and second, beating the Metro teams they face, including Washington, and making the ECF?

Jason Mackey: I see the Penguins finishing in the 2/3 spot in the Metro. I think the only question is who they play -- NYI, CAR or CBJ. I'm rooting for CBJ.

Jason Mackey: ***Note: This has nothing to do with hockey reasons. Just logistically the easiest and a great city.

Jason: Why is there no accountability when players constantly turn over pucks? All you ever hear is we need to correct it but you never see players benched for lousy pick control. Wouldn’t the coach be making a statement to sit players who constantly do this I.E 71 even for a game or two.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I'm pretty sure they're trying to lose. And HCMS prefers as little accountability as possible, praising players when they discard any attempt at thoughtfulness and just wing it.

Jason Mackey: I'm joking, obviously, but they're not gonna bench Malkin. This isn't junior high.

Gus: It is early, but the way the Pens have been so inconsistent all season makes me think a deep playoff run is not going to happen. Therefore, any thoughts as to what the return for Phil Kessel would be this summer? I have never cared for the trade - hes a one dimensional (lazy) player who only has a wrist shot (unable to slap shot, one timer, play defense). As of late, his turnovers have cost us many goals against, and I'll be glad to see him go.

Jason Mackey: I think GMJR, as he did last summer, will listen on Phil. If he gets an offer that makes sense, I think he'll do it. I think his threshold this summer will also be lower than it was last summer. Will he do anything? I think that depends on the interest. Last summer there wasn't a ton.

dave: Do you think Cullen might be a healthy scratch at some point? He can't stop getting kicked out of faceoffs, and he doesn't seem to have much scoring ability any more.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Geez. He was playing with Joseph Blandisi and Garrett Wilson. I wouldn't be looking at him to score 20 goals. And getting kicked out is not new. My colleague, Matt Vensel, actually talked to Cullen about this. Read his mailbag for more: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/penguins/2019/03/20/olli-maatta-in...

Jason Mackey: Short answer: No. There's zero thought whatsoever given to healthy scratching Cullen.

Nate: Love reading your work as a PA transplant in Boston. Very insightful. Last week in what a think was the Washington game holtby was out of position and a shot got past him but was ‘saved’ by a defender. I know that counts as a shot on goal but does the goalie get credit for the ‘save’ or does it get lost in the black hole of statistics.

Jason Mackey: That's a great question, Nate. Let me check on that. If someone knows it, please chime in. But I don't have an answer to give you that I feel 100 percent confident in.

dave: Do you think there's something wrong with Crosby? He's made some very uncharacteristic mistakes in the past few games.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: There's nothing wrong with Sidney Crosby.

Lord of carson: Jason. Any chance Sully was playing in the Czech league in and around the same time Dom Simon was born ?

Jason Mackey: None whatsoever.

Harold: Hi, Jason: Any reason you can ascertain that Sullivan is limiting Teddy Blueger's ice time the last couple of games? It was particularly surprising in the Flyers game, that he only played 11 minutes. The NBCSN announcers were very effusive in their praise of Blueger and had replays of a number of good plays he made throughout the game.

Jason Mackey: Blueger has played 14 or more minutes in four of the past five games. He's currently centering a line with Jared McCann and Phil Kessel. I'm not sure I agree with you that Sullivan is under-utilizing a rookie with 20 games on his NHL resume.

Advertise with us

Todd HH: Jason. I roundly acknowledge the great year Letang has had. But is there something , even back to their last Cup run , that the D is every bit as effective and maybe more so in a different way ?

Jason Mackey: One, you never turn away a player like Kris Letang if you have him available. Two, I think their D was a lot better back then than people -- including me -- gave them credit for. I think we're seeing that now. Three, I think it's an underrated thing for, as a defense corps, those guys to just make the simple play and not get too fancy, as has been the case when Letang has been out.

JohnAl: Re: Simon being a center. He wasn't one in WBS either. Or in the Czech league. Last time he was a center was in the Czech junior leagues.

Jason Mackey: I believe he said he saw some time there, although I could be wrong. Either way, it's not even close to an option.

Todd HH: Jason , I don’t think any Cup team would have the likes of Zar and Simon getting top 6 minutes. They simply don’t score enough themselves for that role. That and the black hole of offensive that’s their 4th line prevents this team from being a realistic Cup team. Thoughts ?

Jason Mackey: If your point is that they need more scoring depth, I agree. But I think ZAR and Simon could conceivably provide that. Have they? In stretches. I don't think it's smart to tie playoff success automatically if xxx or xxx is playing xxx minutes. That's not at all fact-based.

Eric: To your earlier point about scoring depth, besides the obvious (Crosby's line, Malkin, and Kessel) who has the best chance to get hot and to go on a streak with some pucks in the net on a consistent basis?

Jason Mackey: Can I say Hornqvist? My other two candidates would be Nick Bjugstad and Bryan Rust. Maybe Rust first. He has shown the ability to catch fire, and Bjugstad -- that line has been good -- has been shooting the puck a ton.

Nodak guest: I have liked the way Gudbranson has played so far since the trade. However, his contract makes me cringe. Do you think he will be out this summer? If not, what is the plan going forward to get more cap space?

Jason Mackey: I think they'll trade a D this summer. Gudbranson could be on. And I agree with you, he's been much better than advertised. I think who gets traded is still very much up in the air.

Bob in WV: What's your take on Marcus Pettersson? He seems like a liability at times.

Jason Mackey: I've liked his game a lot. Remember, too, that he's technically a rookie. He's going to make mistakes. That doesn't mean he should be shipped to the ECHL. Has a little bit of bite to his game. Moved the puck and skates well. Smart on the power play. Used his stick well. If I was Sullivan, he would be firmly in my top-six.

Spring: Do you think the Pens are going to make the play-offs? If they make the play-offs, do the Pens have any shot of making it out of the first round? Can we count on the likes of Simon, Cullen, Wilson, and Blueger contributing by getting goals?

Jason Mackey: I think they will make the playoffs. Making it around of the first round will depend on depth scoring -- at least in part. More than anything, they need to get Malkin healthy, get Kessel and Hornqvist productive and ensure they're getting the right version of Matt Murray. Beyond that would be worrying about the guys you mentioned.

Larry in KY: Malkin's injury, coupled with the questionable hits on Dumoulin and Rust, and the wrestling match with Letang, seem to point out that we "are not tough to play against". Just hit us and we won't respond.

Jason Mackey: Wasn't Letang doing what he did a response? And Gudbranson has been good. I have no qualms about the Penguins' ability to respond at this point.

guest: are all Pens fans debbie downers, or just the ones on your chats :)

Jason Mackey: It's bad this week. A lot of "sky is falling" sort of stuff.

FloridaSteelers: It seems Malkin has been hurt frequently this year opposed to years past. Is this age conditioning or just bad luck?

Jason Mackey: He's been hurt twice. I don't think that's a huge deal.

guest: Do you think Letang's injury has hurt his Norris chances?

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think they probably took a hit. Unfortunately I don't think his chances were that great beforehand. For whatever reason, he wasn't generating a ton of buzz for the award outside of Pittsburgh. It's a shame because he's having a tremendous year.

Donny: Why do the Penguins struggle so much in overtime? If they were 11-6 instead of 6-11, they'd be tied for 1st right now. Even though OT is typically a crapshoot, a team with their talent should be winning OT games more than just 35% of the time.

Jason Mackey: Agreed, Donny. It's been a combination of things, none of which involve talent. Could be staying out too long. Or sloppy changes. Or poor/lazy defense. Or dumb penalties. The Penguins have done all four. Oh, and some below-average goaltending. The Penguins have gone 5 for 5 in those categories at various points.

pauldia: More a comment,but here goes; Laast night Tampa vs Washington , Kucherov passed up passing to Johnson for a sure open net goal in his selfish, IMO, attempt to score an H.T. I have never seen that from Crosby or many others. Kucherov really dropped in my est after that as a Team guy. Early on Ovi was a selfish player but has really matured into a leader.

Jason Mackey: Thanks for your comment, but given what Kucherov and Tampa have done this year, I don't think any of us should be pretending we know better. We don't.

pauldia: sorry entered early. Will Tampa have a hard time winning a Cup with a selfish superstar?

Jason Mackey: I don't think Kucherov is a selfish superstar at all.

PensFan: Saying Hornqvist and Kessel need to get out of their funk and score is one thing and if we see it surely HCMS sees it - so with that being said - what is your opinion on what else can/should be done to make that happen and get them going again?

Jason Mackey: They need to get the power play figured out. And they can figure out the power play by adjusting their breakouts -- stop with the drop pass to Kessel crap, maybe have someone else carry the puck through the neutral zone -- and simplifying their approach. If those two guys can boost their confidence from the power play, or get feeling good again that way, I think it'll help.

Jerry: The last time a team from Canada won the Cup, it was a year just like this one. The Pens were heavy favorites to win the Cup in 1993, got upset in the 2nd round, and Montreal skated off with the Cup. Given that the Lightning are heavy favorites to win the Cup this year, could that bode well for Calgary or Winnipeg or even Toronto to get the Cup to Canada again?

Jason Mackey: Sure. I think Tampa is tremendous. But I also think it could hurt the Lightning that they've experienced basically no adversity this season. I think you need that.f

Just Me: Jason- What is the probability of a member of the coaching staff being relieved of duties if the Pens don't have a deep playoff run (and I'm not meaning Sullivan)

Jason Mackey: It depends on how things go, but this isn't the NFL. They're not gonna look for a fall guy. I mean, it's possible, but I wouldn't say it's terribly likely.

guest: you think they win tonight? we need a good Mackey prediction!

Jason Mackey: I actually think they will win, yes. Don't have a feel on a score, though.

Ryan : hey Jason do you think the penguins will have their eyes on any college hockey free agent defensemen and do you think Kasper Bjorkqvist turns pro this summer

Jason Mackey: They do have their eyes on a few. Talked to Scott Young about that this week. Haven't been able to find out who. But they are still shopping. And tough to say. I know he's real happy at Providence and has been playing well. Not sure there's an itch to leave, but I also wouldn't cop to having a super close relationship with Kasper Bjorkqvist either.

Subtlety: Sorry, I think we ran out of things to complain about. :o)

Jason Mackey: I have a hard time believing that.

PensFan: Who do you like better with Crosby and Guentzel - McCann or Rust?

Jason Mackey: I like McCann better. But I see what Sullivan's doing. He may be trying to use McCann's work rate and two-way game to help Blueger and free up Kessel. While he can play the left side, Rust has also been better on his right.

Eh?: Pretty amazing the no Leafs games this season have gone to a shootout, eh?

Jason Mackey: If that's the case -- this is a Penguins chat; I don't cover the Leafs -- that is pretty random.

JB: Not sure if this has been asked or not (either today or otherwise), but do you have a sense for how much the Pens practice 3-on-3 play in comparison to other teams? I don't know that anyone is going to give huge minutes to that in practice, but the Pens often look like they're just really uncomfortable with the whole thing in overtime, more so than other teams generally do.

Jason Mackey: I don't, honestly. I don't get to watch a lot of other teams practice. Usually all we see are morning skates, and nobody practices three-on-three then. I will say this: Their struggles are not due to a lack of practice time. It's a lack of execution ... or, in some cases, common sense.

Eric: What's your prediction for Pens playoff position? M1, M2, M3, WC1, or WC2?

Jason Mackey: M2 or M3.

Guest: Do you think it was a mistake to sign Hornqvist for five years at $5.3 mil a year, especially if he’s not playing with Sid or Geno? He’s doing everything but getting shots on net and goals, but to me his best use is not on the third line

Jason Mackey: I don't think it's right to call it a "mistake," especially not because we're ultimately going to make judgements based on the playoffs. His line has also been good. Do I think it's curious? Yes, I do. That much money, you need to play him with good people. I think Hornqvist also brings a lot of off-ice leadership to the room, although I realize that's a tough sell whenever things are as up-and-down as they've been.

PensFan: Just wanted to say thank you for answering my questions - I appreciate it! Have a great afternoon and thanks for the great work covering the Pens!

Jason Mackey: For sure. Thanks for participating. Have a good one!

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it. Gotta turn around some post-skate copy. We actually did get every question this week, minus a few redundant ones. Thanks for participating. Until next week ...