FORWARDS

Grade: C.

The Penguins still can’t get an even-strength goal from any forward who isn’t on the No. 1 line [and they didn’t get one from anybody who played there in Game 5, either], but C Derick Brassard and RW Phil Kessel had their best showings of the playoffs, which bodes well for the Penguins as they attempt to extend their season Monday in Game 6. Kessel earned two assists, both resulting from him putting shots on goal. First-line RW Dominik Simon took an inexcusable, game-changing tripping penalty in the offensive zone with less than three minutes to go in the opening period. By the intermission, a 1-0 Penguins lead had become a 2-1 deficit.

DEFENSEMEN

Advertise with us

Grade: C-.

The No. 1 pairing of Kris Letang and Brian Dumoulin had a disastrous third period. A communication breakdown – or perhaps an ill-timed attempt to get to the bench by Letang – led to both being on the same side of the ice, setting up the Evgeny Kuznetsov breakaway that tied the game, 3-3, 52 seconds into the period. Dumoulin then had a chance to put the Penguins up from close range with about five minutes to play, but was denied by Washington goalie Braden Holtby. Seconds later, Letang played the subsequent Capitals rush poorly, making Jakub Vrana’s game-winning goal possible. Jamie Oleksiak continues to be one of the most pleasant surprises of the season for the Penguins, and scored the goal – the first of his playoff career – that staked them to a 1-0 lead.

GOALIE

Grade: C-.

Matt Murray was very good early, when Washington ran up a 7-1 edge in shots on goal. He did not get a good look at the John Carlson shot through traffic from the slot that gave the Capitals their first goal, and the Brett Connolly goal that put Washington up, 2-1, deflected off Penguins winger Patric Hornqvist before bouncing past Murray. His teammates left Murray defenseless on the Kuznetsov breakaway, when he was beaten cleanly by a backhander between the legs, and Vrana was unchecked in front of the net on the goal that put the Capitals in front to stay. Murray wasn’t responsible for the loss, but was outplayed by Holtby.

Advertise with us

SPECIAL TEAMS

Grade: B.

Winning the special-teams battle usually translates to a victory on the scoreboard, but that wasn’t the case in this game. The Penguins scored on two of their five power plays – and generally looked very good when they had a man-advantage – and allowed one goal in three shorthanded situations. Their penalty-killers have allowed a goal in four consecutive games, which means it’s imperative that the Penguins limit the number of opportunities Washington gets with the extra man in whatever remains of this series.

COACHING

Grade: C.

Advertise with us

Mike Sullivan’s infatuation with Simon’s performance – as opposed to his potential – continues to be rather baffling, and he did not drop Simon onto another line or significantly reduce his ice time after Simon’s offensive-zone penalty in the first period. It’s hard to hold the coach accountable, however, for the lapses in judgment and execution that allowed the Penguins to be pushed to the edge of elimination.

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG