The Penguins dropped a 6-3 decision against the Capitals in Game 5 of the Eastern Conference semifinals Saturday in Washington. The Capitals now lead the series, three games to two. Here are some initial impressions from the defeat.
It was over when: T.J. Oshie scored an empty-net goal to put Washington up by its winning margin with just 1:31 remaining in the third period.
Heroes: The Penguins’ power play has seemed like it was close to a breakout since Evgeni Malkin returned to it in Game 3, and the flood gates opened Saturday night. The unit scored two second-period goals that turned a 2-1 deficit into a 3-2 lead. Notably, Phil Kessel assisted on both goals after looking like a zombie for most of the series. Both are important developments for a team that’s been relying mostly on its top line for scoring for too long now.
Braden Holtby kept his team in the game. After an quick spurt in the opening minutes, the Capitals were heavily outshot and out-chanced by the Penguins, but the goalie allowed just one goal at even strength all evening. He’s simply outplaying Penguins counterpart Matt Murray right now, and he’s the biggest obstacle the Penguins will face if they hope to win this series in seven games.
Goats: Dominik Simon took a horrid offensive-zone penalty that led to John Carlson scoring Washington’s first goal on a first-period power play. Moments later, Brett Connolly got a goal off a fluky deflection, and the Penguins’ early one-goal lead was suddenly a one-goal deficit. It was a totally unnecessary shift in momentum. Simon can’t be making mistakes like that while getting big minutes on the top line with Sidney Crosby and Jake Guentzel.
Kris Letang was caught badly out of position on Evgeny Kuznetsov’s goal that tied the game early in the third period. Kuznetsov was able to skate in all alone after receiving a long pass from the neutral zone. The Penguins had done a better job of limiting the Capitals’ odd-man rushes in the last couple of games, but that mistake really cost them.
Read More
All of that being said, Murray has to be able to bail those guys out of those situations in a game like this. The Penguins dominated possession for long stretches, but when the time came for Murray to make a big save to preserve the momentum, he too often didn’t. In all honesty, his performance was reminiscent of some of Holtby’s in this series last year. The Capitals heavily outshot the Penguins in most games, but the Penguins got timely scores past a goalie who wasn’t sharp and stole the series. Now Murray’s the guy who’s getting outplayed, and Holtby is starting to look like the game changer that Marc-Andre Fleury was a year ago.
Blown leads: The Penguins have held the lead at the second intermission for the past three games and won just one of them, and Saturday’s loss was particularly painful. They outshot the Capitals in the second period, 18-5, but could not make that momentum translate. The Capitals simply came out hungrier in the third, riding Kuznetsov’s early goal to a 14-8 advantage in shots in the final frame. If the Penguins are going to survive, they need to re-discover the killer instinct that so often helped them close out games like this one in Stanley Cup runs the past two summers.
Derick Brassard contributes: The Penguins’ big trade deadline acquisition had been very quiet in this series, but he set up the Penguins’ first goal by digging the puck out from behind the Washington net and feeding it to Jamie Oleksiak for a fat one-timer. It was a needed confidence boost for a guy who’s been under a lot of scrutiny — both inside and outside the Penguins’ room.
Next: The series shifts back to PPG Paints Arena for Game 6 Monday night. Puck drop is 7 p.m.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.