guest: Was there any thought to Bill Guerin being an assistant coach?

Jason Mackey: None whatsoever. He's potentially Jim Rutherford successor. He's not a coach.

Matt Duchene: How come you won't sign me?

Jason Mackey: You make too much money, Matt. Sorry.

Advertise with us

Chris Kunitz: I changed my mind, I want to come back and play with the Pens. We can totally three-peat!!

Jason Mackey: Too late, Chris.

keepinita hundred: How long before Sully kicks Kessel to the curb?

Jason Mackey: I wouldn't phrase it like that, but if you're asking when the Penguins might explore trading Kessel, my answer would be not before after next season. Think about it: Kessel scored 23 goals last season. Believe that's the second-lowest single-season mark of his career. So, you're trading an asset when its value is low. Plus, Daniel Sprong and Zach Aston-Reese probably need at least a half-season in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton. The scenario that makes the most sense is for the Penguins to let those guys develop -- they could always have their hand forced by Sprong or Aston-Reese -- then have Kessel produce a gaudy goal total, and you see what the market is for him next summer.

Aaron: As the roster stands, who do you see on the #1 PP?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think Letang deserves the right to be out there to start. I'd go Letang, Crosby, Malkin, Kessel and Hornqvist. However, if the unit struggles, I would not be shy about replacing Letang with Schultz and Hornqvist with Guentzel.

HB: How much do you think sheary will get and i saw numbers where sheary would make more than dumoulin which is ridiculous because we need dumoulin but we dont need sheary.

Jason Mackey: How much a team needs a player does not factor into his arbitration number. Production and contributions to the team does. ... I don't think Dumoulin will make more than Sheary. I think Dumoulin will get around $3.5 million, Sheary $2.5, and I don't have any problem with either of those numbers.

Jason Mackey : Did the chat start yet?

Jason Mackey: It did. You're late.

Advertise with us

Porter: Do you think trading Sheary is on the table once his arb case is settled? Thanks J-Bone.

Jason Mackey: Yes, to make a deal, I think the Penguins would listen. I don't think they're shopping Sheary, mind you, but I would not call him untouchable the way I would someone like Guentzel.

Ray Fittipaldo: Hi Jason!

Jason Mackey: Hi Ray. How's the South Side? Was lunch good?

Brandon: Jason, any idea on who will propel into Recchi's former spot as the player development coach?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Good question. Talked to Rutherford about this yesterday. He said interviews will kick into full gear next week. Hard to handicap because GMJR needs to know his candidate pool. I don't think it will be Matt Cullen, I'll say that. I think Pascal Dupuis would be a possibility, if he's interested; I don't know that he is. Outside of those guys, I think they may look to fill it externally.

Mike in Kennedy Twp.: Been wanting to know answer to 2 questions about Game 6 winning goal. Did Shultz deliberately shoot wide and why did they rule no goalie interference?

Jason Mackey: I do think Schultz meant to do what he did. As for goalie interference, I've watched, and I don't see that. What are you referring to specifically that makes you say that?

Gary Rissling: What are Pouliets flaws? Decision making? Lack of awareness? Basic hockey IQ?

Jason Mackey: Yes, yes and yes. They are not physical, by any stretch. In Derrick's defense, I'll say this: Mike Sullivan's system is not easy. Defensemen are asked to do a lot. And quickly. That said, it's the decision-making and thinking the game that has lagged behind with Pouliot.

Advertise with us

HB: do you think the longer we wait for rutherford to make a trade for a 3rd line center the more potential that its a block buster move

Jason Mackey: No. I don't think the wait will translate to the size of the move. The Penguins have a certain amount they can spend, and that's that. I think GMJR's waiting for a few things to happen away from his own organization -- like teams that are over the cap and whether they're going to keep or trade guys -- and that will likely impact the trade more than anything.

dave: Why bother giving Pouliot another contract? Are they trying to pump up his trade value?

Jason Mackey: Could be. But I also think the organization has convinced itself, right or wrong, that there's a hockey player in there somewhere. You certainly can't question Pouliot's physical ability. He has all the tools. If they can get through to him mentally, they could have something special.

Lukas: Do you see the pens targeting anymore college UFAs? Specifically Will Butcher in August?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I wouldn't say no, at this point. Especially after their last undrafted UFA signing. The Penguins track all of them. They do it well. It's of interest to them. They'll be monitoring, I'm sure.

Guest: What do you think of recent signing Adam Johnson, and do you think he has any real NHL potential?

Jason Mackey: I like it. It addresses a need. Not going to offer an opinion on NHL potential, however, as I've never seen him play in person, other than development camp. Wouldn't be fair.

HB: is Daniel Sprong eligible for rookie of the year since he played a couple games his first year.

Jason Mackey: Yes.

Advertise with us

Krobsr: Jason, I just heard Rutherford say he is looking for a center in the 2 million dollar range do u think he is bluffing or maybe he will sign multiple players

Jason Mackey: Heard that. I think it's strategic. Unless he legitimately expects Dumoulin and Sheary to get $6 apiece in arbitration or something. They can afford more than $2 million for that position, and I believe they'll spend more there.

Ray Fittipaldo: Lunch was super...just a little heartburn. It looks like next year's team is going to be weaker with some of the departures. How do you see the team playing out next year record-wise. Three-peat seems a bit of a tall order.

Jason Mackey: I don't think so. Honestly, I don't see anyone else in the Eastern Conference that's intimidating, other than maybe Tampa. And even then, I have some questions. I think they'll be in the mix to win the Metro, probably the favorites and snag one of the top seeds. But honestly, the regular season is meaningless around here. You know that.

Mark: Do you think that someone like Sheary would help bring back a center? And do you think GMJR is waiting to go bargain wing shopping, perhaps for someone like Vanek?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I don't see them having any use for someone like Vanek. ... Sheary would have to be packaged with someone. I don't think he could net what they're looking for by himself.

dave: When free agency started, GMJR said he was close to making a deal for a 3rd line center. Who do you think he was talking about?

Jason Mackey: I'm not sure. I believe he said he was engaged with talks. I don't ever remember saying he was close to making a deal. I remember the title of an article saying he was close to making a deal.

Krobsr: I do believe we have a lot of cap room to sign an elite player any thoughts

Jason Mackey: Sure. I think they can allocate around $4 million to their 3C position. That's plenty of room to get an elite player.

Advertise with us

Eric : What does Derrick Pouliot need to do to translate his AHL success to the NHL?

Jason Mackey: Thinking. ... Well. Pouliot has all the physical gifts in the world. He needs to make smarter, safer decisions in his own end and better defensively, something that starts with your brain.

Mike in Kennedy Twp.: Hornquist made a lot of contact with Rinne's pad and stick as he went around Rinne's left to get to the puck coming off the boards. I never heard an explanation on the no interference ruling.

Jason Mackey: Went back and watched it again. I still don't see anything that prevented Rinne from making the save.

Justin: Speaking of 51, you think he is ready to step up and play NHL minutes? Has to be basically he last chance.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: This might sound weird, but I actually think he is. I think he could have a breakout year this year. I really do.

Dale: In your opinion, does Pouliot have any real trade value left? Do teams see him as a top prospect who just doesn't fit the Pens' system, or is his value low?

Jason Mackey: I think his value is low. There may be zero interest, honestly. What he's put on tape isn't good. But as I just said, I think he might be alright ... here. I don't like the idea of Pouliot, at this stage in his career, learning another system.

Pekka Rinne: It's all MY fault!

Jason Mackey: Yes, yes it is.

Advertise with us

Andrew: What's with Mark Madden's pronunciation of Mackey (Ma-Kai) ? Anyways, that was good radio

Jason Mackey: Ha. Thanks Andrew. I don't know. I think it has something to do with English soccer, although I don't know exactly what. I think next time I guess on his show I'm going to have him explain this.

John: Which is more difficult to overcome: the turnover in players or the turnover in the coaching staff and front office?

Jason Mackey: I think front office, but not Tocchet. I think losing Botterill has and will continue to be a big blow. People underestimated everything the guy did, down to little, logistical things. He really was good at his job, and I think the Penguins are realizing this more and more now that he's gone.

David: With the way the roster sits right now, what are the chances the Pens can 3-peat?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I like them, honestly. I think they have as good of a chance as anyone.

Dave: The one thing I've heard this offseason that I don't quite grasp is that the Pens lost too much in the leadership department. Even their youngest players have gone through the rigors of the playoffs, and all anyone says about Sid is he's one of the best leaders in the sport. So why is leadership loss an issue? Don't they have enough of it?

Jason Mackey: I think they lost some "character" guys in Kunitz, Cullen (for now, anyway), Hainsey, Daley and Bonino. Well-liked guys. Key voices. Nothing against Jake Guentzel, but he has zero locker room presence. That's not a serious knock, but address those strong voices in some way -- Matt Hunwick fits here -- will be important.

Lukas: Are the Pens planning to have 8 D on their roster all year? I'd imagine one of them would get claimed if having to pass through waivers.

Jason Mackey: It's a good question. Although with this group, you never know with injuries.

Advertise with us

HB: who do you see as our 6 defensemen next year?

Jason Mackey: To start, I'd go Dumoulin-Letang ... Maatta-Hunwick ... Cole-Schultz ... Ruhwedel and Pouliot as extras.

Joe: So you're saying Pouliot has a million dollar body and a ten cent brain?

Jason Mackey: Something like that, yeah.

Avi: Hopefully, you understood the Rinne comment was a dig at Predators fan incessant chant

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I did.

Jordan Staal: So am I really coming back or what

Jason Mackey: No dude. Sorry. You're not on the market, and I talked to someone in your camp ... nobody has even broached the subject.

Scotty Bowman: What do I see in Ollie that others do not?

Jason Mackey: I think there's a lot of good to Maatta's game. I also think that, for whatever reason, when he struggles, he REALLY struggles. It's weird. It's like he gets his money's worth whenever he struggles.

D-man: What's your gut tell you about the chances Cullen returns for a shot at the 3-peat?

Jason Mackey: I don't think he's coming back. Sorry. I think if he plays at all, it's going to be in Minnesota.

Willis: So there's a "rumor" on Twitter that the Pens would be interested in a Kessel for Pavelski deal. Please shoot this down.

Jason Mackey: Per usual with this sort of stuff, need to see the original report first. If you can include that, I'd be happy to address.

D-man: What would you say are Sully's biggest challenges going into another title defense?

Jason Mackey: The biggest thing, honestly, is health. It's a belligerent game, to borrow one of Sullivan's favorite phrases. Things happen. Even with Letang this past season, the Penguins have actually been fairly fortunate when it comes to health, especially in the postseason. ... Also Matt Murray staying healthy and Antti Niemi being a serviceable No. 2. ... Defensive depth. ... A fourth line that can contribute. ... None are huge, but you asked for potential problems.

Lukas: Do you think Rowney get first shot at 4th line C if Cullen retires or do you think it'll be an UFA or possibly a guy like Adam Johnson?

Jason Mackey: If Cullen retires, I wouldn't be surprised if they sign a veteran for cheap so Rowney doesn't have to be counted upon to play center. Honestly, I thought he was a lot better on the wing. I wouldn't play him at center unless I had to.

CarlyDishong: I like Archibald on the 4th line. Chances he's there for the start of the regular season?

Jason Mackey: I think fairly good. With Kunitz gone, I think that increased his chances. I also think to acquire a 3C and fit everything under the cap, someone like Wilson or Kuhnhackl could easily be included to sweeten the pot, if necessary.

Jaromir Jagr: Will the Penguins call me do you think

Jason Mackey: I wish, Jags. But no. You in no way fit what the Penguins are trying to do, and it's a [darn] shame.

HB: why would cullen want to go to a trainwreck that is the western conference capitals hes stated multiple times he loves Pittsburgh and he said its great for his kids to be around the pens franchise.

Jason Mackey: Because he's from Minnesota, his wife is from Minnesota, and she has admitted she's homesick. They also want to get their boys in public school, entrenched in that life. That's one of the reasons Matt has thought about retiring. To do that and play one more year with a good team ... I think that may be too much to resist. Cullen also said what he said before Minnesota showed interest.

John: How many more years of their prime do you think Crosby and Geno have?

Jason Mackey: More than I'm comfortable handicapping at this point.

MFA: What's your take on Corrado? Do you think there's potential there, maybe another Schultz on a smaller scale?

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I definitely saw some potential. I didn't see an NHL-ready player, however. I think he'll really benefit from working with Gonchar. How far he comes will dictate whether he sees NHL time this year.

Jaromir Jagr: Cmon man, I'm still fast

Jason Mackey: If you came back here, it might be the single greatest story in the history of Pittsburgh sports.

Lukas: Do you have any guys you'd like to see then Pens target in FA or through trade?

Jason Mackey: I think Tyler Bozak is very appealing. I'd also like to see them bring in Jaromir Jagr, although I'll admit that makes zero sense and is good only for me.

Eric : The team seems to have an abundance of NHL level wings ie. Wilson, Kuhnackl, Archibald, Hagelin, and even Sprong eventually. Do you think the team will try to move any of these guys for potentially a third line center?

Jason Mackey: I think they could be packaged. I don't think they could net a third-line center by themselves. I worry about the tradeability of Hagelin given his contract, but it would give them financial flexibility -- sorry, I know we all hate that term. I also wonder who would want Hagelin for his production and that number.

JamesinNYC: I was listening to the NHL station on Sirius...they were downplaying college FA but the Pens have done well. Luck or just old school thinking on their part?

Jason Mackey: Jimmy Vesey hasn't stunk. Wait until Aston-Reese, Ethan Prow and Thomas Di Pauli are integral parts of the Penguins. There are obviously more. I wouldn't say you should build your team 1-23 like that, but I think it's important to be active on the market; you can find value, and the Penguins have.

Lukas: I like Bozak but I'd rather the Pens step-up and go after a guy like Kadri. I know he'd take more to acquire but after watching him play against Ovi in the playoffs, I'd love to have him as our 3C.

Jason Mackey: Absolutely. I'd take Kadri in a heartbeat. I don't know why Toronto would let him go.

guest: I am really bummed they did not resign Kunitz.... for the deal he got you would think they would have brought him back for his leadership and experience alone

Jason Mackey: I was similarly surprised. If he would have gotten 2-3 years or like $4 million from some desperate team, I would have understood the Penguins letting him walk. Not for one year and $2 million. I thought that was reasonable. Clearly they don't think he has much good hockey left.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it. Will hopefully be talking to Pouliot soon, then have to head into the office for a staff meeting, following by a P-G sports department happy hour. Look out. Thanks for participating. Always enjoy these. I'm on vacation next week, but let's do this again the week after.