Well, friends, we’ve reached the end of the road. The Penguins’ season came to an end a week ago today with their 2-1 overtime loss to the Capitals. The Penguins seemed to be in a good position in the second period of Game 5, when they were controlling play and poised to go up 3-2 in the series. But they lost that game in the third period, and dropped a tight, defensive contest in Game 6. At locker clean-out day, players were reflective of how great the last two years were, but also lamented a missed opportunity this time around.
Jim Rutherford also said that day that there will be changes in the offseason. Exactly what that means remains to be determined. The Penguins only have one unrestricted free agent in Carter Rowney, and Bryan Rust, Riley Sheahan, Tom Kuhnhackl, Dominik Simon and Jamie Oleksiak are restricted free agents. We’ll address their futures in the questions below. As always, some questions have been edited for clarity.
For the last time this season, let’s dive into the mailbag…
Erica F.: What do you think Jim Rutherford meant in his season-ending news conference when he said the team will look different next year? He wouldn’t have said that, would he, if all he was changing was a few depth guys? Do you think he is contemplating bigger moves over the offseason, such as trading Letang or Kessel?
Also, to that end, was the season-ending loss to the Caps really about some deficiency in the Pens’ roster or was it about: 1) failure to execute well — both in coaching and in playing — when the Caps started to trap; and 2) the Capitals just playing really, really well as a team?
Sam: It’s definitely interesting that Rutherford said there will be changes this offseason. That may seem like pretty generic GM talk for a team that just lost a playoff series, but the truth is, given their free agency situation, the Penguins don’t really have to make many changes if they don’t want to. Rutherford saying this team will look different next year is an indication that he wants to look different next year.
Read More
Now, exactly how big the changes are sort of depend on your framing. For instance, a lineup that includes Daniel Sprong and not, say, Carl Hagelin and/or Conor Sheary would be a pretty different, even if none of those moves would be totally out of left field.
As far as a blockbuster trade involving Phil Kessel and/or Kris Letang, I don’t get the sense Rutherford is actively pursuing either one. That’s not to say, however, that it’s impossible. If a team calls with a serious off for either one, I’d expect Rutherford to at least listen. Of the two, Kessel probably makes a bit more sense to move, given the pending log-jam at right wing if Sprong is indeed a lineup fixture next season. With Letang, I think the Penguins are willing to bet on a bounce-back year with a full offseason to train and prepare.

It’s also worth noting that with Kessel, Rutherford would be dealing from a slightly stronger position, as he’s coming off a 90-point season. When it comes to Letang, well, other NHL GMs watched Game 5 of the Washington series, too.
Which brings us to your second question, about the reasons for the Washington loss. I tend to lean more towards the other options you presented. Yes, there were certainly some holes in the Penguins’ lineup that showed a bit in this series, but if the Penguins’ stars played to their potential, they win this series and probably do so comfortably.
Also, this series was really, really close. Both Games 5 and 6 could’ve gone either way and, for as much talk as there always is about the Penguins “owning” the Capitals in the playoffs, the past three series between the teams have been incredibly tight. Eventually, the Penguins were bound to come up on the wrong side of one.
Jim Rutherford talks about making changes for next season
Figge L.: What do you think is the number 1 priority for the Pens this offseason?
Sam: This is sort of an interesting question, because there doesn’t seem to be one glaring area of need for the Penguins this year, as there was during The Great Third-Line Center Search of 2017. This offseason will likely more about just making all the pieces fit.
Really, the biggest priority for the Penguins this season is figuring out which contracts they want to keep, and which they want to shed. Hagelin, Sheary and Matt Hunwick (to a lesser extent, Kessel and Letang are part of this conversation, as well) all make more than their current production warrants. Getting one or two of those guys off the books is most likely on Rutherford’s to-do list this summer.
As far as additions, I do think they could do a bit more to bolster the blue line. The Matt Hunwick experiment failed pretty miserably this season, and while he could be in for a bounce-back year, you probably don’t want to bet on that. Chad Ruhwedel was perfectly serviceable as the sixth defenseman in the postseason, but the Penguins are a bit more comfortable with him in the No. 7 role. I could see an addition on defense, specifically on the right side.

Cindy42: How likely is It that Hagelin gets traded?
Sam: As always with Hagelin, this question mostly centers around whether or not you could find a team willing to take on his contract. It’s a bit more palatable now, considering Hagelin is coming off a strong season and there’s only one year left on the deal at this point.
The Penguins like Hagelin a lot, but if they could move him to open up a top-six spot for, say, Bryan Rust (moving Rust over to the left side, where he plays a bunch already), that might not be a significant decline.
The odds that Hagelin gets moved are probably right around 50/50. It depends on what sort of assets Rutherford can get back, what other wingers they consider to be in the picture for next year (i.e. Sprong, Sheary, Simon, Aston-Reese, etc.) and what other sort of players the Penguins are looking to add (if they want to make a move on John Tavares, they better free up cap space). Rutherford would be fine opening next year with Hagelin still on the roster, but he also wouldn’t say no to the right deal.
Darren V.: I’ve been convinced Sheary is a movable piece for a while now, if for no other reason cap space to add a defender. Is their a market for a middle six winger as inconsistent as he is?
Sam: Honestly, Sheary and Hagelin are in pretty similar situations here. They might be a bit more willing to deal Sheary because, while Hagelin is a vital part of the penalty kill and can play a number of roles up and down the lineup, Sheary isn’t a major part of either special team, and has shown next to no offense when he’s not playing with Sidney Crosby. He and Derick Brassard flashed a bit of chemistry late in the season and into the playoffs, but that’s not enough of a reason to keep Sheary if a good deal presents itself.
Of course, all the reasons it makes sense for the Penguins to move Sheary also make him a bit less desirable to other teams. If he only produces offensively with Sidney Crosby, well, no other team has Sidney Crosby. I think the Penguins could probably get more value out of a Hagelin deal, while a Sheary trade (his contract runs through 2020) might have to be more of a straight salary dump. The Penguins still like Sheary internally, so it’s possible he comes back, likely to play with Brassard on the third line, next season.
Danielle: 1. Do you think Rust and Sheahan will get signed or go to arbitration?
2. If TOR is shopping Nylander, is he a possible target for the pens?
3. What area's do you think the pens need to improve?
4. What do you think of the backup goalie situation for next yr?
Sam: OK, let’s hit these one at a time:
1. I’d expect both deals to get done before arbitration. The Penguins value both guys, and these negotiations should be relatively straightforward. Both are probably due deals in the low- to mid-$3 million range (Sheahan may have helped his case this postseason a bit).
2. Maybe, though that might be pie-in-the-sky stuff. If there’s a big-time talent on the market, expect Rutherford to be involved in some form or fashion, even if it’s just as a smokescreen. With Nylander, the Leafs obviously need a right-handed defenseman in return, so if the Penguins do decide it’s time to move on with Letang, maybe that’s the fit.
3. In general, I think they could probably stand to get a little bit faster. I know that’s a borderline insane statement about this team under Mike Sullivan, but it’s pretty clear at this point that other teams have caught up with them and speed is no longer a competitive advantage.
4. I think it’ll be Casey DeSmith. It’s probably even odds whether the Penguins trade Tristan Jarry this offseason or keep him in the organization for another year. I know they really like DeSmith, as evidenced by his role as Matt Murray’s backup in the playoffs. Jarry has a better pedigree and projects more as a long-term starter in the NHL, which the Penguins don’t really have a need for at this point. Rutherford loves his goalie depth, but Jarry could be a pretty good trade chip for the Penguins to dangle this offseason.

Joey B.: What are the chances Sprong starts the season with the Pens and stays there all year? Would they really trade him?
Sam: Rutherford made it pretty clear that he expects Sprong to be part of the lineup from Day 1 next year, and there’s no reason to think otherwise. If he starts the year on the team, he’ll be there all year, since starting next year he would have to pass through waivers to go down to the AHL.
As far as Sprong’s trade potential, it’s at least worth keeping an eye on this offseason. He’s clearly a talented player, but there’s a reason he never sniffed NHL minutes after January this season. Sullivan doesn’t seem to like him, so if he has more value to another team, it might make sense to at least consider a trade. Sprong could also be a good sweetener if you really want to unload some salary, especially if you want to make a really big move like …
Jon J.: Out of left field…What do the Pens have to do to get Tavares?
Sam: ... like this one! At face value, the idea of the Penguins signing John Tavares seems a bit insane (and it might be). But so was getting Derick Brassard at the deadline (this time around, there’s no George McPhee to step in and eat half the salary for … reasons).
Realistically, signing Tavares would have to start with clearing a ton of salary. Hagelin, Sheary and Hunwick would probably all have to go (and it might take dealing Sprong and/or Jarry to get those contracts off the books). Even then, that’s going to be cutting it close if you re-sign all your restricted free agents.
If that’s the case, maybe Brassard shifts to wing full-time and Sprong does lock down a spot in the lineup. It’s really stretching believability, would involve Tavares taking less money than he could get elsewhere, and would limit the Penguins’ ability to address any other areas (i.e. the blue line). But I’m not going to tell Rutherford he can’t do something.
mafifi: What is your favorite moment/memory from this season?
Sam: The clear answer here was Marc-Andre Fleury’s return to Pittsburgh in February. It was always obvious what Fleury meant to this city and fanbase (especially after last year’s playoff run) but to hear the ovations and see the reception he got in a different uniform, that was really cool.

I’ll also say that, even though it flamed out on the ice, the Ryan Reaves era was pretty fun. From his pranks on Kessel to doing a postgame interview in a Steelers helmet, he livened up what can be a pretty dull locker room at times.
To that end, I also really enjoyed writing some off-beat features on players as fans, guys with missing teeth and the Penguins’ fantasy football league.
From a hockey perspective, I think I’ll remember Game 5 against Washington. That was such a well-played game on both sides, and truly, truly entertaining stuff. That was one of the best games the Penguins played all year and, for the first time in their history, the Capitals stood up and punched back. That game was really where this series was decided and, even though it meant an earlier summer than years past, it was a really good one.
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.