You’ll have to forgive Ian Cole if his Thanksgiving dinner this year involved a little bit more mashed potatoes and a bit less corn on the cob.

Cole recently joined a somewhat exclusive club in the Penguins’ locker room — those with visibly missing teeth. Fellow defensemen Matt Hunwick and Justin Schultz are members, as is center Greg McKegg.

And while it may increase a player’s hockey bona fides to have a gap in his smile, it does take some getting used to.

“It's all right,” Cole said. “I still every once in a while look at myself in the mirror and go, ‘Ah [shoot]. I got all my teeth knocked out.’”

Advertise with us

Cole had three knocked out last month blocking a Roman Josi slap shot. Schultz lost his front-right tooth late in the 2015-16 season against Philadelphia when he took a stick to the mouth.

“It was still hanging there, but I knew it was toast,” Schultz said. “We tried to save it, but it was hanging on by a thread.”

McKegg is missing the same one — front-right — but lost it years before Schultz did. In McKegg’s last year of juniors, 2011-12, he was teammates in Erie with now-Maple Leaf Connor Brown.

“We were in the corner,” McKegg recalled. “I kind of fell, he came in there and I don’t know if he tried to lift a stick or something, but he ended up catching me in the mouth and just picked it clean off.

“You stick your tongue there and it’s gone.”

Advertise with us

The post-game procedure is generally an unpleasant one. The dentist has to remove the rest of the tooth, and even though they do their best to numb and freeze the area, it’s not a painless procedure.

“You’ve got to go to the dentist, and it’s not that much fun being at the dentist,” Schultz said. “I remember it wasn’t a great night sleeping. It was aching pretty bad. It wasn’t that fun.”

Cole, Schultz and McKegg all opted against getting a permanent replacement, mostly because of the relatively high odds this type of thing could happen again.

“They have to do a bone graft and put titanium screws in,” Cole said. “If you get hit again, it’s a bigger mess.”

Instead, they get a device known affectionately as a “flipper.” Basically, it’s a retainer with a false tooth in the place of the missing one. That, in itself, is a process as well.

Advertise with us

‘You get the flipper made up, and that’s the tough part,” McKegg said. “Does the flipper fit right? You’ve got to carry it everywhere with you. You lose them, you break them, that’s tough. Eventually I want to get a post [permanent replacement] put in there.”

The flipper fills in the gap in their smile, but doesn’t do much to function as an effective tooth. Schultz doesn’t wear his much, and McKegg often takes his out when eating. Schultz said burritos are especially tough, because the tortilla has a tendency to get stuck on the flipper.

Eating, in general, requires a bit of an adjustment without front teeth. Schultz and McKegg can get by, since they’re only missing one tooth apiece. For Cole, missing three, it’s a little tougher.

“I feel like that old cowboy that walks around with a knife and cuts his apple up,” he said. “I have cut them up. Haven’t tried to eat them off the core.”

Food poses its challenges, but just talking normally might be the biggest hurdle to dealing with missing teeth. Even a year and a half after losing his, Schultz still has a bit of lisp. He said he didn’t offer Cole much in the way of advice after his accident last month — “We’re only missing one. [He’s] missing three.” — but did provide some encouragement on that front.

Advertise with us

“I just told him the lisp does get better,” Schultz said. “It gets easier.”

So too, does realizing you might not have the classic, picture-perfect smile anymore. Cole might still be getting used to seeing that in the mirror, but McKegg and Schultz have come to terms with it.

Schultz said it was a bit awkward in social settings at first, and he got a lot of people asking him what happened. But once he said he was a hockey player, people generally understood.

“It’s not the prettiest thing, but it’s definitely that stereotypical hockey look,” McKegg echoed.

And because gap-filled smiles go hand-in-hand with hockey, all of the guys with a few missing chiclets knew this was a risk they signed up for.

Advertise with us

“My mom wasn’t too happy when this happened, but you know it’s coming,” Schultz said. “You’re not wearing a cage or anything. It’s bound to happen eventually.”

Even Cole admitted it was “only a matter of time,” and he had been fortunate to play eight years as an NHL defenseman without getting any teeth knocked out. So now he has to deal with cutting up apples and adjusting to a lisp, but that’s just an occupational hazard.

Heck, a lot of fans even view missing chompers as something to be proud of, a sign that a player is truly willing to sacrifice everything for his team.

“I don’t know if it’s a badge of honor,” Cole said. “I would’ve liked to keep my teeth, for sure.”

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG