Jason Mackey: Alright, folks. We're off. Thanks for participating.
Jeff: So, since we've been mispronouncing Conor Sheary's name all this time, can we PLEASE now use Steve Perry's "Oh Sherrie" for his goal celebrations? "Oh Sherrie, our love, holds on, holds on" by 18,000 people would be epic right?!
Jason Mackey: Unfortunately the Penguins don't do goal celebrations individually. Again, unfortunately. That would be a lot of fun.
Joe: Do you think the Pens will still be actively seeking another 3C after the Duchene trade? Sheahan, who doesn't shoot and has one point, can't be the answer there right? Also, do you think the team is also looking for a LW for Geno in the power forward mode? Any chance they are looking at Evander Kane from Buffalo?
Jason Mackey: I don't think the Duchene trade had much to do with their plans. You saw the return. No way the Penguins could or would match that. As for Sheahan and the 3C spot, they need offense there. I think it's too early to make any sort of determination with Sheahan. However, if he is unable to score, then, yes, I do think GMJR will look to upgrade that position. Remember, he has often struck a month or more before the deadline, in order to get a little bit of a lower price.
Jason Mackey: And no way on Evander Kane.
Read More
Joe: Can the Pens win another Cup loading up the top two lines and getting little to nothing offensively from the bottom six?
Jason Mackey: No, I don't think they can. I don't think any team can. To win the Cup, you have to get balanced scoring. That goes for the Penguins or the Blackhawks or the Capitals or the Lightning. If the Penguins are going to win another Cup, their bottom two lines have to be more productive. They'd be the first to tell you that, too.
caopall: The Pens have another set of back-to-backs this Friday and Saturday against Washington and Nashville. The Caps haven’t been playing all that well and the Preds will be coming off of three day’s rest when they meet the Pens. Who do you think will start in goal this weekend for Pittsburgh?
Jason Mackey: I see no reason to go away from Murray-Jarry. Stinks for Jarry to again get the second leg, but that's a backup goaltender's job. In his third start, odd as it may sound given what transpired in the playoffs, I think I'd rather play Jarry against the Predators than the Capitals. I view the Capitals as the more dangerous team from a rookie goaltender's perspective. That said, Murray has been incredible against the Preds. Sullivan could play matchups.
HB: Is it going to be Murray or Jarry Friday and I’m guessing the other one Saturday?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, they'll split. I would think Murray-Jarry, but we won't know for sure until Friday morning. Sullivan only announces goalies the day of.
caopall: Any updates on Rowney? I think the Pens miss him on that 4th line, not so much as a scoring threat, but as someone that really helped that unit to maintain possession time in the offensive zone. Hey, if they aren’t going to score, then the 4th line should at least wreak havoc on the other team’s ability to match lines by logging extended shifts.
Jason Mackey: He's skating. That's all we know. He has a fractured hand, and he's expected back no earlier than Nov. 24. So, it's early. Probably too early to tell, honestly. ... And the fourth line needs to score more, with or without Rowney. If they can do what they did at Florida -- the best game the fourth line has played this season -- the goals will come.
HB: Why they take archibald out of the lineup we are undefeated with him in?
Jason Mackey: Ha. 1-0 undefeated? If you put Archibald in, out of curiosity, who comes out?
HB: When Carter Rowney makes his return does mckegg have a send down option or do we have room to just scratch him?
Jason Mackey: Assuming they would not keep Corrado up, I believe they would have the cap space to keep two extra forwards (Archibald and McKegg in this case) and one additional D (Ruhwedel).
Joe: What's going on with Letang and Crosby? They both have been bad early on in different ways. Letang issue seems mental--lack of confidence, poor decision making. Sid seems like he hasn't started caring yet. Have you discussed their problems with Sullivan and what does he see as the problem, if any, and the solution? Do you think he agrees with JR that Letang's minutes should be limited ?
Jason Mackey: Trust me, lack of caring is not where it starts with Crosby. I've met few people who care MORE about their job, hockey or otherwise. If anything, he cares too much and could stand to chill out a little bit. Letang, too. I think Crosby is putting too much pressure on himself while at the same time becoming too passive. The line with Hornqvist isn't great for his game, in my opinion. I'd like to see 59-87-43 and for Crosby to shoot a lot more. With Letang, tamp down his minutes, minimize mistakes, give him some favorable matchup and let him build his game. More than other players, that means a lot to him. He needs to see some positive results and then later worry about taking chances.
HB: As a hockey writer what are your thoughts on the Duchene turris picks and prospects trade?
Jason Mackey: Glad you didn't ask me as a dentist or an accountant, HB. It's fine. It is what it is. I don't know if I have a strong opinion any which way. I think COL grossly underestimated the human aspect of the deal -- I.e. irritating Duchene -- but they're allowed; it's their team, their trade piece. I still don't think Colorado is very good or building toward anything significant.
Joe: When Hunwick returns who sits do you think? Ruhwedel has played well
Jason Mackey: I'd sit Ruhwedel. He's your No. 7. He's played well for a No. 7, but he's your No. 7.
HB: I think the Penguins lack of shoot first mentality on the power play is perfectly summed up by no one trying to put the puck on net with time winding down in the 1st I believe?
Jason Mackey: I've actually been OK with the frequency with which they shoot on the PP. I think that, more than anything, was a lack of clock awareness. Remember, hockey isn't like basketball, where they're used to paying attention to a shot clock.
HB: Is reaves someone the Penguins will try to resign this offseason or let him walk?
Jason Mackey: I think it's too early to tell. I think they would have interest, but I think they want to see how this works over 82-plus and then playoffs.
Danielle : how concerned are you about Sid lack of offense and do you think putting Phil on Sids line could help
Jason Mackey: Not at all, Danielle. He'll be fine. Crosby puts in an insane amount of work every day. He's the best player in the league. Even that guy goes through slumps. If it was for a lack of effort, or he was dragging down his team, maybe I'd worry. But Crosby is 180 degrees the opposite.
Danielle : Also, what did you think of Malkin's line with 59-71-81
Jason Mackey: I love it. Problem is, I like Guentzel with Crosby better. Seems like they're a playmaking LW short. Sheary does some good things but doesn't provide enough defense/blue collar/responsibility with Geno and Phil. Playing off of Geno and Phil isn't a strength for Rust. They have a couple parts with skills. Guentzel fits, but I think what it takes away from Crosby's line is greater than what it adds to Malkin's.
Zack: I'm sure you're getting a lot of "what's wrong with Sid" questions right now, but I figured I would offer my opinion on the matter and see what you think. I don't necessarily think there's anything wrong with him, I think it's more his mindset. For all the years I've watched Sid, I think he's at his very best when he is looking to go to the net, thinking shot first. In other words, I think he's best when he's looking to create for himself. If you look at the past two years, I think he scored more goals than usual because he was confident and was a little more "selfish" with the puck. Lately I see him pulling up at the blue line, thinking pass first. Just my thoughts. What do you think Jason?
Jason Mackey: I think you should get your own chat, Zack. ... Seriously, though, I agree with you. I think Crosby needs to get a little more selfish. I also think he will. We've seen him shoot himself out of slumps before. ... As I've been saying, too, I think going back to Sid and the Kids -- although it doesn't look like Sully agrees with me -- would give Crosby a little more comfort.
Sadie: There was an article recently about the Pens, including Sid, being mostly dairy-free and gluten-free, but Zatkoff was talking about Sid's sweet tooth as recently as the 2016 playoffs. Does Sid just eat a lot of sad gluten-free cookies? What is the truth??
Jason Mackey: I've actually talked to Sid before about his sweet tooth. It's real. And it doesn't always have to be gluten-free. Chocolate chip cookies -- I need to get him to try Nancy B's, come to think of it -- and Timbits are two of his favorites.
Tom Wilson: Will Reavo fight me tomorrow night?
Jason Mackey: Oui.
OHIO412FAN: Jason, with the Penguins playing up and down hockey as late, it seems their defense is lacking, Letang is underperforming, and both sides of the puck need tweaking. What are the biggest cons right now with this team? I truly believe this team is a Stanley Cup winner, only if they have the cards fall their way.
Jason Mackey: If you're going to criticize the Penguins or worry about them, I would start with their lack of depth scoring. Second might be their depth on defense; they're two injuries away from having Frank Corrado in their top six. Don't love that. Third could be the backup goaltender situation, although I'm pretty high on Tristan Jarry. Like him a lot. Letang and Crosby aren't concerns at all for me. It's November.
OHIO412FAN: Injury report?
Jason Mackey: I'm feeling OK. Back was a little sore yesterday but no serious issues. Might've slept weird, too. Neck's a little funky.
OHIO412FAN: Current lineup as of now for Washington tomorrow? What are the biggest areas of need to improve on for this team?
Jason Mackey: Need to get on the Twitter. Sheary-Crosby-Hornqvist // Guentzel-Malkin-Kessel // Hagelin-Sheahan-Rust // Kuhnhackl-McKegg-Reaves ... Maatta-Letang // Dumoulin-Ruhwedel // Cole-Schultz. ... Depth scoring, for one. Better starts. Second night of back-to-backs. Oh, scoring more five-on-five might be a kinda big one.
OHIO412FAN: What’s the status quo on the Civic Arena Site? I heard they are building an outdoor concert facility, etc.
Jason Mackey: I'm not totally sure. That's Mark Belko's domain. I would encourage you to check out his coverage on our website or in print. He's the best.
OHIO412FAN: Riley Sheahan, could the Penguins do more to get him more acclimated to getting the chances and minutes to succeed? Do you think they that trade was a hit or miss?
Jason Mackey: I think it's neither at this point. Need a larger sample size. Could be something there. I'm worried there's not. He tends to disappear and isn't terribly assertive when he has the puck. That could change, though. They've played with him good people, in advantageous situations. Not sure there's more they could do from that standpoint.
Steven: When does Archibald get back into a game? He looked good in the one he did get into, and now has been relegated to perma-scratch so Reaves can average 7:17 a game. Is there a plan to get him more time or just waiting for injuries to hit?
Jason Mackey: I think probably waiting for injuries to hit ... or getting him a game sporadically just to keep him involved. There's nobody on the cusp of losing their spot.
Titan for life: Better head coach, Sean Kelly or Carmen Nocera's bag of clean balls?
Jason Mackey: Oh, boy. That's a tough one. See, Sean Kelly always made sure our shoes were clean, we dragged a razor across our face and we could do a backwards duck walk. Carm was the greatest baseball player Geneva had ever seen, coached third base while talking on a cell phone and actually knew what the hell he was doing. So, I'd go Carm.
Dave: While I give JR credit for trying to find hidden treasure in the clearance aisle, between the Niemi and now the Sheahan experiment, when does he finally give up something of value to get a legitimate 3rd line center?
Jason Mackey: I would say when he needs to. Niemi didn't work. And give Jim credit, they cut bait fast. Got lucky with Florida picking Niemi up. ... If they don't get anything from the 3C spot before the deadline, I think Jim will get someone. Will it be Duchene-esque? I don't think that. But they know full well one of the biggest reasons why they've won the past two years is getting scoring up and down the lineup. Right now -- whether you agree or not -- they feel like they can be getting more and they're trying to make that happen.
MarP: Do you see the Pens going out and maybe trading for a top 6 forward at some point in the season/signing a big UFA (Neal coming back). At the same time, do you see them trying to move Hagelin?
Jason Mackey: Why would Vegas trade James Neal? No, I don't think they need to address the top-six. They might need to address the 3C center spot again, but their top six is perfectly fine. ... Not picking on you MarP, but I get the Hagelin question a lot and don't understand it. The guy has seven goals in his past 77 games and makes $4 million a year. What NHL team would willingly give something up to take that on? It's not like they'd be shopping Guentzel or Murray here.
Titan for life: Would Sean Kelly have been able to turn around the Pens the same way Sullivan did?
Jason Mackey: Easily. Only problem would be whenever he appointed Ian to take care of the ice at PPG Paints Arena.
Chuck in D.C. (HATE CAPS): Just my 2 cents. I still believe it is way too early to panic. It's a marathon...not a sprint. Health and adjusting to missed former teammates is most important.
Jason Mackey: Chuck, if you're going to be rational, we have no place for you here.
John: What is your opinion of Kuhnhackl? I hate having players in the lineup for the PK who can't score, it reminds me of having Glass and Adams in the lineup.
Jason Mackey: I know where you're going with that John, but I would argue that Kuhnhackl gives you more than Glass/Adams. Kuhnhackl's scoring was fine with Matt Cullen and a good version of Eric Fehr. No, he's not Phil Kessel, but if they played him with better people -- he's on a line with Greg McKegg and Ryan Reaves for crying out loud -- I think you would see him score more.
Kevin: Hi Jason! Alot is being made of the lack of bottom 6 scoring. With guys like sprong, ZAR, Di Pauli, & Johnson down the AHL, could the fix be as simple as bringing them up in Dec allowing guys like haglin to slide down to better roles. That's kinda what happened with the 1st wave in 2015. We still made need a trade or 2, but maybe minor ones like the Schultz/Haglin trades at the time. Your thoughts on this group of youngsters?...Thanks for the chat
Jason Mackey: I think Sprong is a card they could and should play at some point, but he doesn't address the 3C need. Neither do Di Pauli or ZAR. I worry whether Johnson is big enough for the NHL; he probably needs more time. It is intriguing to me -- and I don't know if I totally agree with this yet -- whether they would move Guentzel to center and try something like this: Sheary-Crosby-Sprong ... Rust-Malkin-Kessel ... Hagelin-Guentzel-Hornqvist ... Kuhnhackl-Sheahan-Reaves. Probably not, but I'm just trying to think of ways to create a third line that can actually score without making a trade.
RandomHockeyGuy: Would the Penguins have any interest bringing Bonino back, if NSH put him on the block or he requested a trade? Seems he left for a shot at being a 2nd line center, which may be off the table with the Turris acquisition. NSH says they may want to move Bonino to wing, but that has never been his cup of tea.
Jason Mackey: Definitely different circumstances for Bonino with the Turris thing. And I do think there's mutual attraction. However, the money is hard. What, $4 million per year over the next four? That's a lot with Rust, Guentzel and, in two years, Murray, needing paid.
dave: Why do you think they moved Guentzel off of Sid's line?
Jason Mackey: I think Sully likes Sheary, Sid and Hornqvist. I just don't know if Sid likes Sheary, Sid and Hornqvist. Guentzel is going to be in your top six, and this team is best with Malkin and Kessel together, IMO. At least right now. I also think maybe to try and give Guentzel some different looks and to get him going offensively. There's also the idea that they haven't scoring much and Sullivan has been trying anything and everything to get a spark.
Steven: If Hunwick comes back and is steady, does Cole become trade bait for a 3C? His contract is up at the end of the year, and while he provides a lot for the PK, he's normally at the bottom of ES TOI for the D.
Jason Mackey: No way. I think you're robbing Peter to pay Paul at that point; what happens to your depth on defense? You're decreasing it. Cole is probably their best PK defenseman. Yes, he's going to walk after the season. Some team will overpay. But I wouldn
Jason Mackey: 't trade him.
Constantino: Is it a given that Sprong slots into Crosby's RW when he is called up? Either way, what does the (if healthy) top-12 look like upon his arrival?
Jason Mackey: No, I wouldn't say it's a given. He might actually fit better with Malkin. If you had to compare Sprong with one NHL Penguin, I'd probably go Kessel. Kessel and Crosby, because of their divergent styles, have never had a ton of chemistry. So, maybe it's not a natural fit. But if Geno has Phil on his right side, the only top-six opening is with Sid. If you kept Guentzel on the wing, you could go Sheary-Crosby-Sprong // Guentzel-Malkin-Kessel // Hagelin-Sheahan-Hornqvist // Rust-Rowney/McKegg-Reaves/Kuhnhackl.
Guest: I know in a previous chat you gave some great tidbits about the human-side of all the pens players (Sid and Olli hanging out together, etc.). Any more of those things you can share?
Jason Mackey: I can, but I don't know what specifically you're looking for. Feel free to ask again and I'll say what I can.
MG: If the Wild continue to not play well through Jan/Feb, do you think there's a chance for the return of Cullen as a rental for another Cup run?
Jason Mackey: I do, yes. But I really don't see Minnesota falling out of the race. If they do, though, I think it makes a ton of sense for all involved for that to happen, and I would fully expect GMJR to place a call if Minny is way out of it.
Rek : When looking at all the upcoming UFA/RFA for the Penguins, who do you think comes first in order of priority for GMJR?
Jason Mackey: I think they will try to sign Hornqvist (UFA). I think it's going to be tough, though, because he has a great resume to shop to other teams and might've priced himself out of Pittsburgh. RFA-wise, I think they need to pay Rust the way they did Dumoulin and Sheary this past offseason, and I think they will absolutely do that.
Kevin: Why do the pens never try & sign their young players to longer term team friendly deals? It's pretty well know bridge deals are bad foe the team in the long term. Instead of 3yrs $2.4m for dumo they could've done maybe 5 or 6 at a better rate. Now they're locked in on bigger deals for sheary and dumo...seems they maybe missing an opportunity to stretch cap space a bit
Jason Mackey: Dumoulin did sign a six-year deal. As for Sheary, I think the bridge deal was because of his slump in the playoffs and the fact that he was undrafted. Basically both sides were OK with the bridge deal, believing he could earn more with solid productive over the next three seasons.
Guest: I'm not specifically looking for anything. I just love details that make the players feel less like untouchables and more like real people. Is cheesecake really crosby's favorite dessert, what ice cream flavors do they like, favorite fast food joints for the team. Those are just some things that came to mind but obviously does not need to be food related. Just anything you can share. Thanks, Jason.
Jason Mackey: Ha. Many of the players do not eat fast food. Apparently Brian Dumoulin is a popular dining partner on the road. Very into food. Very into trying new things and finding hot spots.
JP: Is sid a jokester around the boys??
Jason Mackey: Some. But not really. He's much more low key.
Dick Tarnstrom: Any potential UFA's you think the Pens might be interested in if they end up needing to add scoring depth to the lineup?
Jason Mackey: I think it's too early at this point, Dick. I don't look at this team as one that's going to make a big splash with anything next summer, honestly. Look for them to sign their current guys.
Reed: Hey Jason, do you believe we have the “build” this year to compete with Tampa Bay? What is your take on that situation and do you see them coming out on top in the Atlantic?
Jason Mackey: I do see Tampa as the best out of the Atlantic, and I think the Penguins -- ignore their current state -- are right there with them. They maybe need some more depth scoring, but I think the Pens are still among the top two or three teams in the East.
Guest: have there been any pranks that happened behind the scenes we haven't been privy to but you may have seen?
Jason Mackey: Nah. If we see a prank, trust me, we report it. Not a ton I can share that you haven't already see prank-wise.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks, that does it. Thanks so much for participating. Let's do this again next week!





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.