Penguins coach Mike Sullivan believes goaltender might be the most important position in all of sports.

He also doesn’t think his team has let the Nashville Predators find life in the Stanley Cup final because of subpar performances between the pipes.

“We haven’t lost games because of our goaltending,” Sullivan said on a Tuesday afternoon conference call, when he was asked whether he was thinking about benching Matt Murray in favor of Marc-Andre Fleury for Thursday’s Game 5 at PPG Paints Arena, the series tied at two wins apiece.

There are a couple things at play here, and none of them lead to the definitive answer everyone is searching for.

Advertise with us

Simply put, Sullivan isn’t going to name his goaltender until he no longer has to; whoever leaves Thursday’s morning skate first will more than likely start, although in Sullivan’s world of Bill Belichick-like lineup deception, even that’s not a guarantee.

Only when Sullivan confirms it will we know for sure, and he’s yet to do that before his post-skate availability.

Which leaves more than enough time to debate the merits of starting Murray versus Fleury, thankful aren’t we all.

“I think the goaltending position can be such an important position by nature of how the game’s played,” Sullivan said. “Certainly I thought [Monday] night, it was a case where we felt as though Matt had a solid game, but Pekka Rinne had a tremendous game. I think maybe early in the series, you could probably point in the other direction.

“These guys do have an impact on their teams’ ability to have success. I think that’s the nature of playoff hockey. That’s the nature of hockey in general. It might be the most important position in all of sports because that position can single-handedly change the outcome of a game, as we’ve seen on a number of different occasions throughout the course of this playoffs with all different series.”

Advertise with us

The rationale for starting Murray is simple: He’s proven to be Sullivan’s guy. He won Sullivan’s Penguins a Stanley Cup, and why freak out over a goal that barely crossed the line, another on a so-so rebound, and a breakaway that Murray could probably have played better?

What sort of message does that send?

On the other hand, starting Fleury would probably placate a large majority of fans. It would give Fleury a chance to re-ignite the magnificent run he had at the start of the playoffs, and it would give Fleury’s teammates — who have to feel better for not playing better in front of him in Ottawa — one final chance to make things right for their friend.

Murray also allowed eight goals in two games. That’s not good, however you want to spin it.

Whichever direction Sullivan ultimately goes, this much is clear: There will be plenty of pressure on the goaltender Sullivan does pick to perform.

Advertise with us

“We believe in the guys that we have,” Sullivan said. “We think one of the strengths of our team is in our goaltending position. So we’ve just got to try to do our best to focus on the things that we can control, and that’s that one game in front of us.”

Updates on Letang, Bonino

Among the other topics Sullivan addressed was the possibility that Kris Letang could return for the Stanley Cup final.

A TSN report by Darren Dreger surfaced after Game 4, and it said there was a “slight chance” Letang could return.

“There is zero chance that Kris Letang will come back for this series,” Sullivan said.

Advertise with us

Sullivan said that Nick Bonino was held out of the lineup Monday after taking part of warmup because, “He didn’t feel strong enough that he could help our team win.”

About those chances

Naturalstattrick.com credited the Penguins with 23 scoring chances Monday during five-on-five play in Game 4.

To put that in perspective, they averaged 13.7 during the first three games of the series.

“Our coaching staff thought the game last night might’ve been our best overall game in the series to this point,” Sullivan said. “We were disappointed that we ended up on the wrong side of the score, but there was a lot to like about that game.”

Advertise with us

In terms of high-danger scoring chances, the Penguins had 13 of those. That equals the number they had in Games 1-3 combined.

No Phil with Sid

We’ve seen Sullivan try Sidney Crosby with all sorts of wingers. Jake Guentzel, Conor Sheary, Bryan Rust, Chris Kunitz, Carl Hagelin and Patric Hornqvist chief among them.

The only top-six or top-nine winger Crosby has not started a game with this season is Phil Kessel.

As Sullivan broke up Kessel and Evgeni Malkin on Monday and started the game by deploying Kessel with Matt Cullen and Kunitz, perhaps it bears revisiting why Sullivan has been hesitant to use Kessel with Crosby.

Advertise with us

“Our experience as a staff has been that there hasn’t been a ton of chemistry between the two when they have been together,” Sullivan said. “We have thrown them together at times. We also believe that, when we do separate them, we tend to create better balance amongst our group that makes us more difficult to play against.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.