This time is different.

The Penguins have a stellar history against Washington, and are undefeated when facing elimination under Mike Sullivan. But history won’t be taking any shifts in Game 6 on Monday. The Penguins’ 9-1 record in playoff series against the Capitals can’t make any saves, and their back-to-back Stanley Cup championships won’t score any goals.

The Penguins may have squandered their chance to take control of this series Saturday night in Game 5, and Monday night could very well end with the Capitals finally — finally! — getting the 800-pound gorilla off their back.

For as much as history may indicate a trip back to Washington for Game 7, here are five reasons the Penguins could very well see their season end Monday night:

Advertise with us

1. Braden Holtby has been the better goalie in this series

The highlights of previous series between these teams are replete with saves from the Penguins’ goaltender. Think Marc-Andre Fleury’s Game 7 breakaway save on Ovechkin in 2009, or his miraculous shaft save last spring.

The Penguins have historically had the edge in net when facing Washington, but that’s not the case this year. Holtby kept the Capitals in the game as the Penguins dominated the second period of Game 5 Saturday, and has pretty thoroughly outplayed Matt Murray in this series.

Through five games, he leads Murray in save percentage (.915 to .898) and even-strength save percentage (.928 to .911). Holtby has been steady throughout the series, while Murray — despite some flashes of brilliance — has looked pretty shaky for long stretches.

2. The Penguins don’t have any sort of reliable scoring depth

Advertise with us

The Penguins felt like Game 5 was one of their best performances of the postseason, yet look at where the goals came from: One from Jamie Oleksiak (not exactly a reliable long-term offensive option) and two from the power play.

Sullivan has been mixing and matching lines over the last few games to try and get something, anything from their bottom nine, mostly to no avail. The fourth line looked good in Game 5, but there’s been no emergence like the HBK line in 2016, or even the Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel duo of last year. Both Malkin and Kessel have been MIA from an offensive perspective in this series. Without the scoring depth to create matchup problems, these Penguins become a lot more beatable.

3. The defense still seems a bit leaky

Giving up too many odd-man rushes has been a problem for this Penguins team dating all the way back to the beginning of the season. That issue continuing to crop up in the second round of the playoffs could indicate that it’s just a fact of life for this team, rather than something that can be corrected between games or over the course of a series.

Game 5 wasn’t necessarily as bad as Games 1 or 2, but the Capitals still got plenty of chances off the rush, and Evgeny Kuznetsov’s game-tying (and game-changing) goal early in the third came off a defensive breakdown for the ages.

Advertise with us

One mistake won’t kill you over the course of an 82-game season, but in a do-or-die elimination game, it could be the difference between Game 7 and the end of the season.

4. The Capitals might have found something with their top line

After spending most of Game 4 lamenting the absence of Tom Wilson, the Capitals finally switched things up midway through Game 5 and moved Jakub Vrana up with Ovechkin and Kuznetsov. That line scored the tying and winning goals in the third period, and looked just as dangerous (if not more so) as when Wilson was in the lineup.

There may be some concerns defensively, but the speed and offensive ability that unit has now could be a nightmare for the Penguins.

5. These don’t seem like the same old Capitals

Advertise with us

At this point, the Capitals are experts at tricking their fans into thinking this year is really going to be different. But … this year does feel like it’s going to be different.

Look at how the Capitals have won games in the series. After wilting in Game 1, they bounced back with a comprehensive 4-1 win in Game 2. Their victories in Games 3 and 5 came with late goals — usually the types of heartbreak moments the Penguins inflict on them, rather than the other way around.

This Washington team doesn’t seem to be playing with the weight of history on its back, with young players and relative newcomers like Vrana and Brett Connolly stepping comfortably into spotlight roles.

This could very well just be the Capitals’ most effective fake out yet, but this time and this team really do feel different.

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.