Penguins' GM talks about acquiring defenseman
A little more than 20 months ago, at the 2017 NHL Draft, Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford made a bet that the presence of Ryan Reaves would prove more important than his first-round pick that night at United Center in Chicago.
Rutherford made a similar wager Monday shortly before the NHL trade deadline, although at least this time he preserved his first-round pick.
In acquiring defenseman Erik Gudbranson from the Vancouver Canucks for Tanner Pearson, Rutherford basically went double or nothing on his belief that the Penguins need this particular type of player.
Gudbranson is a league-worst minus-27. Among defensemen who’ve logged at least 600 minutes, the 6-foot-5, 217-pounder ranks dead last in five-on-five goals-for (34.4) and scoring-chance (38.6) percentages. In 57 games, Gudbranson has two goals and eight points. His best offensive season was four goals and 13 points for the Florida Panthers in 2014-15.
Rutherford seemingly couldn’t care less, because of the elements that Gudbranson brings that the Penguins no longer have.
“In Erik’s case, he’s a real heart-and-soul guy,” Rutherford said Monday at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex. “He’s a good dressing room guy. He’s got good character. And he can protect our players. Puts us in a stronger position to push back when we get into more physical games.”
Read More
In 448 NHL games, Gudbranson — who won’t be available for Tuesday’s game in Columbus due to immigration issues — has fought 27 times. To put that in perspective, the 12 forwards the Penguins will dress against the Blue Jackets have a combined 24 fights at the NHL level.
Like Reaves, Gudbranson is more than willing to drop the gloves — and he’s good.
More of a concern, of course, will be Gudbranson finding the right role and partner, but Rutherford could ill-afford to wait around or get overly picky. Because of what happened Saturday night at Lincoln Financial Field, Rutherford, perhaps a little irritated, pushed his chips to the center of the table.
Since Reaves was dealt to the Vegas Golden Knights a year ago, the Penguins relied on Jamie Oleksiak to defuse situations like the one that arose against the Flyers, when Wayne Simmonds concussed Brian Dumoulin. Kris Letang came to the aid of his defense partner but was injured in a wrestling match with Shayne Gostisbehere.
Having someone like Gudbranson around, Rutherford figures, should help in that capacity. Both in limiting the freedom other players feel to hit or take liberties with the Penguins’ top players and via retaliation when something does inevitably occur.
Is Rutherford right? Should this sort of thing trump quantifiable on-ice influence? Only time will tell, but Rutherford does feel strongly that this sort of element was needed.
“We’re comfortable in a sense with [Zach] Aston-Reese and [Garrett] Wilson, guys who can push back in those more physical games,” Rutherford said. “But having another guy, especially on the back end, is going to give us more of a comfort level in that area.”

Timing was also a factor here, and Rutherford seemed happy that it worked out the way it did.
Dumoulin (concussion) and Letang (upper-body) are both out because of the injuries they suffered Saturday. They’ll miss Tuesday’s game in Columbus. Olli Maatta, too, remains out for, at minimum, a few more weeks with a shoulder injury.
A week ago, Rutherford said he checked on Gudbranson, thinking he needed some personality and toughness, and learned he wasn’t available. That time line changed Monday, as the Canucks started to part ways with a few assets.
“I was aware that he could be available maybe within the past week,” Rutherford said. “Talking about different things and who we might make available and whatnot, it took until this time to make that decision on which way we wanted to go.”
Whether or not Rutherford wants to admit it, the Penguins have undergone a huge change on the back end. Two years ago Monday, the Penguins beat the Flyers, 4-2, at Heinz Field, the first Stadium Series game between the teams.
The Penguins’ top six on defense that night included Dumoulin, Ian Cole, Trevor Daley, Ron Hainsey, Justin Schultz and Chad Ruhwedel.
Only Schultz and Ruhwedel remain, and they’ll be joined soon by Jack Johnson, Marcus Pettersson, Juuso Riikola and Gudbranson, all of them new this season.
Rutherford’s team, meanwhile, is clawing for every point, which only hastens the urgency for the chemistry to work.
“Hopefully Gudbranson can fit in pretty quick,” Rutherford said. “There’s not a lot of margin for error here down the stretch. We definitely need defensemen.”
And the Penguins, truthfully, need what Gudbranson can bring.
Their dressing room can be quiet at times, almost businesslike. That’s not bad, but the Penguins could use a pot-stirrer, someone to lighten things up every so often. On the ice, if nothing else, Gudbranson does serve as a nuclear deterrent.
Skeptics will question this deal because of the numbers listed above. But also remember the sort of stuff the Penguins have done with Schultz, Oleksiak, Cole, Ruhwedel and others on the back end, finding the good parts of their game, accentuating those and ironing out the remaining wrinkles.
The cost of Gudbranson was also not cheap. Forget Pearson and the one goal he scored over his final 16 games, but Rutherford essentially traded Carl Hagelin for Gudbranson. It’s yet another reason why Rutherford needs this to work.
“You have to find somebody who’s available that can come into your team and play a little bit,” Rutherford said. “There’s some guys out there. They wouldn’t fit our team.
“The nice thing about Erik is he’s a character guy. He’s a team guy. He’s going to help in the room. He’s going to make guys feel more comfortable. He’s got experience playing in the league.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.